Maddam Sir - EDT #1 - CLOSED! - Page 42

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

54k

Users

19

Likes

2.8k

Frequent Posters

rinki_99 thumbnail
Screen Detective 2 Participant Thumbnail Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 4 years ago


People on Twitter have been analyzing on this angle that memory loss can also be a drama. Let's see how makers proceed with this


if she is presenting again, MPT is going to be really hurt.


I asked same question to my mom while watching. And if he was this possessive for his fake girlfriend, how would he be to his real wife smiley5 But I too liked Urmi's reaction to all his actions. She would never want to see him again in this life smiley37


expanded on the other post!


Cheetah, baby, your mind needs break from your Santu Ji to start functioning again


BWHAHHAHAHAHAH


The BTS for this scene was better again


has it been posted on the forum? i wanna see!


Phir se aap lalla ko le aayi or phir se aapne unke bhaag phod diye smiley37 Poor lalla and his bhagya


deepika di needs to add this to the iconic dialogues post!


Ikr! She remembers Urmila but not mission, Bakshi, Haseena's thoughts. This is the rarest memory loss I saw on ITV


inspired by yours truly ekta mata!


Might be because HM got unconscious before revealing the entire truth and Karishma saw her dying with her own eyes so her mind is playing games with her. She is confused what to believe. Moreover people around her desperately making her believe that she is Urmi


she did give enough proof for Karishma to believe her real identity tho. the mannerisms, trusting her with the pen drive, the poem, shooting a gun and that entire sequence really. but mind game is fair enough.


Seems to be good idea

yep

Anee2 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: LogicLover

Today's episode was much better in terms of execution than the previous ones. And I noticed these days people are only criticizing everywhere including me so for a change I won't do that today.

Thanks for holding onto the positives. We have such high expectations from this show that our reactions might often be exaggerated compared to rest of ITV. Execution was certainly better.

I liked the issue they addressed this time. Love demands personal space no matter how important and irreplaceable part of your life the person is. And it's equally important in any relationship. Of course the love that man had for his wife was not toxic but still it's difficult to breathe in such relations.

Definitely, the issue is a very good one, and addresses a balance that many couples probabaly struggle to find. Love is all about understanding each other, knowing when/where to pull in or let loose on the connecting thread. I just think it could've been explored much better and taken more seriously if not forcefully merged with haseena's memory loss.

I knew Urmi wasn't going anywhere smiley37 but the bargaining scene reminded me of my mom.

I was hoping someone had the true bargaining skills to drag it to one or other extreme. That would've been hilarious.

The scene between Urmi and Karthik at HM's house was quite comical. Urmi still was patient with him. If someone wakes me up while I'm sleeping, I'd have scratched his face. The man was literally a leech who doesn't leaves you even for second.

Yea I'd have swatted my hands around, with my eyes still closed. I will not let anyone disturb my sleep.

Thank you Karishma for reminding us that our beloved Cheetah Chaturvedi is a women psychologist. But what a brilliant use of skills smiley32 He is the only psychiatrist who refers his patient to Akela Baba. Karishma rightly said, "Asshiqui mein na tum baura gaye ho"

Aaj kal kuch zyaada hi aashiqui aagayi hai 🤔


But I agree to Urmi, along with the husband, the girl too was messed up smiley44I don't know how to find her a perfect husband who has all the qualities according to her checklist smiley23

Yea this was the point where this case felt much more legitimate and serious. Both husband and wife have an unhealthy approach to their relationship, and that makes things interesting to solve. Perfection takes practice, ya toh keep practicing with new guys, ya to practice making this one perfect 😆


Finally, moving to best part of today's episode. Karishma has starting doubting Urmi. Finally her cop instincts are kicking in. I loved how Pushpa Ji is always there to support her. I just hope Karishma doesn't get influenced by others around her.

The saas-bahu are sukoon! Despite my annoyance at karishma being a tubelight, pushpa ji's look of warmth and care was palpable through the screen. Made me think, koi nahi, sab theek ho jaayega.

