Neha verma and Judges - Page 3

oh my god!!u ppl have no sense 😡 ...challenge mein toh kisiki burai karne se nahi ruke...atleast spare these poor kids..agreed neha was gud singer..but u guys have no right to say things like protik shuld have been out..or gurpreet shuld pay for her mum's actions(ash issue)..cmmon guys these r just kids..just think wht u guys did when u were just 10..and rahi baat judges ki..they knw wht they r doign..agar unko neha ho eliminate karna hi tha..then they would have not selected her in best 11..agar tum logon mein music ki itni hi samjh hai...then u guys wuld b in place of those judges..each kid is an amazing singer..
just sapre them...and kiski burai mat karo8-|

In the episode where neha was eliminated,injustice was done.She was pretty good and that day better compared to protik.don't know why she was eliminated.

Every week, when some one is eliminated, there is a topic that she/he should not have been eliminated. Injustice has been done.

The topic starter should then say who should be eliminated. There has to be one every week. I think so far it has been fair.

My question is if it was not Neha, who should it be? Protik? He is gone next week anyways. Who would you pick? The judges have been fair so far albeit two of them are rude. It is much better than public voting for sure.

My 2 cents

Originally posted by: rashi_kool

oh my god!!u ppl have no sense 😡 ...challenge mein toh kisiki burai karne se nahi ruke...atleast spare these poor kids..agreed neha was gud singer..but u guys have no right to say things like protik shuld have been out..or gurpreet shuld pay for her mum's actions(ash issue)..cmmon guys these r just kids..just think wht u guys did when u were just 10..and rahi baat judges ki..they knw wht they r doign..agar unko neha ho eliminate karna hi tha..then they would have not selected her in best 11..agar tum logon mein music ki itni hi samjh hai...then u guys wuld b in place of those judges..each kid is an amazing singer..
just sapre them...and kiski burai mat karo8-|

It's not about "burai" of someone, it's about injustice to someone. Hum public hain, we can speak our mind if we feel something is wrong.

Who is out who is in, kiska number aaj laga aur kaun baach gaya, that might not be a factor to you or me. It does matter to those kids. Getting out in the 10th position is not same as getting out in some position lower than that.

I agree! Neha should not have been eliminated. I know she was not the best but there were and are many more who is incompetent in comparisn to Neha.

I thought armaan would be out of the contest, indiscriminate of what grades he has been getting. because I now really don'nt believe in their grades.

... and if the judgement is given in the basis of age and your background I think the competition should have been divided into 2 groups, below 10 and inbetween 10 to 15 yrs.