Originally posted by: columbia
yoi bring up valid points on Kathaa. However I don’t think it’s about her processing his loss. There is no full stop to that kind of loss, its omnipresence is often confused with interference or inability, whereas that may not be the case. BUT BUT we don’t know because the writers don’t give us clarity on this from Katha’s perspective. The only thing we know so far is she has become very comfortable with just herself and her son. This has been compounded with her having to deal with his illness, there has been no time for anyone else and now she feels there is no need. And it’s absolutely fine to feel that there is no need. Because women who have loved and lost are made to feel like they are afraid to love again.. while that may be partially true, it is different for different people.
Obviously the last episode we have been shown that this need is something her son has expressed, which obviously she will now possibly entertain. And yet again, the makers give us these imbalanced characterization / on one hand she has told Viaan very categorically that no place for a third person and on the other hand, she expresses her need to fulfill every wish of Arav to Dodo.
Of course, this can only mean one thing. If Katha will say yes to Viaan it will be for Arav and not for herself. To me that makes for an interesting chapter. But here again I do wish there was more clarity on the characterization. And the reason I say IF is because since they have given us no clarity on her exact feelings, who knows we may have a track where another guy is also introduced by PapaG who he can control.
With respect to Viaan I agree with you - am cut pasting what I already said two pages ago. This also relates to Ehsan. The whole about turn is a joke - I agree with @Amarpali2 on this
……
with respect to Kathaa it is actually her inability to open up to a second chance. Viaan is right in that Katha is afraid to so do. BUT its actually not normal for a man who is in love with a woman who has been in love before and lost to have such an objective perspective, I wish the dialogues that Viaan said had actually come from Ehsun. Because Viaan should have gone into she will never love me, because when you are in love, there is a slight vulnerability.
To me, this is where the writers are messing up. They are not clear in how they want to build the two characters of Viaan and Ehsun. if they have decided to make Ehsun the supportive friend then they need to go all out. If they have decided to make Viaan vulnerable, then they need to go all out…they can’t flip flop. Katha has clearly just told him there is no place for anyone else and apna hero has decided nope, I don’t agree. That’s not normal. In fact, if anyth8ng Ehsun who has heard this before has had time with this information, the nope this isn’t true, or cannot live in past should have come from him, because he has had time to assess her after she told him the same thing.
I did however like the whole friends convo,,,the lightness of it..was a treat to watch.,. Especially when Ehsun goes we don’t have experience of being fathers…it was funny.
BUt I am unable to understand the characterization of Viaan. If someone asks me what kind of a man is he…I will be unable to answer…because you can be a little of a lot of things, but you can’t be a little of everything.
Now coming to G family, I do think they wrapped the ema track so that they could explore the what happens when someone new comes into our widow bahu with ghar ka Chirag track… I do think here too they will not fully explore because they have given the family another boy…
The whole culmination of tracks so abruptly has added to the confusion while watching. There needs to be some seamless way of storytelling. It’s kind of disappointing.
Anyways!!! I do hope you drop by more often… becos even discussing it here in the forum has become less interesting… again pata nahi if that’s just me!