Anupama Chopra lambasts Simmba rape plot, Rohit Shetty calls her 'pseu

MsAmazing thumbnail
Group Promotion 1 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#1

Anupama Chopra lambasts Simmba rape plot, Rohit Shetty calls her 'pseudo-intellectual'


Rohit Shetty's Simmba starring Ranveer Singh and Sara Ali Khan has not only been making new records at the box office but has also emerged as the biggest commercial film of 2018. 

Ranveer Singh's performance as Simmba has been lauded by many and Sara Khan's freshness is like a breath of fresh air onscreen.

While a majority of the critics have hailed the film with many stars, critic Anupama Chopra hasn't entirely been convinced with the plot. Talking about the 'rape scene' and the 'courtroom drama' in the film, Anupama felt like though Rohit's intentions were great but it appeared in the film that it was all done and shown only to serve the men.

She added that not only all the women were in relationship to Simmba, even the female judge was emotionally blackmailed into taking a decision. She also pointed out how in the end, a female judge blamed another female a mother for something a man did which made the entire matter of 'rape' in the film seem just as a lip service and not heartfelt.

In conversation with the critic, Rohit Shetty, totally declined her accusations. He said that it was his point of view that some strict and tough action should be taken by the cops in his film to create a terror among those who do such a thing. He also added that the judge blamed the mother of 'Durva' as his father had died long back. However, the judge had added towards the end that both 'maa' and 'baap' are responsible.

Making a stance clearer, Rohit Shetty said, "Today, I don't need an issue like rape to make a film hit. I have proven 13 films, 8 a 100 crore, 2 a 200 crore, this one is going for a 100 crore. I am sitting with 10 blockbusters and I don't need such a pathetic thing to do, that's wrong."

However, when Anupama asked him whether he is able to see where the criticism is coming from, Rohit replied, "You are one, who is saying about this and 2-3 people who have written about this. Other than that, if this was the case, there are so many women calling, there are so many women writing on Twitter, they are not feeling it like that. I think they are not analysing it, but are just getting entertained."

Getting a little defensive on the topic, Rohit also said that the film and the encounter was his point of view and he doesn't care about what few pseudo-intellectuals would write.

Ouch! That's some kadak statement.

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2653

Users

12

Likes

41

Frequent Posters

Maroonporsche thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#2
Anupama is nothing but mouthpiece of select few. Now that they are becoming irrelevant themselves she is doing anything to stay in the news πŸ˜†πŸ˜†
Hindi film critics cant even speak hindi πŸ˜†πŸ˜†
hedwig_fawkes thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#3
Rohit is clearly sexist. 
Pain-in-ur-Neck thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#4
Difference in both is Anupama and few others are criticizing the movie while he is "name calling" them! ... Speaks a lot about Rohit Shetty! .. 
Posted: 5 years ago
#5
The whole message of the movie was that Parents should teach their sons to respect women yet she finds a fault in that but remained tightlipped about a movie where having sex with 350 is shown as an achievement
Maroonporsche thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AhmadZahir

The whole message of the movie was that Parents should teach their sons to respect women yet she finds a fault in that but remained tightlipped about a movie where having sex with 350 is shown as an achievement


She's a hypocrite and has a bad accent

An for someone who has a talk show she isnt very attractive πŸ˜†πŸ˜†πŸ˜†
Posted: 5 years ago
#7
Anyone who criticizes a masala movie automatically becomes a "pseudo-intellectual" according to some people, and most abused word during these type of arguments is "entertainment". Well, if the movie is just for entertainment and you don't want the audience to take it seriously, then don't include such serious issues like rape  or have any preaching in your movie. Sorry Rohit Shetty, it's your problem if you are confused between wanting to entertain the audience or want to give a social message. If you want to do both then do it properly otherwise you are bound to be criticized.
And the way he's boasting about his 100 and 200 Crore films, either success has gone over his head or he's finally showing his true colours.
Edited by Luna46 - 5 years ago
Posted: 5 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: DragonBoy49


She's a hypocrite and has a bad accent

An for someone who has a talk show she isnt very attractive πŸ˜†πŸ˜†πŸ˜†


I like the other woman on Film Companion more than her. Does she have a talk show as well? Suchitra or whatever is her name doesn't speak only in English, she does it in Hindi/Urdu as well.
Pain-in-ur-Neck thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Luna46

Anyone who criticizes a masala movie automatically becomes a "pseudo-intellectual" according to some people, and most abused word during these type of arguments is "entertainment". Well, if the movie is just for entertainment and you don't want the audience to take it seriously, then don't include such serious issues like rape  or have any preaching in your movie. Sorry Rohit Shetty, it's your problem if you are confused between wanting to entertain the audience or want to give a social message. If you want to do both then you are bound to be criticized.

And the way he's boasting about his 100 and 200 Crore films, either success has gone over his head or he's finally showing his true colours.


So true .. Oxymoronic stand of the movie! ... On one hand calls the movie "entertainer" .. But how can one even take the major plot-line, "rape", as entertaining?!... Calling Simmba an entertainer with "rape revenge" as it's basis is a bit sickening! ... Call it anything else but don't tag the movie "entertaining" when it's dealing with suffering of rape victims!
Maroonporsche thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: AhmadZahir


 Suchitra or whatever is her name doesn't speak only in English, she does it in Hindi/Urdu as well.


That girl is funny and cute. She just makes fun of every film and its hilarious πŸ˜†