Neha verma and Judges - Page 2

I agree with u.She was better than some other contestant.I was shocked that Neha is out. She had a nice voice and she improved alot.

I agree....her elimination was bit surprising! Neha was better than atleast couple of participants in that week.

Of all the singers, Sanchita is most consitant and very melodious and then comes Pawni and Shraddha. I placed Neha as fourth in melody and consistancy. I am also surprised to find her go. even Protik predicted that his performance was not up to the standard and expected to be out. It seems to me that there is no value for these grades. Armaan, Sameer Mohammad, Gurupreet will fall one by one. I do not like Sameer's tactics of attracting judges attention. I heard Abhrokanti today on 28th July eposode. I found out that he was having problem raisign his voice to higher octave. If he continues to have that problem, I will have change my opinion on him.

I was really disappointed to see Neha go. The judges were biased especially Alka. Neha picked out an old song and she gave a wonderful performance. Seems like all the judges favorite is Gurpreet. Judges should not be biased, judge on voice quality rather than focusing on the age factor.

Who should have been eliminated this week? Protik got more points than Diwakar.. Now, again is it the same issue?

I think Neha didn't deserve to leave so early. Protik proved earlier with Mast song that he can sing well. If I were a judge, I would let Gurpreet go in that episode. I feel like Gurpreet is overrated for some reason.

Last thursday and friday I watched LC and Neha's elimination. I found Neha sang well and got good grade, better than Pratik (gradewise). Even at the end when they were asked who would be out, Pratik said he would be the one. But the way Abhijeet jumped while announcing.....
My question is what is the basis of elemination.. is it on grade or judges sweet wish!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I feel sorry for these young ones, may be this will create a deep affect on their confidence.

Yes agree with you. She is a victim of favoritism. Armaan should have been gone with flawed notes, Gurpreet being the youngest is the star of attraction(TRP).

I have noticed one thing judges are more partial towards the contestants whom initially and individually they selected. Alkaji finds fault and corrects by singing with those who are likely to go soon. She thinks Gurpreet did justice while Neha did not!!!

When Armaan was doing so-so, they(Alka, Abhijeet) praised him highly but the selection job of Armaan was done by Bappi Lahiri in the last two episodes. May be they wanted to stay away from any controvery of favoring him because of his famiy connections.

I read all the responses and most of us think that these terrible trio judges are somewhat biased.
I strongly think that they should have some other judges everyweek - so they can give unbiased judgement....
terrible trio can commnet - but cannot decide on elimination. New judges should decide that.

i feel that protik shud have been out rather that neha. i think comparatively in the last epi neha sang better. i agree with whatever alkaji said, but i think she cud have atleast given her an "A" however even neha shud understand that the choice of song was wrong and she cud have chosen an easier song...in which she was more comfortable singing. but now that shes out, its sad