GHKPM & YHM Comparisons Thread - Page 4

Originally posted by: Rosh4rose

Oh I see

I never watched YHM that time I was addicted to " Meri Aashiqui Tum se Hi"

I will never ever watch another Ekrha serial either so 🤷 watch this no interest to watch old serials either 🤔....

This is the only one I used to watch ....

Every thing depends on TRP gang ; if they accept it will survive if not Ganja can do another mass murder

Ekta does this to everyone I see

You pick up one of her shows and become an ardent viewer of it, because in the beginning she just creates magic with the lead pair, and later on she'll just make you hate the whole existence of Indian TV

After YHM, I didn't pick up any show, let alone Ekta's, I just don't want to feel that all sweet things turning ashes in my mouth🙏

YHM forum was a very active forum, the episode analysis threads, rantings threads, episode discussion threads, fan fics, forum was so much fun. 90% of the members left after surrogacy track. Most of them didn't pick up any other show. Ekta just shooed off all of them.

Originally posted by: akipog

Ekta ruined that show by adding truck loads of toxic track . The only good thing was Shakti had good scope of acting nd a meaty role 2 perform nd d chem nd romance bwn IshVeer was electrifying. Yhm was too good until 350 epis it went downhill post that but still bearable till that hideous surrogacy nd leap track. I watched yhm until leap hppnd nd then I watched soap opera once Imlie was on air. I watched that show until Gashmeer was there . Since I'm a upsc aspirant cum working professional s2 attracted me but d day makers did away with that track I quit this show. After seeing few clips I decided to give s3 a try but it couldn't hold my attention as leads lack d spark nd chem of og nd d side chars r bland but I would still say s3 is miles better than Imlie post Gashmeer nd Hitesh nd Amyra is doing a fairly decent job compared to Fahmaan who has just 1 expression throughout the show. Bhavika nails emotional scenes but her foster mom scenes need more passion like that of Ishita. She's still stuck in her pre leap Savi mode while Hitesh nd Amyra almost blended well nd has improved a lot from b4 esp cutiepie Amyra she's slowly nd steadily improving.

Wow you have great goals 👏....I am so proud to read that you are trying UPSC ❤️

All the best 👍...No wonder you liked S 2

That " MATSH' taught me a lesson but luckily that show ended with 400 plus episodes without children

YHM was a super hit show right? Baby Amyra improved a lot ;...Savi character has lost original " kadak' self now becoming a " crying bechari" 😢....Ganja is too lazy to do any thing deviate a bit from OG so that viewers will have curiosity now every one knows the story since it was not a regional show ....

Really it is all writing ✍️ how they destroyed S2 same thing might happen again !

Originally posted by: --QUEEN--

Ekta does this to everyone I see

You pick up one of her shows and become an ardent viewer of it, because in the beginning she just creates magic with the lead pair, and later on she'll just make you hate the whole existence of Indian TV

After YHM, I didn't pick up any show, let alone Ekta's, I just don't want to feel that all sweet things turning ashes in my mouth🙏

YHM forum was a very active forum, the episode analysis threads, rantings threads, episode discussion threads, fan fics, forum was so much fun. 90% of the members left after surrogacy track. Most of them didn't pick up any other show. Ekta just shooed off all of them.

Totally agree with you 👍...I have gone through the same thing

That show " Ashique" was such a beautiful love story , It was " purely love story " ....half way Ektha destroyed every thing she created ...

Only good thing was it ended a way faster 😌

Originally posted by: akipog

Some family react like that nd the makers were highlighting that as well but as u pointed out ghum should have done away with that scene. These makers r blatantly copying yhm so how will they change this? The only addition ghum came with was the most insensitive nd vicious thing by making Jigar utter things like u won't b pregnant even if I do something so I can ra@e u that was outright disgusting nd vile as far as I remember yhm didn't have such kind of dialogues. Ghum ph r sadists nd thrives on toxicity orelse who will show such a track during Navratri. They could shown in like Savi single-handedly handling d situation like how she was doing b4 fbs of Kiran Savi Mama scenes nd Durga Maa symbolism would have added more impact instead these makers decided to copy paste the og. The slap was deliberately added to grab more eyeballs . Simmi was too naive there nd it's shown all through d show while this Tara looks more sophisticated nd educated than Simmi but yeah this ph can't do any creativity other than verbatim copy or omission of romance so can't say anything. The slap amounts to dv as well as physical torture as per dv act 2005 so yeah d ph is very insensitive nd will do nd add any dialogues to make Savi a bechari

The dialogue about Ishita not being able to be a mother was there too, YHM was extremely problematic and Ghum makers are too for copy pasting it

I am not able to explain the issue and you are keen on defending one show which is counterproductive because it is not about which drama is better, the issue is extremely sensitive. I am stopping discussion from my side here

Originally posted by: Rosh4rose

Wow you have great goals 👏....I am so proud to read that you are trying UPSC ❤️

All the best 👍...No wonder you liked S 2

That " MATSH' taught me a lesson but luckily that show ended with 400 plus episodes without children

YHM was a super hit show right? Baby Amyra improved a lot ;...Savi character has lost original " kadak' self now becoming a " crying bechari" 😢....Ganja is too lazy to do any thing deviate a bit from OG so that viewers will have curiosity now every one knows the story since it was not a regional show ....

Really it is all writing ✍️ how they destroyed S2 same thing might happen again !