LogicLover thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: rinki_99


People on Twitter have been analyzing on this angle that memory loss can also be a drama. Let's see how makers proceed with this


if she is presenting again, MPT is going to be really hurt.


Although I doubt this is going to be true. She doesn't seem to be HM at all. And why now when she almost revealed the truth to Karishma. What could have changed between falling unconscious and waking up at hospital 🤔

I asked same question to my mom while watching. And if he was this possessive for his fake girlfriend, how would he be to his real wife smiley5 But I too liked Urmi's reaction to all his actions. She would never want to see him again in this life smiley37


expanded on the other post!


Cheetah, baby, your mind needs break from your Santu Ji to start functioning again


BWHAHHAHAHAHAH


The BTS for this scene was better again


has it been posted on the forum? i wanna see!

Guess not. Will find out and post that


Phir se aap lalla ko le aayi or phir se aapne unke bhaag phod diye smiley37 Poor lalla and his bhagya


deepika di needs to add this to the iconic dialogues post!


Ikr! She remembers Urmila but not mission, Bakshi, Haseena's thoughts. This is the rarest memory loss I saw on ITV


inspired by yours truly ekta mata!


Virus of Ekta Maa spreads faster than covid 😆


Might be because HM got unconscious before revealing the entire truth and Karishma saw her dying with her own eyes so her mind is playing games with her. She is confused what to believe. Moreover people around her desperately making her believe that she is Urmi


she did give enough proof for Karishma to believe her real identity tho. the mannerisms, trusting her with the pen drive, the poem, shooting a gun and that entire sequence really. but mind game is fair enough.

I'm hoping they just wrap it up by next week somehow. If Anubhav could find out the truth then so can MPT, especially Karishma. In fact, they have signs now. They even do not wait for HM to gain her memory back for her to reveal the truth


Seems to be good idea

yep

Chir-Cute thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Was field day today so missed watching the epi. Reading the comments and it seems like maybe not much was missed. Too exhausted. Will watch today's and yesterday's nautanki later and then come to share my disappointments and inshallah some good things. 😆


Meanwhile jao article padho aur comment karo. Hopefully IF delivers our concerns to the team, the next time they go to take their interview.

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/gulki-joshi-of-maddam-sir-the-new-track-is-superbly-exciting_185456?ri=6&rv=6689

Edited by Chir-Cute - 4 years ago
rinki_99 thumbnail
Screen Detective 2 Participant Thumbnail Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 4 years ago

Although I doubt this is going to be true. She doesn't seem to be HM at all. And why now when she almost revealed the truth to Karishma. What could have changed between falling unconscious and waking up at hospital smiley24


I also don’t think it’s possible considering the timeline of events. Plus, Haseena already told karishma the truth so there is no reason to hide it anymore.


Guess not. Will find out and post that


Okie. Thank you.


Virus of Ekta Maa spreads faster than covid smiley36


☠️ Golden words


I'm hoping they just wrap it up by next week somehow. If Anubhav could find out the truth then so can MPT, especially Karishma. In fact, they have signs now. They even do not wait for HM to gain her memory back for her to reveal the truth


They couldn’t do it in a months so I ain’t holding my breathe. But still, I admire your positivity!!

Anee2 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Episode 457, March 24/2022

Today's episode was both written and executed quite nicely. The case ended, and we had important progress in the memory loss track.

Case was resolved in classic HM style. I wish they had addressed the wife's 'perfect' expectations, but they had lectured her about it somewhat in the last episode, so understandable.

HM is now 100% urmila, all the time, so she feels like another comic character altogether. The whole sequence, from her sleeping in the jail to dancing outside was funny (see BTS for more 😆)

Karishma's entry on the bike, her bhaukaal towards bille/cheetah/iqbal (twice😆) felt very very refreshing. It's so amazing to see her in that avatar again, confident and focused.

