🌸 Jhanak Plot and Character Analysis, Creative Writeups Thread 1 🌸 - Page 37

yeh totally get that ... but i guess i explained it was for the feel from J's perspective ... he is hero for us all in all

Originally posted by: MayaFruitbae

I dont have any issue if all the people felt same and I felt different . Its upto different perspective. I kept only my part . In your post the main highlight for me was that Anirudh was like a side character ,which was not convincing for me. So I replied on that.

Originally posted by: MayaFruitbae

Its beautiful analysis and loved how you wrote in detail about all the characters. You connected it so well with previous incidents too.

For me Anirudh wasnt like a side character at all , it was a place where he just came into and cant suddenly show his rights on a girl . And with Aditya it was more of a confrontation which stunned Anirudh .

Did Anirudh feel like he is not the most important character in Jhanak's life , I believe he would have felt left out from the situation , of what has happened and what is happening in Jhanak's life at the moment. He wouldn't have felt that his place is less or more or replaced by someone else. He cant be replaced in her life at all. His word of I am the most important .....back then is right , nobody in asylum matter to her more than him. He saved her life and that cant be sidelined just because an Aditya took charge of the scene now.

Anirudh had helped her when she had no one with her and he always wanted someone to be with her when he cant help her. His match making with Rahul too was a result of this thought , a support for Jhanak. Now when he is seeing her after long days , and sees her surrounded with supporters why would he feel not important in her life. Aditya presence might irk him as for him Aditya is not a good man , he read a lot of gossip about him , so he may be cautious .

For me , the entire episode was centered round Anirudh , his concern, his eagerness , anxiety above all the controlled expressions in the presence of Arshi and Shristi. He was not a side character , just because Aditya took charge of the scene. Aditya mouthed few dialogues which would be a mirror to Anirudh . He would bring out the emotions which he has buried within himself after Jhanak left . His concern might sound odd to people because they dont know about their relation , but does that make him a side character .

Aditya too doesnt have any relation to Jhanak other than they had done an ad together and now he helped her with dance . If that is the measure of importance then Anirudh contribution in Jhanak life is immeasurable .Aditya who is now mouthing to be the greatest supporter of Jhanak itself is Anirudh's contribution.

But certainly I dont know why such double meaning dialogues are being thrown at Anirudh character by the writers , be it through Aditya or Bipasha . Aren't they quite sure about what their character is or their show is.🙏🏻

Maya,

I am yet to watch the episode so can’t fully comment this way or that about how the execution is from my perspective
writers when they place the scene have to always check for how does the scene comes through on the aspect of impact.

When they have decided to place Ani in a situation where he is unable to react, they cannot ignore that Ani will as per his nature feel constrained so the scene impact must take care of it…. If the viewers remain confused on the impact it is poor writing and worse poor execution

So this long winded discussion scene should have been avoided and focus should have been on the aspect of who takes her to hospital etc

The competition rules discussions should have been crisper and Ani’s reactions received more focus. The other nonsense aspects could have been done in a separate scene. The impact of a single flashback of Jhanak’s past hospital scene would have been enough to juxtapose Ani of the past and Ani of the present. The emotion of care being the same but the constraints of his situation not lost on the viewers

for instance the episode when they first met they had a scene of Arshi, Ani, Brij fellow, Shristi in a huddle where one scene prior they show Jhanak across the aisle but her reaction or presence in the background is completed omitted. What? Was she touching up her makeup for the next dance after just meeting Ani face to face!! Total killing of impact!!
I want to just to whack the editors!! Then the RP and Jhanak scene and no awareness from Ani? Wtf!! Very poorly done!! For me the episode yesterday was very underwhelming.. despite some great dance performance

Now coming to Adi’s importance it is situational but it’s irks us and it is meant to irk us with all those dialogues becos someone rooting for Runak will feel the immediate pain… You have said above, how can their role be compared… true but by making a choice to align with Arshi, there would be a price to pay ( irrespective of how that situation came about and we can have our views about it) but one unassailable fact remains that the maryada Or thresholds of that bondage make him an outsider.

But like you say I don’t know how much they will butcher Ani to bring in the drama

Sidelining Ani does not serve any purpose so my worry isn’t that Ani will become less important; on the contrary he will become more important now on

Originally posted by: vira76

yeh totally get that ... but i guess i explained it was for the feel from J's perspective ... he is hero for us all in all

Now after writing this back to back , its clear .

i think this one will be the hardest path Ani will have to walk on ....

