Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 8 - Page 70

Originally posted by: Moor278

So I am yet to watch last 2 episodes... and reading all the comments and discussions... I don't want to..

Now Mukta is refuting the claims that it's not an IPL track when it does look like it... or they are waiting for TRP tomm to decide whether to continue...

I am amazed that the writers thought of introducing a second necklace and have it in Raveenas possession (since she lives in London most of the time)... but they haven't thought of how Mannat sees the picture.

Mannat was sleeping in the outhouse... a considerable distance from the main house as can be imagined by Viks long walk... yet she could hear Punnu shouting. That girl didn't even brush her teeth and went and did all the road side drama...

Similarly she has been sitting on that huge piece of evidence without handing it over to the police... what was the point in waiting for next morning? Police stations are supposed to work 24x7 right???

Another point is what I have read is Mannat is fighting a battle no one ... not even the victim wants her to fight... The makers want ARS vs Mannat (per their April promo) but making Vik an unfortunate victim... this might work in shedding his BKB image but doesn't help his character at all

Now it seems like only Shalini has to come up and speak the truth or Raveena Bobby have to slip off something for Vik to start investigating again...

There's not much logic left to the proceedings anymore 😢 and like Lost days... The writing team is having a break in between... which is leading to odd continuity and edits.

Bold- I am not understanding this.

Mannat hearing Punnu shouting was for her to see his phone wallpaper and police station is not open 24x7 in Mannat world, in short logic mat dhundho.

Mannat said to Harneet that a lot of things happened that she forgot about the necklace. At that point Derek has been arrested as culprit with evidence and it is still a doubt could the real culprit be someone from Saluja/RaiSingh family. She was planning to discuss the Shalini's reaction and evidence with Vikrant first, its about his restaurant staff and family too. But..then the panic attack and she fell asleep. When she found out the necklace is Bobby's, stopping him from leaving India is more urgent..she was too absorbed, that she didnt had time to freshen up.

Mannat said na even Shruti will tell her to stand by the right thing, Shruti let go of marriage and own kids to raise her. Also she doesnt want Bobby to attack another girl and get the innocent Derek out of jail. She is fighting for all the other victims and girls out there. Till now Vikrant is not messed up, he is going by proof and Shalini's word.

Agree about the continuity and edit. It feels like so much happens in one day of Mannat world.

Ab sab Sahi hoga. Mata Rani in the house.

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

Exactly. If Vikrant comes to know, he will go to the police station along with Mannat. Shalini will also have the confidence since none of the Salujas and ARS will blackmail. Open and shut plot.

Mannat has a bloody neck piece as a solid proof. She is sitting on it for some days now instead of submitting it to the police. Isn’t this a clear sign of deliberate screenplay.

If they don’t get the desired TRP, they will wrap up by next week.

Agree! He is both clueless and powerful in this track, and TRP will decide whether he will continue to be clueless or use his power.

It is funny, The Salujas want to hide from him, Mannat wants him to see the truth. The track is focused on that only.

How will Vikrant believe Mannat when Shalini has never changed her statement from the start. She maintains it is Derek. Even in the upcoming press conference, she won’t implicate Bow Bee.

Mannat showed the bloodied necklace as proof. But Raveena counters that by saying Bobby's necklace is with her... shows a second necklace.

Through Neetu it is told that Neetu had gifted them 2 identical necklaces (with gun locket) 25 years ago... my point is what are the chances that Raveena has both of them with her on a trip to India????

That's why I was questioning the writing... ki kaam ki chijo ko justify karte hai through dialogues... but some things are very odd.

But as you said... logic mat dhundo

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

Ab sab Sahi hoga. Mata Rani in the house.

Tum dhanya hoon

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

How will Vikrant believe Mannat when Shalini has never changed her statement from the start. She maintains it is Derek. Even in the upcoming press conference, she won’t implicate Bow Bee.

I know... that's why I said Raveena or Bobby has to slip... Varna to isi loop main rahenge

Originally posted by: Moor278

I know... that's why I said Raveena or Bobby has to slip... Varna to isi loop main rahenge

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

How will Vikrant believe Mannat when Shalini has never changed her statement from the start. She maintains it is Derek. Even in the upcoming press conference, she won’t implicate Bow Bee.

Best end would be Vikrant waking up from sleep and realizing this was a horrifying dream

Originally posted by: Taiyo

Just a thought, it is the press conference where the Bobby's truth is revealed. Like the engagement episode, where Aishwarya ( also, Bobby and his wife) thinks everything is in her control and then the truth comes out.

I mean, who has a press conference on an on-going case, when one ‘suspect’ is already arrested but not gone to trail…… what would be the purpose of this PC? Has Mannat made it public that Derick is innocent and Bobby is the suspect? Even if it’s before or after the kidnapping……?

And aren’t SA victims given some for of anonymity or privacy from the alleged perpetrator until it goes to court ( a scarf over your face is hardly that).

These bts clips are actually traumatising because we aren’t seeing the context within the episode imho