Regardless of what pushpaji, cheetah or santu said at various stages in the episode, she was clear in her head that urmila is her maddam sir. She feels it and her sixth sense is never wrong (I was so ready to cringe if she said 'ehsaas', but she said 'mehsoos' instead so we're good).

Biggest relief though was, they finally started to address the elephant in the room which we've all been staring at for 2 months - the betrayal! Pushpa ji refused to believe that their maddam sir would ever fool them like that for months. Karishma expressed a brief glimpse of how hurt she is about maddam sir doing this whole drama.

I think karishma's tone and mood today is a mere teaser of the tsunami to follow. She hasn't let the implications of this truth fully sink in. Once haseena's memory returns and she accepts everything is when karishma will completely realize what's been done to her. I can't wait to see how all hell breaks loose at that point. So so glad to see even a glimpse of that today though, it was the emotional highlight for me.

Special mention: the kareena hug (fans being gifted one scene per episode these days 😆). Karishma felt her maddam sir, and urmila flashed back to their first hug from the fairwell party. Cute that this is the first memory she gets back.

Edited by Anee2 - 4 years ago
LogicLover thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 4 years ago

The execution of the episodes are improving now. It's a good progress.

I liked how Karishma solved the case with maturity and in HM's style without anyone forcing her to do so. It came out of her naturally. It was good progress for character's development.

So finally a episode where we had progress with memory loss track. Karishma has started joining the pieces of puzzle and now it's not her assumption, it's her confidence that she is not Urmi but her Maddam Sir. All this time, her Maddam her was infront of her.

Pushpa Ji and Karishma's conversation made me realize that they are not going to take this entire Urmi drama by HM lightly. Pushpa Ji is not ready to believe that her Maddam Sir would have lied to them all this time and so she doesn't want to believe that it's HM, not Urmi.

So slowly Haseena has started getting flashes of her being HM. And the confident smirk on Karishma's face when Haseena addressed her with style and tone like HM 👏 I'm sure soon Karishma is going to find the truth. This also proves Haseena is not faking the memory loss.

I liked how Karishma reprimanded Cheetah, Billu and Iqbal for their foolishness. But Cheetah's explanation did make me emotional. They all have been suffering all this time and Urmi being infront of them just adds to that. I realized that somewhere even rest of the MPT members know she is Haseena. Their subconscious mind has accepted it long back and that's the reason they let her intervene everywhere. But they are refusing to accept it because they do not want to keep their hopes high just to see it break into pieces. They do not want to suffer again. When he said , "Ab hum sab thak chuke hain", I did feel for him.

But Karishma won't let anything or anyone brainwash her now. She knows Urmi is her Maddam Sir and she will prove it.

But the way Karishma taunted Haseena at the end is clear indication that she won't let this go easily. The hurt was evident is her eyes and now she needs answers for every pain she had to go through.

Now coming to precap, I'm trying my best to be positive because I somewhere believe it's same writers and makers who introduce us to these beautiful characters. But I'm not sure if I'll be able to see tomorrow's episode. By now everyone in this forum knows though I love whole MPT, but my inclination toward Haseena is little bit more. And I cannot see the SHO Haseena Mallik dancing in middle of street on 'Chikni Champli'. Earlier when she danced, I was fine with it because she did it within the station but the precap somewhere offended me.They have ruined all the essence, charm and grace this character once carried. This is not the character I've fallen for so hard. It makes me remind of the day when MPT won best thana competition and everyone was celebrating, Haseena came and did just few steps because she was in her uniform. That was the decorum and disciplined this character carried. I just hope they are done with this Urmi now because I'm turning possessive for Haseena Mallik. Just reveal the truth, give us proper confrontation scenes and bring old MPT back.

rinki_99 thumbnail
Screen Detective 2 Participant Thumbnail Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 4 years ago

I...liked today's episode. It was both well written, executed and wasn't completely filler. In fact, it felt like the characters actually knew what they were doing for a change.