Some lessons are learned the hard way! But I am looking forward to that journey. hope they make it into a journey though , sab hype create karake in the end i dont want to see him again making same decisions. But for reason whenever i think about it , i feel makers might disappoint us again in terms of Ani's journey... if this is not the track for that purpose

Originally posted by: MayaFruitbae

I will take it as he is being shown the same path as how she felt when he ignored her . They always have done that . The same for both on many things.

From now on it should be his journey .

Not this side character and Aditya being hero or whatever word it is..

Originally posted by: vira76

i think this one will be the hardest path Ani will have to walk on ....

Some lessons are learned the hard way! But I am looking forward to that journey. hope they make it into a journey though , sab hype create karake in the end i dont want to see him again making same decisions. But for reason whenever i think about it , i feel makers might disappoint us again in terms of Ani's journey... if this is not the track for that purpose

True , we experience this in all tracks ... We expect something and they end up with totally different twist and shocks ..🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

Purple- This I agree to , except the concern that remains as you correctly put it - ' I don’t know how much they will butcher Ani to bring in the drama'

Coz giving Ani the required character learning curve, does not dwell well with the makers target of a 1000 epi s ! Letting Ani be, the way he is, and making him act accordingly, is a sure shot recipe for a 1000 !

Originally posted by: sanfan

Maya,

I am yet to watch the episode so can’t fully comment this way or that about how the execution is from my perspective
writers when they place the scene have to always check for how does the scene comes through on the aspect of impact.

When they have decided to place Ani in a situation where he is unable to react, they cannot ignore that Ani will as per his nature feel constrained so the scene impact must take care of it…. If the viewers remain confused on the impact it is poor writing and worse poor execution

So this long winded discussion scene should have been avoided and focus should have been on the aspect of who takes her to hospital etc

The competition rules discussions should have been crisper and Ani’s reactions received more focus. The other nonsense aspects could have been done in a separate scene. The impact of a single flashback of Jhanak’s past hospital scene would have been enough to juxtapose Ani of the past and Ani of the present. The emotion of care being the same but the constraints of his situation not lost on the viewers

for instance the episode when they first met they had a scene of Arshi, Ani, Brij fellow, Shristi in a huddle where one scene prior they show Jhanak across the aisle but her reaction or presence in the background is completed omitted. What? Was she touching up her makeup for the next dance after just meeting Ani face to face!! Total killing of impact!!
I want to just to whack the editors!! Then the RP and Jhanak scene and no awareness from Ani? Wtf!! Very poorly done!! For me the episode yesterday was very underwhelming.. despite some great dance performance

Now coming to Adi’s importance it is situational but it’s irks us and it is meant to irk us with all those dialogues becos someone rooting for Runak will feel the immediate pain… You have said above, how can their role be compared… true but by making a choice to align with Arshi, there would be a price to pay ( irrespective of how that situation came about and we can have our views about it) but one unassailable fact remains that the maryada Or thresholds of that bondage make him an outsider.

But like you say I don’t know how much they will butcher Ani to bring in the drama

Sidelining Ani does not serve any purpose so my worry isn’t that Ani will become less important; on the contrary he will become more important now on

well said Rekha... it meant to irk us and Ani ... and it did lol, I feel it will be all worth it if Ani learns his lesson and if there is some change and progress... I love scenes where Jhanak and Ani are asked difficult questions. I like honest portrayals, raw and unfiltered. I don't like scenes where, "chezo pe parda dale"... I want to see their weak sides, where they lack so when they comes out of it, that moment feels that special. So for me, when Ani was being put in place by Aditya, it was the most enjoyable thing ever. He was asking questions on the viewers' behalf. So I don't like to take the character assassination route at least for this episode...

iTV makers can be inconsistent as hell, so it certainly feels like they are butchering the character... For instance the room scene. I agree with you in terms of execution, I was thinking the whole time why no one talking about taking Jhanak to the hospital. It reminded me of the time when Jhanak tried to commit suicide. If it was an emergency situation at that time, how is it not an emergency situation now? That scene was added just to show Arshi with Ani, so Adi sees them together, Arshi going to the hospital did not make sense.. so they added this crap... But thinking this all could have been done on the stage ... Shrsiti took Adi's place as a special judge, so we needed to guess Adi was not present in the Auditorium and probably came later on hearing about Jhanak news... iTV makers don't think this far though. They work 365 days a year and this is bound to happen. The impact of the scene is all that matters. So, we need to ignore these things for our sanity lol and only keep story line in mind , that's the lesson i have learned

Originally posted by: sanfan

Maya,

I am yet to watch the episode so can’t fully comment this way or that about how the execution is from my perspective
writers when they place the scene have to always check for how does the scene comes through on the aspect of impact.

