Round 2: Shreya Ghoshal - Page 5

Originally posted by: ssk13809

How do I know she can't sing that type of song? Maybe because she never has. Can you show me any song, live or recorded, where Shreya sang any song similar to that one? I mean, sure she probably can sing it, in a literal sense, but sing it well enough for her voice to be used in playback singing for that type of song?

Nope

As I said I do not want to get in a debate with you so I would prefer not to answer your question but if anyone else wants to do it then feel free to do so...

Originally posted by: --Rachna--

As I said I do not want to get in a debate with you so I would prefer not to answer your question but if anyone else wants to do it then feel free to do so...

There is no debate. Shreya hasn't sung songs like that. End of debate.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

I don't agree at all. After all, Sunidhi Chauhan is the self-proclaimed "Most Versatile Female Singer in India" . And rightfully so. Shreya can't do a Dhoom Machale, she can't do a Aisa Jadoo, and the list goes on. She can't do any explosive song period.

Just the way it would sound awful if sunidhi sang 'teri ore'

An excellent song by shreya composed by none other than ARR
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5xothA560KM[/YOUTUBE]
Edited by p@ras - 14 years ago

Originally posted by: p@ras

Just the way it would sound awful if sunidhi sang 'teri ore'

Not really. See "Mere Haath Mein" from Faana

Isnt this Shreya's thread where we should be discussing Shreya..why all the topics end up as a comparison topic between singers?

None can compare legends. Its immature to do so!!

When some Music Director has to record a song like 'Aisa Jadoo", they are going to first think of Sunidhi and if they want to record a song like 'Goonji si hai" Shreya would be the singer of choice!! Edited by sunandshine - 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ssk13809

Not really. See "Mere Haath Mein" from Faana

We have to accept that shreya is good at romantic numbers and sunidhi in the fast and pop type...I think just like shreya cant sing the pop ones sunidhis voice matches better with the fast tracks and not soft tunes so they better stick to that and let us just enjoy the music

Originally posted by: ssk13809

I don't agree at all. After all, Sunidhi Chauhan is the self-proclaimed "Most Versatile Female Singer in India" . And rightfully so. Shreya can't do a Dhoom Machale, she can't do a Aisa Jadoo, and the list goes on. She can't do any explosive song period.

Edited by Hunk101 - 14 years ago

Polls are now closed!!!


Final Audience Avg: 9.6
Final Judges Avg: 8.5


Final Score: 9.1!!!
Edited by risingabove - 14 years ago