Originally posted by: Neetu_GirlPower
live performances can go horrible...and sometimes with even the best of people... i have seen udit narayan myself going out of the place at a concert...even the melidious alka yagnik once was seen going haywire in songs...
so how does tht suppose to make the singers terrible...what logic is thtπ
anyways talking abt singing...Alisha has sung the bhajan 'BABUL MORA' fantastically in album 'OM' this proves enuff she is a fantastic singer...and she has a lot of fans too...doesn;t matter if i-f doesn;t have it...who really caresπ€
ehm...live performances can go wrong..yes singers can go off key once or twice...not for the entire duration of 3 hours, that she would be compelled to start lip syncing her song...thats plain embarrassing and an insult to the audience who paid to watch her perform live...
Ive seen udit, alka, hariharan, SPB, shreya, sunidhi,sonu nigam, chitra, shubha mudgal ...all perform live(Several times) and they go offkey once or twice at max (SPB dosent even go off key once..the man is like the god of singing)...
And many music directors claim that alisha dosent have a grip on her notes and keys...her voice is always needing some electronic enhancement or another...so whatever tracks we listen on the CD are electronically tweaked to make her notes sound good.
Her comments while judging indian idol too were useless, and prove she knows peanuts about the technicalities of singing...javed akthar and udit narayan themselves admitted that on the show...she has a gorgeous voice..that is about it.
Edited by smartie_pants - 13 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount