Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 27th Sep 2024 Written Update and EDT - Page 23

Episode Discussion

Created

Last reply

Replies

243

Views

12.7k

Users

39

Likes

881

Frequent Posters

Aadi04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3

Team Critics

Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Sparkle232

This track making me remember ghum 1. There too they made Sai's infertility all about virat. Sai faced miscarriage and infertility. When doctor announced her problem, he legit left her in doctor's room, started distancing himself from her, stopped sharing room with her, never consoled her. Seeing his behaviour, she told him he can remarry for baby for which he was like I want baby only with you as if he didn't treat her as shit after knowing about her infertility.

Here also it's all about what armaan wants. He is crying buckets for getting called stepson while the woman who got called worser names is consoling him.



Virat was not desperate for a child he wanted his children with Sai .

He had big hopes that his child will be his waaris .. both parents were hoping to make one kid a doctor and the other a police officer ( typical Indian parents)

He always told savi you will be a big police officer and make me proud ..


That’s why he jumped for surrogacy .. but never tried for another baby .. when he was married to pakhi believing Sai to be dead .. as if he had premonition any child with anyone else will be nalayak only

Sparkle232 thumbnail
Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: sweet_tania

Lekin Pakhi, Kaku all had very much character consistency throughout the show unlike this show.

Pakhi ka character subah different raat ko different aisa nahi hota tha jaise yeh log yaha dikha rahe hai iss show mai.

Kanu ka character consistency was way more than Kaveri Poddar. Sirf kaku he nahi Karishma vagera ka character consistency kafi better tha iss show se.

Yaha toh subah se raat ka bhi character consistency maintain nahi kar paate hai characters ke liye so trp bhi kaha se ayegi!

Ghum 1 was toxic but character consistency was way better than this show. Yaha toh main supporting cast ka bhi 0 character consistency hai and leads ka bhi 0 character consistency hai.

2 nights back Armaan ka character was like maa baap kisi se fark nahi padta, bhag kar mandir mai shaddi karne ko ready tha, house key tak ready tha and 2 din baat hayeeee meri maaaa kar ke roye ja raha hai smiley8

They were inconsistent too.

Pakhi also got whitewashed.

She was ready to move on with samrat but post samrat's death she was like I want virat back.

Chavans were equally toxic & inconsistent if not more. Kaku told virat to feed his bhabi with his hands, whole family encouraged virat to go with pakhi to trip while having problem when sai joined them.

Sometimes kaku indirectly ships virat pakhi then suddenly acts nice towards sai, Sai's father in law about to slap her but gets whitewashed when sai brought him some gift then again turned jerk. Sai's mother in law is just double standard character, she always brainwashed sai into accepting her son's abuse. Then treated her as worse in Shruti track when it was her son who projected infront of everyone that he married other woman.

Here atleast ruhi got slapped but in ghum pakhi slapped sai many times, pakhi never got slapped, when sai was about to slap her, virat stopped her.

nutmeg7 thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

Exactly. Exactly. While they may not take the surrogacy route, I still see triangle revival later on. They haven’t closed the infertility angle.

Edited by nutmeg7 - a day ago
Drna7 thumbnail
Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Anniversary 4 Thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

They should better focus on Ab's career growth upsetting poddars just like suhasini was bitter when naira had upper hand over kartik. Instead of rinse and repeating same Ab clashing with Dadisa or repeating ghum storyline.

Edited by Drna7 - a day ago
Aadi04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3

Team Critics

Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Sparkle232

@bold how 😭? By showing only one egg is left with sai to make them do surrogacy process without mother's consent later on making sai pregnant after declaring she has 0 eggssmiley24

Sai was slapped 3-4 times by pakhi during her pregnancy while all family members watching it live silently.



Yes they were stupid .. but that slapping incident happened after samrat had died saving Sai ..


If samrat had stayed at home to do gulu gulu with pakhi .. he would be having kids with her ..



The track was stretched to show torture by jagtap , trauma and guilt due to Samrat’s death .. leading to a mental breakdown which lead to sai’s miscarriage .



They showed her being admitted to hospital . Later in Counselors was shown ..


It was not decided by random blood test done at home with a gynaecologist like it is done here.. during Sangeet .. results declared in Mehndi and then shadi .


These 2 have not even gone for a second opinion .. they have not even done the deed

Edited by Aadi04 - a day ago
Aadi04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3

Team Critics

Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Drna7

They should better focus on Ab's career growth upsetting poddars just like suhasini was bitter when naira had upper hand over kartik. Instead of rinse and repeating same Ab clashing with Dadisa or repeating ghum storyline.


They should start the Manish Goenka reveal track . Let it be done and stretched anthem other tracks brought in including infertility and it’s solution

Sparkle232 thumbnail
Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Aadi04



Yes they were stupid .. but that slapping incident happened after samrat had died saving Sai ..


If samrat had stayed at home to do gulu gulu with pakhi .. he would be having kids with her ..



The track was stretched to show torture by jagtap , trauma and guilt due to Samrat’s death .. leading to a mental breakdown which lead to sai’s miscarriage .



They showed her being admitted to hospital . Later in Counselors was shown ..


It was not decided by random blood test done at home with a gynaecologist like it is done here

That I agree. They showed why she faced miscarriage and infertility but never addressed her pain.

That whole surrogacy track virat wanting to choose his ex to surrogate his baby, doing surrogacy process without Sai's consent, keeping sai away from pakhi during her pregnancy time by believing pakhi words that sai will harm that kid. At last snatching kid from sai to give it to pakhi. Very cruel.

Aadi04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3

Team Critics

Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

Manish Goenka made tea for Suwarna in yesterday’s episode


He was just looking for an excuse to talk to his grand child privately .. his track n mind is on Abhira only

Drna7 thumbnail
Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Anniversary 4 Thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Sparkle232

They were inconsistent too.

Pakhi also got whitewashed.

She was ready to move on with samrat but post samrat's death she was like I want virat back.

Chavans were equally toxic & inconsistent if not more. Kaku told virat to feed his bhabi with his hands, whole family encouraged virat to go with pakhi to trip while having problem when sai joined them.

Sometimes kaku indirectly ships virat pakhi then suddenly acts nice towards sai, Sai's father in law about to slap her but gets whitewashed when sai brought him some gift then again turned jerk. Sai's mother in law is just double standard character, she always brainwashed sai into accepting her son's abuse. Then treated her as worse in Shruti track when it was her son who projected infront of everyone that he married other woman.

Here atleast ruhi got slapped but in ghum pakhi slapped sai many times, pakhi never got slapped, when sai was about to slap her, virat stopped her.


The worst was him giving their son to didi and bringing her back from jail even after repeatedly saying he loves Sai. Only saving grace was Sai was not mahaan nor forgives easily.

If not for high level kaleshi entertainment it provided ghum was worst way worst and deserved no trp.

Aadi04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3

Team Critics

Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Sparkle232

That I agree. They showed why she faced miscarriage and infertility but never addressed her pain.

That whole surrogacy track virat wanting to choose his ex to surrogate his baby, doing surrogacy process without Sai's consent, keeping sai away from pakhi during her pregnancy time by believing pakhi words that sai will harm that kid. At last snatching kid from sai to give it to pakhi. Very cruel.


Yes but over here it is down right stupid .. they have not even consummated the marriage .. and people are doing RR in infertility..

and who decides infertility on a blood test .. even poor people buy a tkt from udaipur .. go to Delhi aims or some where in Mumbai to show themselves to a better doctor in a big hospital

This is ridiculous


Unless Abhira was diagnosed with life threatening disease or something this type of crying made no sense

Edited by Aadi04 - a day ago
Top