Tabaah Ho Gaye - Kalank | Madhuri Dixit | Shreya Ghoshal | Pritam - Page 6

Bad choreo, rhythm and the shoddy camerawork is taking away from Madhuri's dance. If you see Bhansali's work in Devdas, the camera used to be still to capture the dance perfectly, I am talking about Maar daala and Kahe ched mohe here, very slow moving shots and camerawork. Here it is all over the place and is just creating a haphazard experience.

that is the reason why I always say Madhuri was never a great actor to begin with.
Massively popular, possibly the biggest female star ever if we take only peak, but as an actor. Nah.
An above average actor with few good actual acting performances here and there, a image of being hot and sweet at same time, while also being a great seductive dancer with a beautiful smile.

She has the television actress expressions whenever she has to express sadness and pain.
And I can't take that seriously.Edited by Thug-Leader - 5 years ago

Madhuri is a wonderful dancer. Think "ke sara sara for instance. She easily matched prabhu deva. But there is only so much one can do with a terrible song and choreography.

They should have stuck to shankar, ehsaan, loy if they wanted semi classical numbers. And I repeat, this film is more subhash ghai than Bhansali. Edited by hedwig_fawkes - 5 years ago

This is saroj khan choreography alright

The conspiracy theory of Kjo doing everything to make Madhuri dull😆.. For god sake its his late Dads ambitious project.. And he is spending crores for it  Why would he compromise with his project for Alias sake.. If anything Kjo loves tge most apart from himself, its money.

Originally posted by: Thug-Leader

that is the reason why I always say Madhuri was never a great actor to begin with.
Massively popular, possibly the biggest female star ever if we take only peak, but as an actor. Nah.
An above average actor with few good actual acting performances here and there, a image of being hot and sweet at same time, while also being a great seductive dancer with a beautiful smile.

Edited by dedh - 5 years ago

Sad for MD. She accepted this role without thinking how Papa Beti pair is on the spree to make everyone look bad except Beti..!!

Originally posted by: ponymo

^The above post should answer your question, @rbpll. Youtube comments are mostly positive because they are heavily moderated for negative comments unlike I-F which is a bit liberal - which is why it seems like it is a cesspool of negativity 😆

@OT: Bad song with awful, awkward steps. Shreya's voice doesn't suit Madhuri. Should have got someone like Madhushree or Rekha Bhardwaj to sing for her. Madhuri looks especially bad in those closeups though. It isn't the fact that she's older. Something weird that I can't seem to put my finger on.

Madhuri can't dance, Madhuri is an overrated dancer, Alia is better. What else is left to say? Vo bhi bol do

Originally posted by: dedh

Couldn't think of a post which gets it more wrong. Madhuri's power has always resided in the variety of expressions. Her dance numbers are like concentrations of those expressions. There's nothing mediocre about her as either an actor or a dancer. Even when the song is subpar (like here), even if the voice doesn't fit (and it hurts me to say that because Shreya's voice is beautiful - it just doesn't fit this song), even if the camera work is trashy, Madhuri still delivers. She's absolutely on point in that fragment of the song.

😆 Madhuri is epitome of what you call the typical filmy actress. And that is why she always failed to give an acting performance which will be talked for ages and seen as an acting master class. She is your typical commercial Bollywood filmy actress whose flaws are hidden under the delusional and imaginative ''adah'', ''nazakat'', ''grace'' bullshit people put every time to put the older actresses in pedestal as their actual acting is mostly above average to good.
Her expression and emoting is your typical television actress OTT acting, which is all outer supported than an internalize truth. Anyways it is not my interest to change your opinion, or put my opinion through your throat, so it is okay for both of us to think different way and have our own opinions. You enjoy yourself thinking whatever you think about Madhuri, I will think, what feel about Madhuri.