Originally posted by: Ashviniv
@bold - this is what i feel too. no one (or most everyone) decides to cheat on their spouse intentionally. don't get me wrong they do cheat is still despicable but infidelity is not a broad brush stroke. Every case is different, every story is different is what I feel.
there is case of one of my friends. she is deeply unhappy in marriage. her husband is not able to emotionally support her. she has tried counselling, spirituality and everything. even her husband agrees with her assessment. they don't want to separate for the child. she asked her husband once that what if i strayed? he understood what she was asking and he contemplated too. though she is still holding on to the marriage sanctity but u see this is very delicate situation. every case will have their own story to tell
edit - thats why i feel its very easy to judge people from afar.
I beg to differ... This Arnav's redemption is still completely dilusional concept for me -
Those who have cheating habits, they will always cheat no matter what, but let's keep them aside... And I agree others do not plan on cheating their spose intentionally. But then cheating once, realizing the blunder and act on it right away versus continue cheating behind your spouse's back and on top of it, ill-treat your spouse and do hundred other things for your own guilt / hurt / hatred / escape is another level of narcissism..
We simply cannot ignore except his wife, Arnav had discussed the divorce behind her back with everyone including L. He even discussed with La when he was going to tell her.. He had done everything to protect his image (La and his photo incident), hired lawyer to figure out finances, what he can offer to Khushi and then he wanted to continue with the other woman (asked L to not call for a few days during divorce proceedings)! He was preparing for divorce for months but never find it important to inform Khushi. He never considered how Khushi will feel if she figures out somehow or find about his affair & divorce from others like she did, seriously????
He wanted to use his affair as a perfect excuse to convince her for divorce, clearly indicates he neither had guilt nor regret for his actions! He wanted to talk to Khushi for his own closure.. Once Khushi agreed for divorce and though she agreeing easily stumped him, he did not want to tell Khushi about La at all, in the name of avoiding hurting her further.. So if Shyam didn't happen or he didn't find her note or they simply had gone separate ways, there was never going to be an acceptance, forget the apology or redemption...
Arnav is this story is potrayed as brilliant, hard working, responsible since teenage, respecting woman (Khushi was smitten by his behavior), modern, solution finder, ethical, non-egoistic and most importantly righteous man! The same man has behaved so crass recently, turned so reckless to hurt his wife by doing things she was sensitive about, kill her beliefs applying for divorce, deserting his own wife, parents, treating women like trash, choosing to sleep with worst possible woman who is no less than tramp and he knew it too, and wants to continue with her..
From which angle he was planning to redeem himself????????? Just because the situations forced him the route of thinking and finding out, doesn't mean he is on path to redemption! Difficult situations could come again in life, will he repeat the chain then? This Arnav has failed himself, forgotten virtues given by parents/mom, has lost himself completely during THEIR JOURNEY TOGETHER from rag to riches.. Flying high, he lost his footing... And his efforts now might will never be enough....
I was trying to bring fun with Star Wars but Arnav has become henious Darth Vader, tomorrow we will know how exactly... Arnav's own deduction for the pain he wrought on Khushi is perfect - Lavanya, Manali, Shyam, and entirety of Uma Nagar, he could personally throw all of these people into the fiery pits of hell and then take a plunge into the depths himself. No less punishment Arnav deserves...
Aripta - What a tremedous coincidence, in Star Wars Anakin dies falling in Lava after Obi-wan severs his legs & left arm and Arnav here also is ready to throw himself in fiery pit!
The 101st time I am telling myself I want to understand Arnav's thought process during his affair time to seriously have even an ounce of sympathy that he is no where close to right now... Khushi should still forgive him not because he deserves forgiveness, but because she deserve peace, power and positivity to move on to the path she chooses for herself... But Khushi should not forget to learn her life lesson never to allow anyone else to take her for a ride!
We are judging the fictional characters here critically, improving our own notion of rights and wrongs as a mature group so I am ok with it...
I did share my worry with Arpita that if Arnav turns out to be worse than average Joe, just an ordinary weak man who used excuses and assumptions to bang next available woman, it will be a complete let down of such a beautiful story... But then I am wrong, the characters are build in such a realistic way that mighty do fall from grace in real world too!
All kudos and credits go to our brilliant writer, Arpita, nothing can take away from this beautiful story and her writing style is amazing!
Edited by SwatStar_Arshi - 1 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount