Just watched the episode.
i am under no illusion that the love story of Jhanak & Ani is a tough one. Love in itself is not easy and add to that the complexity of one that has had a very arduous path. So one expects the lovers to undergo painful situations before the love can triumph.
If Ani and Jhanak had been a real life pair, I am fairly certain that it would have combusted one way or the other.. and misgivings would have been aired, they would have fought and accusations would have flown freely and if they found it worth it to be with each other their love may have survived.
Now coming to the episode, I wonder if the writers chose catharsis as the theme of the episode. What Jhanak said to and of Ani today, when wanting to put an end to the relationshipโฆ do writers think relationships have the power to withstand such vitriol, hate and tongue lashing? If they want the protagonist to show the mirror to the other, I wish they had the courage to also not sugarcoat it with that monologue. Today, if the monologue hadnโt been there, I would have merely considered it the outpouring of grief of a person who had loved and lost. There was a powerful scene today when Ani says ILY, when Jhanak moves away almost in disgustโฆthe pain of the older ILY would have surely jolted her.. I wish there was a flashback of that scene and it would have made sense. Jhanak went full throttle and for the jugular not sparing Ani. If the monologue wasnโt there I would have found it powerful coz at least it would have told me of the pain in her heart was getting the catharsis it perhaps deserved. But after all that, there was the monologue that was supposed to be a balm but it provided no relief. Why? Coz as a viewer, I couldnโt relate to that monologue at all. I wish they had worded the monologue differently. To say I know you have given your heart to me and so now I will rip inp it into pieces seemed brutal
For me, all through I understood why Jhanak never found it possible to encourage Ani in any wayโฆ it was her issue in how she saw the situation but I also thought Jhanak knew that tooโฆI felt Jhanak took responsibility for that decision. Even if she desired more, whose fault is it today that they arenโt together, hers, his or both? I thought she saw it as both but today it gave me an impression that Jhanak felt it was Aniโs fault alone, they werenโt together when the truth was even if Ani would have broken up with Arshi, Jhanak would have never been with Ani.
I was conflicted today on whether I misread that Jhanak.The writers canโt give such dialogues to her and then try to whitewash it with that stupid monologue. Here, the issue isnโt that the monologue wanted to make the case for moving away. There were other ways to move away. The writers chose this brutal mode for a purpose. If it was to show Ani the mirror,โฆ was that mirror shown by Jhanak completely honest? Did Jhanak think that Do naav ki savari ( that phrase came in today from an unlikely source Lal) Ani ki fitrat hain? Ya majboori?
I wish writers donโt write character traits to be used as plot devices at will.
Ani canโt come home to think that Jhanak has rejected him without paying attention to what she told him. She accused him of having poor character.. Ani, can you choose a Naav and stick to it to prove Jhanak wrong? If you canโt choose a naav, can we get a glimpse of why you canโtโฆ
things have come to a headโฆ it high they resolve it one way or the other.. ab isse pyaar kehne main darr lagta hain
Edited by sanfan - 1 months ago
comment:
p_commentcount