Sai Ketan Rao | ASC | AT 7 | Just sutup ki Uncle - Page 45

Originally posted by: PSharada

The episode went bouncer for me. Maybe someone else can decode it better. Surya threatens that he is going to kill Chaudhary family members and he tells Imlie that he has mixed poison in the lemon juice he sent with Jugnu. Imlie gets scared and runs down without the veil and gets exposed. Surya then pretends that he doesn't know what he is talking about and acts as if he is innocent.

Imlie tries to tell the family members that Surya is acting and he looks like Agastya but is not Agastya. Imlie also tells that she came here only because babu wanted it and whatever it might have been my love for babu was real. Sigh the family still needs convincing that Imlie truly loved Agastya. Pathetic family. Anyway Binni does chance pe dance and provokes the family. Finally Imlie moves out of the house.

Surya has made legal papers which gives him right over the top floor of the mansion and gives the ground floor of the mansion back to Chaudhary's and tells them to live in the house with him. Alka is the only one who is against this idea and wants to go away. Sonali catches on the nervousness of Alka. She immediately calls up Amar - Not going to lie, I am really glad that the creatives have kept Amar ka track open and it is such a good feeling to see the guy on screen.

Amar is angry that Sonali did not contact him for 1.5 months. So it has been 1.5 months since the accident. Sonali tells Amar that she needs to find out about Sarla nurse in the hospital. The reception declines to help Sonali but Amar gets a ruse to help Sonali meet the nurse. Creatives better give a happy ending for Sonali with Amar. He is the one who truly can keep Sonali content and happy. The way he was authoritatively questioning that even she needs someone to take care of her - Please give this guy some more screen space and weave a story alongside.

Imlie decides that she will go away from Purwaiya as Surya is going to trouble the chaudhary's more if she is there. She decides to go by the night train. Surya comes to Imlie's place and ties her cot to his jeep and drives away.

What I don't understand is why is Surya doing all this if he is Agastya in disguise. Does Agastya not want anyone to even have an ounce of doubt that he is Surya in disguise. If he acts concerned for the family or Imlie it would be dead giveaway that he is Agastya. So is that the reason why he is acting so rude to Imlie because Imlie is the only one who can doubt him. Someone please help me explain.

The tashan between Surya and Imlie was good and alongside it was a pleasant surprise to see Sonali with Amar.

Well the straight-forward explanation is that- this, indeed, is Surya, trying to take revenge and find his BIL...

But, of course we are not going to believe that so here is what I think was going on-

I think Agastya/Surya had 2 things in mind- one is, if he had just come and given Choudhary's their home and kept some for himself so he could live together, it would feel super-suspicious to anyone with two brain cells...and here we are talking about some killer who tried to kill Agastya..so of course, he had to do it in some tedha way...and divert the attention from the fact that he ended up giving the house to Choudharys. Also, anyone looking will immediately think that, if this is Agastya, he is going to have the softest corner for Imlie and wouldn't trouble her at all..so to not raise suspicions, he started khulla dushmani with Imlie..now nobody will wonder if he is Agastya... Second is- he didn't want Imlie to suffer as a house help..he, obviously, wants her around and has figured out a way for her to stay closeby (that's what he reassured Malti) but he couldn't see her suffering...

There were a couple of moments when the camera went to Agastya's face and he had that kind of "trying to read the situation" wala look...I dunno how to explain that..he was like evaluating how his plan is working out..how is everyone reacting..also a look as if, he knows some things but has to act like he doesnt know types...This has to be Agastya...

As for how audience will react abt him suffering Imlie..I think CVs count on TRP audience ki short term memory...that's how they get away with frequent plot changes, loopholes and illogical twists!!

Originally posted by: PSharada

Yes I can not root for Imlie to be with Surya - Not after the way he played the trick on her to expose herself in front of the family members. The creatives better walk back a little if they are intending to show it is Agastya with some memory loss as otherwise it will not sit well with the audience. Imlie is doing her level best to keep the family safe and this guy comes in and gets her humiliated - What for ?

