Karthik Goenka ....can he be redeemed ? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Indira1211

kArthik is a disappointment..or rather the writers are majorly disappointing us by writing him like they do.. I look at Harman from Shakti astitva..he used to go against his family all the time for soumya ...even though she was a kinner and they couldn’t even have a physical marital relationship...he loved her so much... and used to fight with the whole world for her...same with neil from Naamkaran...he fought everyone for avni..his family..her family...the police ..the criminals ..etc. I’m just so disappointed with the way they’ve written karthik. Anyway according to the latest segments looks like naira and karthik are together,..so maybe we will finally get some redemption from him..and he will finally understand that his wife comes first ..not his step mother or hooligan cousins..

Aur kitni baar "redeem" hoga ye character kitna asaan ho gaya hau kisi ka baccha chura lo aur sorry bol do biwi pe galat ilzaam lagao aur sorry bhi mat bolo aur ab apme molester bhaiyon ko defend karo aur phir bhi sorry bol do

Seriously indira can you tell me how Karthik is better than kunal ?? That he still deserves apology

Naira is not wrong BUT it wouldn’t have hurt her had she informed Kartik of her decision. She didn’t need his permission or for him to be on board but a heads up would have been nice. That’s what happens in reality. Couples communicate. Even if they have different opinions, they discuss them, argue with each other, reach a consensus and then proceed.
I remember there was a scene once where Naira had done something similar and everyone was looking at Kartik to know if he knew about it and he just walked away. I think it was the time when she was pregnant. Point being, it’s embarrassing to be always kept out of the loop by your partner. I can’t believe that even after 2 divorces, one kid, three marriages, they can’t tell each other what they are up to.

Coming towards Kartik, he’s not right to support Luv Kush or defend them but I do understand where he’s coming from. From a third person point of view it’s very easy to say that Kartik should get his brothers punished, etc, etc, but if you put yourself in his position, then you realise that’s it’s not as easy as it seems. His reaction is very normal in my opinion. He’s taking his time to come to terms with the gravity of their crimes and he will eventually stand against them. Also, from what I gauged, he was ready to get them punished after he found out but the suicide drama shook him to his core. As he said, he’s already lost a brother and he can’t lose another one. What Naira saw, was different from what he witnessed. Also, you are selfish when it comes to your family. It’s wrong but it is the reality of this world.

Anyhow, Kartik will be supporting Naira and Trisha in their fight for justice after the court hearing. I want to see what will make him change his decision.

I would love for Naira to take a stand and leave Karthik permanently. Take custody of Kairav and raise him into a good human being with the help of the Singhania's.

Originally posted by: Kaira_123

Naira is not wrong BUT it wouldn’t have hurt her had she informed Kartik of her decision. She didn’t need his permission or for him to be on board but a heads up would have been nice. That’s what happens in reality. Couples communicate. Even if they have different opinions, they discuss them, argue with each other, reach a consensus and then proceed.
I remember there was a scene once where Naira had done something similar and everyone was looking at Kartik to know if he knew about it and he just walked away. I think it was the time when she was pregnant. Point being, it’s embarrassing to be always kept out of the loop by your partner. I can’t believe that even after 2 divorces, one kid, three marriages, they can’t tell each other what they are up to.

Coming towards Kartik, he’s not right to support Luv Kush or defend them but I do understand where he’s coming from. From a third person point of view it’s very easy to say that Kartik should get his brothers punished, etc, etc, but if you put yourself in his position, then you realise that’s it’s not as easy as it seems. His reaction is very normal in my opinion. He’s taking his time to come to terms with the gravity of their crimes and he will eventually stand against them. Also, from what I gauged, he was ready to get them punished after he found out but the suicide drama shook him to his core. As he said, he’s already lost a brother and he can’t lose another one. What Naira saw, was different from what he witnessed. Also, you are selfish when it comes to your family. It’s wrong but it is the reality of this world.

Anyhow, Kartik will be supporting Naira and Trisha in their fight for justice after the court hearing. I want to see what will make him change his decision.

Exactly. That's the only thing I didnt like..naira reacts first and then mop around while the family give her cold stares. Just inform kartik what is she upto or make a video of luv kush and show it to kartik . Or trisha could have informed the police and fought her own battle with the help of naira . What they r showing is reality . When naira asked them if I was there in Trisha s place and someone else in luv kush place will your reaction be the same?its complicated...everyone is two faced when it comes to their family .

Originally posted by: Poorabhforever

Aur kitni baar "redeem" hoga ye character kitna asaan ho gaya hau kisi ka baccha chura lo aur sorry bol do biwi pe galat ilzaam lagao aur sorry bhi mat bolo aur ab apme molester bhaiyon ko defend karo aur phir bhi sorry bol do

