· Dedicated Unlock Requests:Reintroducing a centralized thread for users to request unlocks, with acommitted response timeframe, could address the inconvenience. This was afeature in the past, and we can revisit it.
· MemberUnlock Option: Allowing thread creators to unlock their own threads is technicallypossible, but it would require careful development to ensure it doesn’tintroduce spam or performance issues.
· Extended Lock Periods: For specificsections like Fan Fictions or reference threads, we could consider increasingthe lock period from three months to a longer timeframe
Originally posted by: vijay
Thank you for your detailed feedback and suggestions, Vaidhumom. I’m glad to hear that you’re enjoying the improvements in speed, page loads, and security—it’s wonderful to know the upgrades are making a positive impact!
Now, regarding the thread locking system, I completely understand your concerns, especially about the challenges it creates for maintaining older threads. Let me explain why the thread-locking mechanism is in place and how similar practices are followed by many other forums:
- Site Performance: Locking older threads helps optimize site performance by limiting activity on dormant content, preventing unnecessary server load. This ensures the site remains responsive and fast for all users.
- Preventing Spam: Many forums implement thread locking to deter spammers from bumping inactive threads. It’s a common problem in online communities, and locking threads helps keep the forum clean and secure.
- Promoting Current Engagement: Locked threads encourage users to create new discussions instead of resurrecting outdated topics. This helps keep conversations fresh and relevant.
Examples from Other Forums:
- Reddit: Subreddits often use auto-locking bots to close threads after a certain period of inactivity, usually between 1-6 months depending on the community.
- Stack Overflow: Threads automatically become read-only if they’re inactive for an extended period, particularly when the topic is no longer relevant.
- vBulletin Forums: Many communities running on vBulletin or phpBB software also auto-lock threads after a few months, balancing active discussions with site management.
These practices are widely adopted to maintain a balance between preserving old content and fostering active, current discussions.
Addressing Your Suggestions
I understand your frustration, especially for threads like fan fictions or resource topics that require ongoing updates. Here are some potential steps we can explore:
- Dedicated Unlock Requests: Reintroducing a centralized thread for users to request unlocks, with a committed response timeframe, could address the inconvenience. This was a feature in the past, and we can revisit it.
- Member Unlock Option: Allowing thread creators to unlock their own threads is technically possible, but it would require careful development to ensure it doesn’t introduce spam or performance issues.
- Extended Lock Periods: For specific sections like Fan Fictions or reference threads, we could consider increasing the lock period from three months to a longer timeframe.
We’ll review these suggestions internally to assess their feasibility.
Thank you again for raising this issue and for your contributions to the community. Your feedback is invaluable in helping us make the site more user-friendly while maintaining its performance and security.
Hello Vijay,
Greetings!
To begin with, Thank you for your quick reply and for being equally concerned. I really appreciate that.
You guessed it right. Its worst frustrating factor for we FF writers. To further comment, The issue is not that the threads are getting locked. You have valid reasons to do so. The major issue is the thread starters face problems in unlocking it again..and I am amused that thread starters dont have authority to lock/unlock their own threads. I would say its really unfair. moreover, we have to send requests after requests to Admin/moderators and there is so much delay in getting our requests done. Anyways, Glad that your team is taking this issue into consideration and will do the needful
Now, I have further comments on these points. Please check and further comment. Eagerly waiting for the day when this issue gets sorted out.
· Dedicated Unlock Requests:Reintroducing a centralized thread for users to request unlocks, with acommitted response timeframe, could address the inconvenience. This was afeature in the past, and we can revisit it. Please bring it back. its needed especially when we thread starters dont have any authority to lock/unlock our own threads.
· MemberUnlock Option: Allowing thread creators to unlock their own threads is technicallypossible, but it would require careful development to ensure it doesn’tintroduce spam or performance issues. As said, This would be the best solution. Also, I am sure that your admin / moderators will be relaxed when this issue shall be handled by the thread starters. Coming to spamming, I have noticed that your development team has set some inbuilt protocalls to take immediate action when there is a spamming happening...
· Extended Lock Periods: For specificsections like Fan Fictions or reference threads, we could consider increasingthe lock period from three months to a longer timeframe. This would help but not a permanent solution to this problem.
Edited by Vaidhumom - 3 days ago
comment:
p_commentcount