Shrimad Ramayan episode discussion thread (21/10/24- 22/10/24))a - Page 7

Originally posted by: Celinacrescent

Wait ...What ??? 😱😱😱Of all the people they could get ,they chose Anand Neelakanthan??R u sure ,he is the writer ??

The man is one of the worst literary creators ,I have ever seen.His debut novel Asura is like literally slinging dung on Valmiki Ramayana.Some of the excerpts from his book are -

1.Writing a disclaimer in the books nd then claiming it is inspired from Ramayana?.

2.Asuras ruled India ,then Aryans came and overthrew the Asuras ??

3.Lakshnan disfigured and raped Shurpanakha ??

4.Sita was Ravan's daughter yet Ravana was worried that Aryan society ne er treated women better so kidnapped Sita for her own good ??🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

4.Ravana was great yet was betrayed by his own brothers ??

5.Ram won and then implemented every atrocity known to mankind like caste system ,Sati system. Initiator of a chaotic soceity!!

I feel so sorry for u Shree Ram...!!Even after many years u still have to undergo this ??

Yes brother...I am sure he was writing screenplay till Yuddhkand...and I agree totally with all on all u said abt his writings and novels.....

Actually that's the reason we see this much dilution of Lakshman & Vibhishan as a character & even Mandodari ka helping to destroy Ravan ka yagya,,so yes ravan Indrajeet shurpnakha in sabko overglorify karne ke chakkar mein they diluted other main and virtuous characters...

In his latest book,asura way of living,,he says history is written by victors,,Ram win battle so we remember him as protagonist & his ways as ideal,,,, otherwise if ravan wld hv won,,his ways wld be called dharma😱,,,and on place of shurpnakha,,antagonist wld hv been Ram Lakshman😰 to disrespect a lady 😬🙄 and then he went on describing how Ram's life is example of tragedy & failure😭😔😮‍💨😳😵‍💫🤦🤦,,,ravan died with glory and Ram lived but with agony and his cost of standing by side of virtues was to be paid by his own wife,his kids and lastly his faithful brother....only reading the article related to his new book left me totally dejected 😭😱😰...how can writers on name of creativity can interpolate our glorious itihaas to this level 😭....

Abt mihir Bhuta I don't know much...

Originally posted by: RamAayenge

Yes brother...I am sure he was writing screenplay till Yuddhkand...and I agree totally with all on all u said abt his writings and novels.....

Actually that's the reason we this much dilution of Lakshman & Vibhishan as a character & even Mandodari ka helping to destroy Ravan ka yagya,,so yes ravan Indrajeet shurpnakha in sabko overglorify karne ke chakkar mein they diluted other main and virtuous characters...

In his latest book,asura way of living,,he says history is written by victors,,Ram win battle so we remember him as protagonist & his ways as ideal,,,, otherwise if ravan wld hv won,,his ways wld be called dharma😱,,,and on place of shurpnakha,,antagonist wld hv been Ram Lakshman😰 to disrespect a lady 😬🙄 and then he went on describing how Ram's life is example of tragedy & failure😭😔😮‍💨😳😵‍💫🤦🤦,,,ravan died with glory and Ram lived but with agony and his cost of standing by side of virtues was to be paid by his own wife,his kids and lastly his faithful brother....only reading the article related to his new book left me totally dejected 😭😱😰...how can writers on name of creativity can interpolate our glorious itihaas to this level 😭....

Abt mihir Bhuta I don't know much...

Oh my god yeh kya tha

Ram ka naam.badnaam kar rakhe hai

Bachpan se simple ramayan suni hai

Yeh sab kaun hai

Kahan se aate hai

Kaise stories laate hai

Mat padho dimaag ka bharta ban jayega

Hey ram sabko sadbuddhi Dena

Ram ke adarsh aaj ke zamane mein shayad nahi chalte but still ram is pujnya

Hum log hey ram kahte hai

Hayye ram nahi

Marte waqt bhi ram nam liya jaata hai

Toh kya yeh sab jhooth hai

I don't want to read this stupid kahani jahan ram ko villain bana dete hai log 😡🤬