When they have decided to place Ani in a situation where he is unable to react, they cannot ignore that Ani will as per his nature feel constrained so the scene impact must take care of it…. If the viewers remain confused on the impact it is poor writing and worse poor execution

So this long winded discussion scene should have been avoided and focus should have been on the aspect of who takes her to hospital etc

The competition rules discussions should have been crisper and Ani’s reactions received more focus. The other nonsense aspects could have been done in a separate scene. The impact of a single flashback of Jhanak’s past hospital scene would have been enough to juxtapose Ani of the past and Ani of the present. The emotion of care being the same but the constraints of his situation not lost on the viewers

for instance the episode when they first met they had a scene of Arshi, Ani, Brij fellow, Shristi in a huddle where one scene prior they show Jhanak across the aisle but her reaction or presence in the background is completed omitted. What? Was she touching up her makeup for the next dance after just meeting Ani face to face!! Total killing of impact!!
I want to just to whack the editors!! Then the RP and Jhanak scene and no awareness from Ani? Wtf!! Very poorly done!! For me the episode yesterday was very underwhelming.. despite some great dance performance

Now coming to Adi’s importance it is situational but it’s irks us and it is meant to irk us with all those dialogues becos someone rooting for Runak will feel the immediate pain… You have said above, how can their role be compared… true but by making a choice to align with Arshi, there would be a price to pay ( irrespective of how that situation came about and we can have our views about it) but one unassailable fact remains that the maryada Or thresholds of that bondage make him an outsider.

But like you say I don’t know how much they will butcher Ani to bring in the drama

Sidelining Ani does not serve any purpose so my worry isn’t that Ani will become less important; on the contrary he will become more important now on

I honestly feel this time as well Ani character graph wont change...

we will ask these questions to each other later on ... oh so why did he not realize this during the time in Mumbai and why only now lol 🤪

isaka ek hi jawab hai.. because makers did not want him to realize

Originally posted by: rysohini

Purple- This I agree to , except the concern that remains as you correctly put it - ' I don’t know how much they will butcher Ani to bring in the drama'

Coz giving Ani the required character learning curve, does not dwell well with the makers target of a 1000 epi s ! Letting Ani be, the way he is, and making him act accordingly, is a sure shot recipe for a 1000 !

Great analysis Vira, Maya, Anum and Rekha.

Purple - My only worry is, I have not seen Ani take feedback gracefully, accept and act on it , to make himself better ! And when the feedback comes from some one like Adi, I have lesser hopes from Ani, understanding and accepting that every thing that Adi said today is the truth !

Ani's mind voice atm might be for Adi - Tumne mujhe mirror dikhaya aur maine maan li ? Pehle batao tum hote kaun ho mujhe mirror dikhane wale?

I have said this before and I say this again, till we see a positive character growth in Ani, where he 'accepts' his flaws and works to improve on them, any no. of times that RuNak meets, it will render no positive outcome !

Also, leaving Ani the way he is and letting him act the way he does, brings in the required drama and moves the narrative forward , so where is the motivation for the makers to bring in a change in Ani?

The entire reason why Ani flip flops and remains conveniently non-committal is to ensure that RuNak does not happen, for the longest time possible !

Originally posted by: vira76

Episode - 263

Anirudh - the experience of being not the most important guy

Today for the first time Anirudh felt what it would feel like to become not the most important person in Jhanak's life. He claimed in the past confidently during her marriage with Avinash, "The Haq" over Jhanak. "iss pure ghar me sabase zyada important main hoon tumhare liye! isake piche ka karan tum samaz to ho!"

He saved her life many times risking his own, and there is a saying...

"Jab koi aapki jaan bachata hai, to aapki zindagi sirf aapki nahi reh jaati"
"When someone saves your life, your life no longer just belongs to you."

But now the situation is different... he has bound himself in a relationship!