Thanks dear. I can definitely say this d show would have been extremely successful nd an imp milestone had d makers brought in dabh 2.0 with IshVi but they literally brought in a leap for yhm. More than anything I'm mad at d makers for making Savi an ambitious girl into a nursery teacher. They could have shown Savi doing the current job as part time along with pursuing her upsc dreams that's wat Ishaan nd her parents wanted nd Chavan fam wanted instead they made her less ambitious nd a foster mother. Who will do that. I personally know ppl who lost parents during their childhood nd still cracked the exam that's how resilient ppl with indomitable spirit. No one quits upsc just like that nd in reality such instances make them bold nd determinant to pursue nd achieve their dreams. Doing away with upsc track nd deviating Savi from her dream goal was such a suicidal move. More than IshVi track I was seated 4 her upsc journey nd thought of getting motivated like dabh . But to my surprise they brought in Reeva nd messed up everything. Sai fulfilled her father's dream, Abhira fulfilled her mom's dream , Ishita is doing the job she's passionate about then y not start Savi's upsc track instead of blatantly copying yhm? Can't these ppl remake dabh instead of yhm nd retain SA? If SA is costly y hire him at d 1st place so that's pure business they used him nd deserted him. Atleast can't they make dabh with Hitesh nd bring bck d lost essence? No these ppl r lazy nd can't do away with toxicity. The show flopped in my eyes when Savi forgo her upsc dream. That's such a bad msg to deliver 😕. U quit ur dreams during the time of adversity? I mean that was such a suicidal move nd that's y trps aren't crossing 2.3

Originally posted by: WhimsicalMind

The dialogue about Ishita not being able to be a mother was there too, YHM was extremely problematic and Ghum makers are too for copy pasting it

I am not able to explain the issue and you are keen on defending one show which is counterproductive because it is not about which drama is better, the issue is extremely sensitive. I am stopping discussion from my side here

U haven't understood my side as well. All I'm saying is ghum should have done away with d slap nd dialogue as its 2024 nd these things won't b taken lightly. Ghum should have come up with something progressive that suits the contemporary era instead of using regressive lines.I will definitely say yhm is superior because this track has been executed so well in 2014 unlike here where everything is haphazard nd regressive nd doesn't suit 2024 setting nd ppl sue 4 such insensitivedialogues nowadays. The dialogue u were saying was used by Bala's mom not Param. Whatever to each their own I rest my case here.

Originally posted by: akipog

U haven't understood my side as well. All I'm saying is ghum should have done away with d slap nd dialogue as its 2024 nd these things won't b taken lightly. Ghum should have come up with something progressive that suits the contemporary era instead of using regressive lines.I will definitely say yhm is superior because this track has been executed so well in 2014 unlike here where everything is haphazard nd regressive nd doesn't suit 2024 setting nd ppl sue 4 such insensitivedialogues nowadays. The dialogue u were saying was used by Bala's mom not Param. Whatever to each their own I rest my case here.

I think Param says that to Ishita.

"Since you can't conceive, no one would know what happened between us"

Originally posted by: --QUEEN--

I think Param says that to Ishita.

"Since you can't conceive, no one would know what happened between us"

Yup it was there in YHM. I think it was a dialogue to show how horrible and cheap that man is..

Anyways I feel this entire discussion a bit uncomfortable. I saw few comments where people said Ishita was a weak character because she didnt beat up Param while he was trying to molest her..I mean seriously?! Idk how people are even saying such things..It almost looks like victim shaming.

Yhm cvs did a good job in trying to bring awareness about this issue.And Raman reprimanded everyone in the house for not supporting Ishita at the end of the track. Atleast for the first 300 or so epis yhm did a good job in portraying certain social issues like divorce,custody, juvenile delinquency, infertility etc

Originally posted by: akipog

U haven't understood my side as well. All I'm saying is ghum should have done away with d slap nd dialogue as its 2024 nd these things won't b taken lightly. Ghum should have come up with something progressive that suits the contemporary era instead of using regressive lines.I will definitely say yhm is superior because this track has been executed so well in 2014 unlike here where everything is haphazard nd regressive nd doesn't suit 2024 setting nd ppl sue 4 such insensitivedialogues nowadays. The dialogue u were saying was used by Bala's mom not Param. Whatever to each their own I rest my case here.

Same dialogue was said by Param to Ishita that she wont get pregnant if he r@pes her, watch the episode titled "Ishita is arrested"

2024 or 2014, These dialogues have no place on screen

And that's exactly what I complained about, ghum makers are extremely ridiculous for copy pasting such insensitive and problematic stuff

The slap is my problem, physically assaulting a woman who has been through so much, it should not be shown on screen especially when they don't plan on punishing Simmi or Tara not believing is fine because our society is like that but slap goes too far

Originally posted by: Golimumab

Yup it was there in YHM. I think it was a dialogue to show how horrible and cheap that man is..

Anyways I feel this entire discussion a bit uncomfortable. I saw few comments where people said Ishita was a weak character because she didnt beat up Param while he was trying to molest her..I mean seriously?! Idk how people are even saying such things..It almost looks like victim shaming.

Yhm cvs did a good job in trying to bring awareness about this issue.And Raman reprimanded everyone in the house for not supporting Ishita at the end of the track. Atleast for the first 300 or so epis yhm did a good job in portraying certain social issues like divorce,custody, juvenile delinquency, infertility etc

Raman's stand towards Simmi was something which I loved the most. He just doesn't want that monster in Simmi's life anymore. Simmi would cry and yell to let her meet Param, but Raman would never allow her to.

You should never give back the same place to a molester in the family. He/She needs to be abominated. Raman would not want Param to even interfere in Ananya's life, he was ready to take responsibility of both Simmi and Ananya.

The few scenes between Raman and Simmi after this track, are so heartwarming, he would yell at her, reprimand her, but he's doing everything right for her. He knows, how it is to deal with your spouse cheating on you, and Simmi is too naive to understand any of this and live a life like RKB.

But everything just got ruined, when Ishita herself goes and brings back Param home. I remember there was a lot of backlash for that move, they just abruptly sent away Param from Bhalla house without any proper reason.