I was really happy when Imlie finally accepted defeat and wanted to move away from Purwaiya. She deserves better. Somehow I feel they are going with Surya being Agastya with memory loss. Because nothing else makes sense. How can you stand there and see your love getting insulted like this.

And the team better cut some happy promos. The episode and the promo both were very disturbing for me today. Not sure of the audience because the tracks in the top trp shows are even pathetic than this but I for one couldn't see Imlie getting hurt everyday like this.

Originally posted by: Gimmeitt

I agree with each & evry word you said. Honestly speaking, I felt the same thing yesterday as well.There was something which made me uncomfortable with their scenes, I can't put my finger on it. But yes, memory loss is the best option if they don't want to play with audience's emotions & ruin the essence of characters.

Yes Memory loss is the only option I felt they have left. Agastya would never stand by and get Imlie insulted like this. No reason is strong enough for Agastya to hide his identity and be quiet when Imlie is said all these kadwii baatein and he stands there alone smirking.

Even when Imlie was his contract wife and a bar singer Agastya protected her honor and even made Chintamani and his family disappear as they were about to expose Imlie's secret as bar singer. He could not take Imlie signing in the bar after she was thrown out after Amrit's blackmail.

I can not take that this Surya is the same Agastya - no he is not and the creatives have succeeded in convincing me that this is Surya and not Agastya.

Is it possible that this is the real Surya & Agastya is somewhere else, possibly in coma or recovering, & he will come back on imlie-surya's wedding day & probably stop them from getting married. But then what about Surya's scars & headaches??

I'm so confused right now!!

Originally posted by: MJHTMonayaSajan

Well the straight-forward explanation is that- this, indeed, is Surya, trying to take revenge and find his BIL...

But, of course we are not going to believe that so here is what I think was going on-

I think Agastya/Surya had 2 things in mind- one is, if he had just come and given Choudhary's their home and kept some for himself so he could live together, it would feel super-suspicious to anyone with two brain cells...and here we are talking about some killer who tried to kill Agastya..so of course, he had to do it in some tedha way...and divert the attention from the fact that he ended up giving the house to Choudharys. Also, anyone looking will immediately think that, if this is Agastya, he is going to have the softest corner for Imlie and wouldn't trouble her at all..so to not raise suspicions, he started khulla dushmani with Imlie..now nobody will wonder if he is Agastya... Second is- he didn't want Imlie to suffer as a house help..he, obviously, wants her around and has figured out a way for her to stay closeby (that's what he reassured Malti) but he couldn't see her suffering...

There were a couple of moments when the camera went to Agastya's face and he had that kind of "trying to read the situation" wala look...I dunno how to explain that..he was like evaluating how his plan is working out..how is everyone reacting..also a look as if, he knows some things but has to act like he doesnt know types...This has to be Agastya...

As for how audience will react abt him suffering Imlie..I think CVs count on TRP audience ki short term memory...that's how they get away with frequent plot changes, loopholes and illogical twists!!

The thing is they need to start showing something better coz the track is super upsetting right now. One day we are enjoying Surya Imlie scenes and one day it feels repulsive.

Originally posted by: PSharada

Yes Memory loss is the only option I felt they have left. Agastya would never stand by and get Imlie insulted like this. No reason is strong enough for Agastya to hide his identity and be quiet when Imlie is said all these kadwii baatein and he stands there alone smirking.

Even when Imlie was his contract wife and a bar singer Agastya protected her honor and even made Chintamani and his family disappear as they were about to expose Imlie's secret as bar singer. He could not take Imlie signing in the bar after she was thrown out after Amrit's blackmail.

I can not take that this Surya is the same Agastya - no he is not and the creatives have succeeded in convincing me that this is Surya and not Agastya.

If he is Surya why does he want to marry Imlie. There are better ways to get to the truth about the jeeja as he is a cop. If you noticed, he pretended before Imlie that he didn’t know he looks like Agastya (the confrontation outside the station where he had hidden the picture ) and before the family too. So I am pretty sure this is Agastya (Surya is probably dead).

