Sardar Udham
This movie deserved every accolade it got. Vicky Kaushal gives a haunting performance as Udham Singh. Even when he is not saying a word, the pain in his eyes, his steely resolve, and his determination, it's all so beautifully portrayed.
I was not ready for that climax. It really cut me. I know what happened at Jalianwala Bagh. I've read about it so many times in history textbooks. But I couldn't have imagined the brutality and gore. Movie depictions tend to gloss over the massacre - perhaps to manage audience reactions/avoid adult ratings for violence. But I am glad Shoojit Sircar didn't hold back. I think we all need a reminder of the atrocities of colonization and the bloodshed before our freedom.
The movie also shed light on how many Sikhs fought and died in WWI and WWII for the British, a fact often forgotten by many. Some of the details were new to me to like the illegal immigration pipeline through Russia, the relationship between some elements of HSRA and IRA, and the solidarity with labor movements.
I am usually critical of non-linear narratives and feel Bollywood movies are indulgent with their run times. But I have no problems with the editing or narrative style on this one. The narrative works and despite the two-plus hour length - I couldn't find much that should have been chopped. The climax could perhaps have been crisper - but seeing the trauma Udham endured is absolutely necessary for the film to linger with you and remind you not to take freedom for granted.
Also, the excuse of anti-British sentiment for not sending the film to the Oscars is such a load of bull. Unlike RRR which is bullish and resorts to British caricatures - Sardar Udham makes a clear distinction between colonizers and civilians. On multiple occasions, Udham Singh clarifies that he doesn't hate the British only the colonizing powers that commit atrocities.
It was also refreshing to see a movie without caricatures and stereotypes about Punjabis or British.
comment:
p_commentcount