Seriously indira can you tell me how Karthik is better than kunal ?? That he still deserves apology

lol...Kunal 😂.... we cant compare Kunal to karthik. Kunal was a very well written realistic character. ..lol..he was a pure jerk, and there’s lots of men like him in real life....pure jerks who cheat and betray their good wives...Karthik is not a very well written character..he was supposed to be a good man..but does all these immoral things...what could be more disrespectful than siding with women molesters. And he is supposed to have this great love for naira...yet he’s ever ready to go against her if any of his family is involved or to question her morals ...where is the love and trust then. Karthik is also A very arrogant snobbish man...just like manish and suhasini..I don’t like the way he speaks to working class people. And today vansh summed It up well when he told kairav ..that the goenkas have a lot of money and power so they can get away with anything..So that’s what these snobbish goenkas believe ..that they have money and power so they are above their law. I don’t know if karthik will change or be redeemed,.and I don’t understand how naira can want to be part of that family or have karthik for a husband ..🤦🏽‍♀️...but he’s the hero of the show and they’ve given us him.. lol...he even married another woman ...and registered that marriage after knowing naira is alive ...Karthik Goenka is definitely not one of the better male leads on itv ..and sadly ..his and nairas love story ..is not anything wonderful... Because the writers have written them like that..Lol...our real life stories and husbands are far better,..🙏

It's unfortunate that the grandchildren have learned that they are exempt from law because of their money and power. Talk about bad upbringing. I hope that Karthik and Naira realize this and reinforce what is good/bad behavior to their children and teach them that there are consequences to bad behavior.

Originally posted by: _charu_

Exactly. That's the only thing I didnt like..naira reacts first and then mop around while the family give her cold stares. Just inform kartik what is she upto or make a video of luv kush and show it to kartik . Or trisha could have informed the police and fought her own battle with the help of naira . What they r showing is reality . When naira asked them if I was there in Trisha s place and someone else in luv kush place will your reaction be the same?its complicated...everyone is two faced when it comes to their family .

in this track I have to support naira,..she did tell karthik many times that luv kush should be handed over to the police...but he said over his dead body . So if she had told him she was going to inform the police ...he and the family would have done everything to stop her. And she did try to be on the side of the family...but that was obviously against the law, against her morals and her ethics, the goenkas and karthik included are completely wrong in this track..no matter how much we love mohsin and karthik...he’s unreasonable and unethical in this track. And yes we all love our family...but if they are wrong we can’t support them. Rapists, murderers, molesters, paedophiles are all somebody’s sons, brothers, cousins , husbands etc....but that doesn’t mean that they must be protected by their family for their heinous crimes. In fact many times their own family lets the police know about them...because they are a threat to society..So really ..karthik and the goenkas can’t be supported or understood in this track..they are wrong ..period ...no doubt about that...and the police threatened them all that they are protecting criminals and obstructing justice...they all should be locked up and taught a lesson in my opinion..😡 ..the goenkas are a self centered snobbish family who believe that their money has earned them power to be above the law .karthik included...and that is a load of BS🤦🏽‍♀️

Originally posted by: Indira1211

in this track I have to support naira,..she did tell karthik many times that luv kush should be handed over to the police...but he said over his dead body . So if she had told him she was going to inform the police ...he and the family would have done everything to stop her. And she did try to be on the side of the family...but that was obviously against the law, against her morals and her ethics, the goenkas and karthik included are completely wrong in this track..no matter how much we love mohsin and karthik...he’s unreasonable and unethical in this track. And yes we all love our family...but if they are wrong we can’t support them. Rapists, murderers, molesters, paedophiles are all somebody’s sons, brothers, cousins , husbands etc....but that doesn’t mean that they must be protected by their family for their heinous crimes. In fact many times their own family lets the police know about them...because they are a threat to society..So really ..karthik and the goenkas can’t be supported or understood in this track..they are wrong ..period ...no doubt about that...and the police threatened them all that they are protecting criminals and obstructing justice...they all should be locked up and taught a lesson in my opinion..😡 ..the goenkas are a self centered snobbish family who believe that their money has earned them power to be above the law .karthik included...and that is a load of BS🤦🏽‍♀️

I didnt support kartik, I said the family will naturally try to hide the crime , but naira must try to convince kartik to be by her side. If she had proof of luv kush celebrating and mocking their family,she wouldn't have to make so much effort to prove it to kartik that she is right . Goenkas can go to hell if kartik is with her .

Originally posted by: _charu_

I didnt support kartik, I said the family will naturally try to hide the crime , but naira must try to convince kartik to be by her side. If she had proof of luv kush celebrating and mocking their family,she wouldn't have to make so much effort to prove it to kartik that she is right . Goenkas can go to hell if kartik is with her .

Agreed with both of your opinions but at the same time just because the twins are their family they are nobody to decide that they are feeling guilty so shouldn't get proper punishment. What utter shit. Imagine all rapists or murderers family's deciding that they should protect their devilish family member if they show so-called guilt in front of them? Ewww. This track has made me hate this family more.

I agree the whole idea of the Goenka's deciding a proper punishment of Luv/Kush was a bad joke. I think it is hard to accept when your own family member does something like this. First instinct is to protect them because they are your own blood and you hope that your kids don't have a malicious nature. I am not at all justifying the Goenka's behavior as they do act very entitled and don't hesitate to use their power and money for influence. The lawyer is creepy in all honesty. He is walking around carrying plants and is twofaced.

Let's see how Naira and Karthik resolve to find evidence to support the truth. I read somewhere that Kairav may lead them to some proof but lets see what happens.

I read the lawyer is Abishek's father so he has a vested interested in saving Luv/Kush in order to save his own son. I don't understand why only Luv/Kush were arrested? Why not Abishek? I hope that since he is the lawyer's son that he can no longer represent this case and that they are all proven guilty as charged.