Originally posted by: MJHTMonayaSajan

Well the straight-forward explanation is that- this, indeed, is Surya, trying to take revenge and find his BIL...

But, of course we are not going to believe that so here is what I think was going on-

I think Agastya/Surya had 2 things in mind- one is, if he had just come and given Choudhary's their home and kept some for himself so he could live together, it would feel super-suspicious to anyone with two brain cells...and here we are talking about some killer who tried to kill Agastya..so of course, he had to do it in some tedha way...and divert the attention from the fact that he ended up giving the house to Choudharys. Also, anyone looking will immediately think that, if this is Agastya, he is going to have the softest corner for Imlie and wouldn't trouble her at all..so to not raise suspicions, he started khulla dushmani with Imlie..now nobody will wonder if he is Agastya... Second is- he didn't want Imlie to suffer as a house help..he, obviously, wants her around and has figured out a way for her to stay closeby (that's what he reassured Malti) but he couldn't see her suffering...

There were a couple of moments when the camera went to Agastya's face and he had that kind of "trying to read the situation" wala look...I dunno how to explain that..he was like evaluating how his plan is working out..how is everyone reacting..also a look as if, he knows some things but has to act like he doesnt know types...This has to be Agastya...

As for how audience will react abt him suffering Imlie..I think CVs count on TRP audience ki short term memory...that's how they get away with frequent plot changes, loopholes and illogical twists!!

I know the creatives are walking a very thin line

They have to convince the audience that this is Surya who is there to find his BIL and he is troubling Imlie because he has heard her "Hey Radha Rani" on the voice call of his BIL. They have pretty much convinced me of that part.

What I am not able to understand is how are the creatives going to show that this is Agastya and not Surya in the end ? What if Surya is the one who died that day and the mother and the sister got Agastya home and are making him believe that he is Surya and not Agastya. So actually the one who is missing and dead is Surya and Agastya is under memory loss and in the end it will be revealed that Agastya got his memory back after staying in the Chaudhary house.

Nothing else makes sense at this moment not after the warm fuzzy cute love story Agastya and Imlie had. Never did Agastya demean or insult Imlie this bad. They had their fights and their name calling but it was in private and not as a public tamasha. That is what hurts me in today's episode. That the whole humiliation of Imlie was in front of the family.

Girls, it’s just a few days since Surya came in. This track is about whether he is Agasthya or Surya. If Surya is shown going soft then there is no plot left.

The makers will take it to the extreme to test the viewer’s reactions. After all this is a ITV show. They still need to decide on the story further.

Thoda patience toh rakhna padega.

Originally posted by: Gimmeitt

Is it possible that this is the real Surya & Agastya is somewhere else, possibly in coma or recovering, & he will come back on imlie-surya's wedding day & probably stop them from getting married. But then what about Surya's scars & headaches??

I'm so confused right now!!

Someone died that day and it was very conclusive for the family and Imlie to accept that Agastya died. So I am thinking maybe Surya died and Surya's family has taken Agastya home and trying to make him accept that he is Surya. I am not sure what the creatives want to show. They better give some hints to the audience at least. Otherwise the audience is going to move away from the show.

Originally posted by: sai2311

Girls, it’s just a few days since Surya came in. This track is about whether he is Agasthya or Surya. If Surya is shown going soft then there is no plot left.

The makers will take it to the extreme to test the viewer’s reactions. After all this is a ITV show. They still need to decide on the story further.

Thoda patience toh rakhna padega.

Agree with what you are saying. But the point is that the extreme is becoming too extreme for me to even enjoy Surya - Imlie scenes. Today's scene was so not needed given that Imlie is going to come back in tomorrow's episode due to Surya's blackmail.(as per the script leak of Jugnu)

So Surya is going to get Imlie in the house back as his maid and the family is not going to say anything. And Surya is again going to taunt Imlie saying she is coming back even after getting insulted. What was the whole point of this tamasha if she has to come back the same day. He could have allowed Imlie in the house as Paro only na.