Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 16 - Page 113

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

76.5k

Users

37

Likes

8.6k

Frequent Posters

Coolmeg thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team Mannat

Posted: 3 months ago

Trust is foundation of any relationship and Mannat is asking all right questions…. Why does he always need proof. Granted no one would believe an outsider against his mom. That’s why he is being tested… he wants a confession but he clearly sees that his mom dislikes Mannat. Why would he think all will be okay just confess…. That’s twisted!!

Vikrant needs to get off his high horse and start to introspect !

on another note
I don’t mind this slow pace as long as I get Vikrant and Mannat together… fight love kill each other for all I care… just be together on the screen Adnan and Ayesha are really awesome to watch together!!!


Edited by Coolmeg - 3 months ago
wuthering thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 3 months ago

Right? It’s frustrating to even think we are spending more time on analyzing these characters when the writers are are not spending even half the time we are on maintaining character growth and sketch.

Rosyme thumbnail

Team Mannat

Posted: 3 months ago

Trp increased a bit i think. So they may feel this is working and so dragging i guess.

Now ipl s over so next week we will know the actual trp. If it increases tracks may be better.

Saichintalli thumbnail
Rocker Thumbnail 5th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 months ago

Bare with me.... this is gone be loooong......

I know I am gone get lot of chapals for what I am gone say and I don't mind... Chapal he phekna hai tho costly wala pheklena vo bhi pairs mei 😂😂

Now coming to the point... For past two days I really don't get mannath's trust nahi kartha blame.... Arre wait Abhi chappal nahi... Marne ka time ayega... First listen to me ....

See in whole situation I really felt vikranth did wrong but for not trusting his mom ... His mistake is he was silent when neetu is badmouting and pointing on her parvarish, he did wrong for asking mannath to say sorry, he did wrong for not trying to find the truth , not trying to go after doctor.... But he didn't do any wrong for trusting his mom.... Who and why will he blame his mom specially when she did promised on him ...

Will mannath trust vikranth over his mom...again I really want to and also wanted vikranth to highlight the point that " even he did believe in mannath when everyone else are blaming her for poison cake" isn't it comes under trust....when mannath brought up pendrive kaand...

Mannath can't listen a single word against her mom then how can she expect from vikranth to believe her and agree that his mom is spiking the drink.... She herself said to harneet that he will believe his mom.... But again expecting she believes her without any proof...

Really why and what did he do to get a tag of not trustworthy....

Let me ask 3 questions

1. For example if vikranth comes and tells mannath all this while shruthi is wrong , her birth mother is innocent and shruthi kidnapped mannath .. will she believe vikranth?

2. Let's say, manvik ka shadi hogaya and after few years manvik daughter blames mannath that she is spiking vikranth.... Should vikranth believe his daughter and blame mannath?

3. Let say hypothetically neetu is very nice lady ... Mannath misunderstood and blaming her , in this case if vikranth believes mannath and blames his mother .... Is it ok?

If any of this questions answer yes then I will also believe he is not trustworthy

I myself agree he is dumb, being idiot for not standing up for mannath when neetu talking shit, putting her into emotional trauma when she is already suffering with a lot .... But not trustworthy.... I don't agree ....

That's why I really liked the questions asked by mannath after Sunitha death.. " why he is not standing up when everyone blaming her or badmouting about her pervarisha .. why he is not looking or trying to find truth ..."

But I really didn't like her keep on saying he is not trusting her or he is not trustworthy in front of malla or today ....

Even now I say vikranth deserves all bashing he is getting , for executing this idiotic plan without telling her his feelings in first place and ignoring her questions ...but not trustworthy is something I don't get it.

Ok I am done ... Now chappals are welcome ...

Ps: branded+ in pairs + beautiful are only acceptable

Edited by Saichintalli - 3 months ago
Coolmeg thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team Mannat

Posted: 3 months ago

I don’t agree that episode are dragging …. They are finally bringing Mallas character out…

Like I said Vikrant cannot just expect Mannat to confess when he has not been able to trust her or convince his mom that Mannat is who he loves. He is truly living in lalaland … in his defense he’s in love and he’s not able to think anything other then Mannat!!! It’s hard to explain I feel bad for Vikrant and at same time I feel kya gadha hai. How many times people in love have always thought ek baar woh haan karde mein apni mom/parents koh mana lunga

regarding this ARS and Mannats spy attitude… it’s only to be seen on what Mannat really wants!!

I thought I won’t enjoy episodes but to the contrary I am liking how they are addressing some basic foundational issues on two people falling in love…. Just because destiny brought them together doesn’t mean they get it all easily!

trust and don’t ever let third person intervene … those are what I feel is the motto now!!

Edited by Coolmeg - 3 months ago
wuthering thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 3 months ago

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Frustrating episode. Mainly because, everyone seems to be jumping in the same place. I can't make out head nor tail of which conspiracy is going to be unearthed..each one is making very half hearted, pointless, and may I add, brainless efforts.

- Vikrant has thought of this wonderful, experiential method of proving how trustworthy he issmiley29, by asking Mannat to jump into his arms, from a height!! Mannu gives it to him, teaches him by another example of what trust means. She also asks him if he loves Malla, now he wants to know why she wants to know if he loves Mallasmiley26, why does she doubt it. Convo goes nowhere.