Originally posted by: chatterbox

Oh my god yeh kya tha

Ram ka naam.badnaam kar rakhe hai

Bachpan se simple ramayan suni hai

Yeh sab kaun hai

Kahan se aate hai

Kaise stories laate hai

Mat padho dimaag ka bharta ban jayega

Hey ram sabko sadbuddhi Dena

Ram ke adarsh aaj ke zamane mein shayad nahi chalte but still ram is pujnya

Hum log hey ram kahte hai

Hayye ram nahi

Marte waqt bhi ram nam liya jaata hai

Toh kya yeh sab jhooth hai

I don't want to read this stupid kahani jahan ram ko villain bana dete hai log 😡🤬

Yes exactly...I hv not read his any previous books not will read any new one too...I just read article released on his new book,,,and came to know this....even I told my brother who was reading Amish Tripathi ki Ramchandra series ki books to NOT read them or atleast DON'T believe them true and encouraged him to read VR and also Ami ganatra ka ramayan unraveled which I was reading currently and found its again a very good book for understanding ramayan and it's characters as described in authentic versions...

For me VR is best,,,I can read it repeatedly,,,,waise bhi it's long and every time we get to learn something new...

Originally posted by: RamAayenge

Yes exactly...I hv not read his any previous books not will read any new one too...I just read article released on his new book,,,and came to know this....even I told my brother who was reading Amish Tripathi ki Ramchandra series ki books to NOT read them or atleast DON'T believe them true and encouraged him to read VR and also Ami ganatra ka ramayan unraveled which I was reading currently and found its again a very good book for understanding ramayan and it's characters as described in authentic versions...

For me VR is best,,,I can read it repeatedly,,,,waise bhi it's long and every time we get to learn something new...

Maine toh vaise bhi nahi padha vr ya Rcm

Baaki ki baat hi nahi hai

Bas bachpan ki kahaniyan suni hai

Main main baatein pata hai

Is saste ravan ko dekho

Iske baare mein toh ab pata chala ki yeh bhi ek namoona tha

Aur Jo naye rakshas laaye yeh log

Croc and pata nahi kaun kaun

All fiction

Basic par rahte toh achha tha

Yudhh kaand mei on track the but unnecessary manipulation kar diya

Bechara meghu saste mein maara gaya

Theek se fight bhi nahi kiya

Originally posted by: chatterbox

I will tag

Story is not much bas time pass

Ok Thanks Chatterbox

🤗

Yeah Watching For Time Pass Too

Originally posted by: TheMinion

Ah, I love this version!!! Most authentic ever and sadly made by non Indians

Yeah they were sincere like how in general Japansese are.The only partbthat they got wrong was the skin color of Ram.But can be easily overlooked.Frankly speaking ,I have never seen a more beautiful Ram or Sita.

VHP created a huge protest of not allowing it to release after Mr Sako assured a lot of people.Can't blame it on VHP also.They were right from their POV and had valid points.

Originally posted by: ananya3129

https://x.com/mishthi99/status/1848372605079675355?s=46

Your message is too short. Please write at least 4 words or 20 characters.

Though this scene is good,cannot understand why Luv Kush took the arrow release position ,but didn't fire one unlike their father ...🤔🤔

Nice discussions

Anand Neelakanthan was one of the original writers of the show but they removed him sometime before Sundar Kand. Sundar Kand and Yuddh Kand writing credits were given to Tiwariji himself, we discussed this that time. Surprisingly Anand Neelakanthan wrote the good part for this show maybe because of channel pressure to avoid any controversy.

Originally posted by: ananya3129

Nice discussions

Anand Neelakanthan was one of the original writers of the show but they removed him sometime before Sundar Kand. Sundar Kand and Yuddh Kand writing credits were given to Tiwariji himself, we discussed this that time. Surprisingly Anand Neelakanthan wrote the good part for this show maybe because of channel pressure to avoid any controversy.

To be fair ,writing before Sundarkand indeed was quite decent .Till episode 60 ,it was great.Then it went downhill because of messed up CGI only.Otherwise writing was still strong if we ignore the little to no lamentations from Shree Ram as well as long drawn out dialogues from him.Sunderkand onwards it was intolerable.Now I understand whose the culprit.Thankfully Mr.Anand still did justice to Lakshman's character .After him,show's trajectory,content and VFX hit a new low.

https://x.com/klaroliner123/status/1848727873646968898?s=46

Your message is too short. Please write at least 4 words or 20 characters.