Dickinson
Although I watched S1 long ago, I am going to summarize all three seasons in one post as they build upon each other.
Inspired by Emily Dickinson's poems, Dickinson is Apple TV's most whimsical, inventive, and earnest rendition of historical fiction. The humorous approach that uses modern music and parlance against a narrative set in the 1800's makes the drama engaging and relatable.
Another incredible and relatable aspect of the show is how it deals with relationship complexities we presume to be just "modern" problems - like extramarital affairs and suppressing homosexuality.
Set in a patriarchal era, it could have easily presented men as villains who control women. But Dickinson gives them a remarkable amount of depth and humanity. They are products of their time, grappling with the old ways and a changing world.
For example, Austin could have been just that asshole brother who marries Sue despite knowing Emily loves her. But his love for Sue is genuine and earnest as well. He knows Emily's deep fondness for Sue and supports it while not fully wrapping his head around it.
On the one hand, he is a disappointing man who is always a bit of a doofus. He carelessly spends the family fortune. He gets fooled into buying a fake painting. He is always the oblivious fool. But on the other hand, he is someone with a big heart, risking everything to do the right thing. He lets Henry use his barn for his gathering of black people. He funds Henry's abolitionist paper, buys them a printing press, and even funds John Brown's raid on Harper's family.
On the one hand, he spirals to become a drunk womanizer who openly flaunts his extramarital affair. But on the other hand, you see him betrayed and broken by his wife's infidelity and lack of father's support. And most importantly, no matter what, he is there for his sisters and his wife - even though he considers divorcing her at a point.
Even Edward Dickinson, the stoic patriarch, has his redeeming qualities. On one hand, he's the quintessential aloof father who withholds affections and affirmations from his children. He's a traditional patriarch who believes women are property that must be inherited and cared for by men. And quite frankly, he can be an asshole. But beyond the tough exterior is a softness. Despite his criticisms, he is indulging and forgiving of Austin. He's especially partial to his two daughters. Otherwise, back in the day, it would be unheard of for a man to have not one but two daughters who remained fiercely independent and never married.
The two protagonists are not completely sympathetic either. Of course, there is the elephant in the room - they were two women deeply in love but could never live happily ever after because of the times they lived in. But at the same time, they could be deeply selfish and toxic to each other and those around them. Sue's emotions for Emily completely overpower her, and she completely disregards Austin's feelings when she has an affair with Samuel Bowles in order to get over Emily. The worst is when Sue uses patriarchal garbage to deny Austin his desire to be a more present and no traditional father.
Emily is often so self-centered and self-obsessed with her writing that she tends to shut out and disregard everyone around her. She is always oblivious to what her mother, her sister Lavinia, or even Sue are going through. She takes Sue for granted and doesn't think twice before ignoring a postpartum Sue. Her worst transgressions are when she takes her poems and aspirations to be more important than the emotions of Betty, a black woman.
Despite being three short seasons of ten episodes each, Dickinson also gives side characters a chance to shine. Through the three seasons, Lavinia's arc comes to terms with her own unconventional sexual desires and dislike for monogamy. Their mother, Emily Norcross Dickinson, initially comes across as a traditional housewife who exalts domesticity for women. But her veneer of being a perfect housewife fades away to reveal regrets for marrying young and being tired of domesticity.
Most importantly, the show does not exist in a vacuum. It acknowledges slavery and the Civil War, often allowing its black characters to have a voice and take over entire episodes and story arcs. Some of the Civil War episodes especially do a brilliant job of calling out white saviors as they showcase the poor conditions of the Gullah Geechee slaves who want to fight against the Confederacy. It also draws a remarkable distinction between the Union's war and the freed slaves's war.
My favorite past about Dickinson are the guest stars - Wiz Khalifa as Death, Ziwe as Sojourner Truth, Zosia Mamet as Louisa May Alcott, Billy Eichner as Walt Whitman, Nick Kroll as Edgar Allan Poe, Chloe Fineman as Sylvia Plath, John Mulaney as Henry David Thoreau, and Timothy Simons as Frederick Law Olmsted.
Season 1
Based on Emily's earliest poems dedicated to Sue, Season One introduces Emily and Sue as idyllic and carefree young girls in love. But over time, societal realities start closing in on them. As Emily gets older, her family chides her to stop her childish ways. Sue is a poor orphan who feels pressure to marry a man who can provide financially for her. The season arcs from young love and courtship to heartbreak as Sue marries Emily's brother, Austin.
Season 2
In the period after Sue and Austin's marriage, Emily falls into depression and does not write as much. Season two uses a sparse few poems to cover a toxic and turbulent time in their relationship. Sue and Emily are essentially broken up for most of the season. Most of the season is the catastrophic outcomes of two lovers separated and reacting in toxic ways. It is a tempestuous period that causes Emily, Sue, and Austin great pain.
Season 3
The Civil War was Emily Dickinson's most prolific period. She expanded her range of writing, not just romantic odes to Sue but also about war, suffering, and the meaning of life. While Emily and Sue are back together, their relationship is not as idyllic as it was when they were young. Sue is a mother now, something that Emily struggles to accept and respect. Emily is inspired to make a difference in the war with poetry, but Sue struggles with desiring more affection. Then there is Austin, who is on a downward spiral, given last season's events, but seeks a path to redemption. One of the most poignant episodes is a time travel episode to the future where Sylvia Plath foreshadows the future Emily Dickinson and the world would know.
---
Taylor Swift's album Evermore was announced on December 10, Emily Dickinson's birthday. The name 'Evermore' is believed to be inspired by Sue — Forevermore, one of Emily's romantic poems dedicated to Sue. Many people believe the song 'Ivy' was inspired by Emily and Sue's love affair and is sung from Sue's perspective. It's perfection when the show finally infuses the song in Season 3.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5cTUY2Il5s
comment:
p_commentcount