Neha verma and Judges

If u observe Neha verma She had improvement in every performance...

1)Megha Chaaye Aadhi raat->NOt very impressive

2)Rhimjhim sawan-Was better

3)Mujko Hui na kabar-GOod but easy song

4)Awaaz do humko-She was better than many contestants on that day

5)Rukh jaa raat-Was an excellent performance

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAq_8Ve-PBg

All Judges were determined to remove her 😡..

Down with all three especially Alka Yagnik😡..

I really felt That Neha was better than Alka when alka sang a line of this song...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBYQr3ANewQ

I am sure All trios have already decided about winner😡...

It shldnt go like this.I am not againt the grade that was given to Neha she got a++,a,and B++

Then how come she lost to protik who had least grade

Judges dont respect their Grades ...

I Hope in the future Neha becomes a gr8 singer...SHe becopmes a tough competitor to So called melody Queen😡 alka

Didnt anyone feel so.Y no comments

I strongly agree with you too. I felt that neha's voice
is very melodious as compared to other contestants,
who have husky voice.
I was shocked to see her out and this was really unfair.
And yeah...i have a sneaky feeling alka wanted her out
because her genre is the same as Alka.
Just look at other contestants who are overly hyped -
gurpreet -ok, she's young but her voice quality is so harsh. Dinakar- average but gets top ratings,
sameer- completelty indisciplined voice and concentrates more in dancing.
Neha- really had a sweet voice as compared to all of them.
But Alka (and other judges) not just eliminated her
but also said things like - "yeh gana mera bahut hi fav hai aur bilkul maza nahi aya".
And for gurpreet she finds - x factor and wat not.
Just rubbish!

I didn't find Neha that good and thought Protik was overall better than her.

But, what I did not like is that her ratings were higher than Protik's. It makes no sense.

I think Diwakar and Sameer are brilliant. Especially Sameer has an incredibly unique and powerful voice.

I don't think it's fair to start criticizing all the other contestants to make Neha look like she was amazing. From the girls , I feel Sanchita and Pawni are brilliant. That's my opinion. no offence meant.

Originally posted by: ranig

I didn't find Neha that good and thought Protik was overall better than her.

But, what I did not like is that her ratings were higher than Protik's. It makes no sense.

I think Diwakar and Sameer are brilliant. Especially Sameer has an incredibly unique and powerful voice.

I don't think it's fair to start criticizing all the other contestants to make Neha look like she was amazing. From the girls , I feel Sanchita and Pawni are brilliant. That's my opinion. no offence meant.

Neha is not the best But Judgement has to be done on basis of that week performance.Or else it would b liked a scripted draama where the participant who is going out is known prior to their performance...

That day Neha Was definitely better than Protik,Not only that but Neha had shown consistency in improvement..

Ofcourse Sanchita is the best among girls(until now).Pavni is good but inconsistent like Ujjaini in CHallenge-2005 (There are few songs of Ujjaini when she performed better than Nihira,Himani in that particular episode,To mention Koi Sehri babu was better than Dafliwale and DUniya mein was better than Nisha of hIMANI.But we all (including me)Have first pref to Nihira,Himani and then to Ujjaini as they were consitett than Ujjaini)

Shraddha's Is going down in each perfoormance,I hope that she bounces back with "sol baras" kind of song...

CLearly Among the girls Neha and Gurupreet are the weakest link.

But accding to perf Neha was definitely better than Protik ,Sameer and Divakar on that day.....(I am not taking in total)

I haven't watched this episode yet but i must say its a huge surprise to hear that Neha is out. She's a talented performer and its a waste she's out so early when other less talented singers are still in the running.

Originally posted by: zestinkiest

I haven't watched this episode yet but i must say its a huge surprise to hear that Neha is out. She's a talented performer and its a waste she's out so early when other less talented singers are still in the running.

Actually Armaan Whom we had thought to be a waste candidate showed his real talent.He was Excellent in chand Chupa,Protik gave the worst performance last week..(But Protik has talent,We know it)

Originally posted by: ranig

I didn't find Neha that good and thought Protik was overall better than her.

But, what I did not like is that her ratings were higher than Protik's. It makes no sense.

I think Diwakar and Sameer are brilliant. Especially Sameer has an incredibly unique and powerful voice.

I don't think it's fair to start criticizing all the other contestants to make Neha look like she was amazing. From the girls , I feel Sanchita and Pawni are brilliant. That's my opinion. no offence meant.

I know my post SOUNDS like i am criticising others just because neha is out....but i honestly meant what i said. I alwz felt that while other female contestants have a powerful , somewhat husky voice (pawni, shraddha and most of all gurpreet.....), neha had a sweet voice. Ofcourse its my personal opinion to chose neha's voice over other contestants (eg i cant understand how "rat hamari to" from gurpreet deserves 2a+ and a and neha gets b from alka).

But what i really didnt like was the WAY she was ousted..after getting better grades.. the uncharacteristic harsh comment from alka.

and even when they pronounced that she was out (which they did indirectly by declaring protik in), their concentration remained with protik (by telling him, "this was a warning for u"..blah blah).

no final adieu, no boost up.....not that neha needs it but courtseys sake.

i remain with the sneaky feeling that this was pre-determined.

I totally agree with u.
Basing on thsi only I started a topic the very next day when she was eliminate....but to my surprise very less people reacted...
Anyways I am happy there are many people who think the way I though.
"RIGHT WILLL ALWAYS BE RIGHT"

I agree with you completely . Neha was wrongly eleminated, the judges do seem to have already decided about the candidates and are not going as per their performances on those two days (thurs, Fri). Alka Yagnik was harsh in her comments. Very discouraging for Neha.

We need new judges on top of these judges every week now.