- Neetu is determinedly trying to give her tablet to Vikku. And walks menacingly towards the store room. Mannu acts like her normal clumsy, vague self and knocks it over.

- Malla is being her villainous self, plans the chunri kaand, and laughs like one of Ekta's old villains. Kya yaar?? Where is the modern touch to this show? And just her saying 'Aww, aww' at every sentence someone speaks doesn't show her contemporary, London returned persona.

- Neetu and Ronnie have an argument. Ronnies warns her that she's going to destroy Vikku's life by getting him married to Malla.

- Mannat finds Neetu's little bag, and throws out the medicine.

- Engagement evening...Vikku smiles happily, but obviously to make up for it, the director makes him look for Mannat, Ronnie notices.

- Malla sees Mannat walking out and wants to stop her because her plan needs to work...'Awww'. smiley24

I can give you guys tomorrow's update.

Malla will call Mannat on some pretext. Chunri will be discovered, Mannat will be blamed. Neetu will bad mouth her, Ronnie will look upset, Gagan will look upset and acc to the BTS, he at least vocally supports Mannat. ARS will add her bit. Vikku will stand, looking stunned, and in his mind he will say " Bol do, Ms Mannat, ki tumhe mujhpe bharosa hai, phir dekhna, main tumhe duniya ki saari khushiyaan de doonga".

And only when Neetu tries to throw her out the door, he will wake up out of his stupor and stop.

There will be a Manvik scene and conversation that increasingly I feel is manipulating us to watch the episodes. No Manvik conversation had led to Vikrant using his grey cells , in this track.

Sorry for the rant...now the repeated tropes are irritating. Are the writers on leave?? Why are all the scenes written in such a listless manner. Like they have been copied and pasted, with a few cosmetic changes.

I love this team, if they are stalking us, but they are truly taking fans too much for granted.

I blame the writing team completely, the actors are all doing their jobs very well. They have so many open tracks, and they are not moving forward even on one track. Nor are they giving us an indication of any new track.

Other top shows move so quickly into different tracks...I hate to compare. but I also know that this team is excellent and even if they do move into different tracks, they will excel, and be much better than others.

But why this bored kind of writing???

I’m sorry but your prediction for tomorrows episode is such a hoot! Especially Vikrants inner monologue has me in splits. I 💯 agree this is what is going to happen. You have nailed it. Tip of the hat to you!


Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 3 months ago

@Sai

I agree on point no 3 somewhat...

Mannat has never tried to find out why Neetu is giving the medicine... she herself is aware how much Neetu loves Vik... so why would she harm her own son? Ek baar bhi nahi socha???

She did say earlier and even today that I don't know why Neetu is doing this...

To behen jab tere haath medicine lagi thi to test karvati???? Kisi Doctor se poochti ki ye kya hai???

Dustbin main kyun daal diya... ya Vikku ko hi de deti ki dekho tumhari Maa ke purse main mila... ab ise check karao smiley44



This is simply an exercise in increasing episode number 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 3 months ago

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

I don’t agree that episode are dragging …. They are finally bringing Mallas character out…

Like I said Vikrant cannot just expect Mannat to confess when he has not been able to trust her or convince his mom that Mannat is who he loves. He is truly living in lalaland … in his defense he’s in love and he’s not able to think anything other then Mannat!!! It’s hard to explain I feel bad for Vikrant and at same time I feel kya gadha hai. How many times people in love have always thought ek baar woh haan karde mein apni mom/parents koh mana lunga

regarding this ARS and Mannats spy attitude… it’s only to be seen on what Mannat really wants!!

I thought I won’t enjoy episodes but to the contrary I am liking how they are addressing some basic foundational issues on two people falling in love…. Just because destiny brought them together doesn’t mean they get it all easily!

trust and don’t ever let third person intervene … those are what I feel is the motto now!!

@bold is exactly what I feel he is doing... and thats why I can give him some leeway...

@red... I am surprised 😆😆😆

@blue... perfectly put 👏

Coolmeg thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team Mannat

Posted: 3 months ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

@Sai

I agree on point no 3 somewhat...

Mannat has never tried to find out why Neetu is giving the medicine... she herself is aware how much Neetu loves Vik... so why would she harm her own son? Ek baar bhi nahi socha???

She did say earlier and even today that I don't know why Neetu is doing this...

To behen jab tere haath medicine lagi thi to test karvati???? Kisi Doctor se poochti ki ye kya hai???

Dustbin main kyun daal diya... ya Vikku ko hi de deti ki dekho tumhari Maa ke purse main mila... ab ise check karao smiley44



This is simply an exercise in increasing episode number 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Exactly what I thought when she threw in dustbin ….

She also says in monologue that pehle mein ARS kah mamla khatam karu … so she isn’t really thinking of reasons why Neetu is giving meds

Resham thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 3 months ago

I loved Saichin and Megs analysis....and mostly agree to it as well....for me the thing is they aren't showing Vikku using his brain cells..not even one percent of it and another is he behaving so dumb to follow Malla...couldn't he see this as well that MaMa are not that great ever since the Holi night...I would blame the writers here....fine...go slow..this is a soap but make it crisp as well....

Seriously if not for the actors who are really good and AA I would have not taken this show for viewing...Adnan Ayesha is the core and the gems of the show....but writing thoda better karo....

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 26 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission by Leprecheun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 25 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission by Leprecheun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 8 months ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer · 2 months ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 24 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".