He promised Jhanak he would always be there for her even after his marriage on the day of his birthday. But neither did he realize the weight of his words at that time, nor did he imagine such a day to come.

Today, a lot of people felt like Anirdh was a side character and Adi was the hero. But truth be told, he is in that position and that is why he came out like a side character. That was the intention.

Anirudh is a "Main Sambhal lunga" guy! He has the answer for everything, he has a plan for everything, he knows how to escape a situation quickly, he knows how to think quickly on his feet, he was always the most intelligent guy in the room, people failed to see through him... but now he is in a situation where there is someone who is able to see through him.

He wants to take care of things again for Jhanak and do everything he can, but look how tables have turned ... Jhanak suddenly has supporters, and people who are looking out for her. He always wanted to be the first one to be there for Jhanak, if he ever she needs him. That is the role he imagined to play, but today he was not getting to play that as well...

There were a lot of firsts for Ani Bose today! A lot ...

He wanted to go to the room where Doctor was -- he had to manipulate Arshi to be able to do that

He wanted to pay for Jhanak's medical expenses -- event management will be taking care of that

He wanted to be the one to take Jhanak to the hospital -- Aditya was the one arranging that

He wanted to stay at the hospital with Jhanak -- But Aditya and Rudra both are staying there

The doctor's updates are going to Aditya first ...

He isn't free to stay in the hospital according to his will as now he is married ...

Some direct questions and taunts to Anirudh today that rendered him speechless... Aditya is bringing an outsider's perspective to this whole situation.

"Jhanka iss show me tumhare reference se aayi hai?" -- btw wrong time for curiosity but jealousy and insecurity have no time and place!
"Tum ye nahi janate ke Jhanak yaha kaise aayi hai?" -- There are now things about Jhanak he does not know about Jhanak now ...

"ya phir, shadi ke baad tumane zaroori nahi samaza ye kaha par hai kaha nahi?" -- truth hurts

"Are, tum kitano ko sambhalo go..." --- directly accusing him of bigamy?

"thank you for your concern, par aap Jhanak ke kya lagate hai?" -- first time he was asked who is he to help, he never had to answer anyone before to help Jhanak

First time Anirudh's concern was looking odd and out of place... it sounded odd to people why was he asking Aditya to go? He always told people, that he brought Jhanak and she was his responsibility. What excuse does he have now?

"Jo bhi rishta tha... "

"Jab Jhanak ko tumhari sabase zyada zaroorat thi tab tum usake liye nahi khade hue, ab yaha par kyu ho?"

"Kya sirf tum usaki phikr karate ho?"
"Ab koi aur to hai nahi usaki phikar karane ke liye?" --- Ani bose did you lose the right to worry about Jhanak also now?

"Jab koi bina bataye ghar se chala jaye to koi usaki madad kare bhi to kaise?" --- Ani looking here and there, he knows he did not look for Jhanak the way he should have!

"chitt bhi meri, part bhi meri!" -- another accusation of bigamy! "The letter (or note) is mine, and the deed (or document) is also mine"

"Tum Jhanak ki zimmedari lena chahate ho, lekin kis haq se, kya lagati hai wo tumhari?Kya rishta hai tum dono ka, i mean paper me tum kya likho get, kya sign karogo" ...

Sorry one minute... let me first laugh on the side and laugh on this for a minute

-- Uff, ye kya bol diya Ani Bose? Yaar khud ke liye jal kab se bunane lage? The same question applies to you... Ani Bose and his love for zimmedari of Jhanak, is there a rival in town?

"Tum Jhanak ko har chuke ho..." -- this was a knife in his heart

You know, surely for this one episode Anirudh felt like a side character to all of us in Jhanak's life but that is exactly what he has become.

But some lessons are learned through experience... "Laato ke bhoot bato se nahi manate..."

This was in no way a character assassination. Today we and Ani, simply heard things that were bitter truths. We already knew these things. The first step of any kind of change is to accept the truth.

It will be interesting to see how Ani Bose will handle the challenges he always thought he would gladly face ... being the one looking at Jhanak from afar, being happy for her even when she moves on while staying true to his responsibilities!

yes, and they won't show more than one major outcome, so I have very low expectations at least for Ani... he gonna take punches and not punch back in return

Originally posted by: MayaFruitbae

True , we experience this in all tracks ... We expect something and they end up with totally different twist and shocks ..🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️