The case wrapped up pretty nicely with the couple understanding what it means to find balance and give each other personal space. Though, like anee mentioned the wife's perfect partner image should have been talked about. But that's okay, cause I think they ultimately understood the message. Relationships take time to build and need nurturing with can be done with enough love and assurance.


Now on to the main bulk of the episode, the amnesia.


I love how Karishma has finally realised that this was non-other than haseena malik. she even went as far as to tell the amnesic patient off on her face. she stood firm with her decision no matter what the rest said. I am so delighted to see her back in action with the chasing scene on her bike/foot- daroga Ji is back in action. I appreciated how haseena got back a flash of her actual identity right in the spot where the hug first happened. it's a neat detail. karishma doesn't have concrete proof as of yet and she is already pissed off, rightfully so. when the amnesic patient actually recovers is when she's going to go berserk. also, worth mentioning that she solved the case independently. 👏


but urmilla really needs to tone it down. I get that she doesn't remember anything now but that getting her pushcart back/beating up the drunk man part was still irritating- for me at least.


I was expecting Pushpa Ji or my masumiyat to give a good comeback to her when she was calling them useless (yes, it's partially true but self-respect dude.). BUT, this leads me to the highlight of the episode- more of like a personal epiphany moment but you get the point...I hope you do.


they didn't respond with a witty/snarky/sarcastic comeback because somewhere deep down they do think this could be haseena- they wouldn't disrespect her intentionally.


Pushpa Ji, Santosh and cheetah are truly conflicted- they don't know what to believe. I used to say that as an insult to their intelligence but today, I use it as a statement of my understanding of their state of mind.


I had theorised this wayyyyyy back in another thread. now, I think it wasn't complete gospel.


the madam sir they love, respect, adore and know wouldn't betray them. they believe that woman is not capable to commit an act that is a breach of their trust. to them, if this person is really haseena malik, she would have told them- this is their faith. Pushpa Ji said something along the lines of haseena will not betray them. through this, she once again reiterates the unending conviction she has in haseena and her morals. rather than accepting that madam sir intentionally trampled on their trust, they chose to believe in an act that if true, won't cause pain.


it's not they dont believe that this isn't haseena, it's that they dont want to believe that this is haseena.


the conversation between Karishma and cheetah helped me put things into perspective for me. "thank chuke hain hum." as a viewer I am well beyond my tolerance level. these characters have been living with this woman who is a look-alike of a near and dear one. they watch her every day and remind themselves that this isn't haseena. they are tired of putting up with their charade -pretending that everything is perfect when in actuality, nothing has been the same for the last three months. they know sooner or later it's going to end and when it does, it's going to hurt. but this uncertainty -who this person actually is- has served as the last straw. this is their breaking point, this is rock bottom for them.


it's no longer about who is right or wrong. it's about what the cost of this whole conflict going to be. Karishma is not wrong in wanting to prove that this is haseena because she is right. but neither are the other three wrong where they stand and in wanting to move on.


they are dealing with it in their own ways. Karishma supposedly spent all her time and energy looking for the killers. Pushpa Ji spent her time looking after them and particularly Karishma. cheetah and Santosh...I dont really know cause they didn't spend much time on it but I will take silence as their way of coping.


my point here is that everyone has a right to their pain. we don't have the authority to dictate how they should deal with it.


on that note, this conflict here is great. the character dynamics are changing, their opinions are differing adn they are no longer puppets. I hope this continues and they take a stand of their own rather than play sides when the truth is out.


I legitimately feel hopeful that we are gonna get a proper confrontation between MPT with all the trust talks going on.


also, is it just me or does it feel like they are setting up something for cheetah as well with the constant reminder that he has drowned in a lake of asshiqui?



or you know, everything I've written sown is made overthinking.


no comments on the precap.

Edited by rinki_99 - 4 years ago
indiaforumacc thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Nothing makes sense now.. How Lalla became a Dubai Sheikh and how someone forgets what they have been their entire life up til now and remembers the character that they enacted for a few days...


Dont know how a good show can become so dumb all of a sudden.

rinki_99 thumbnail
Screen Detective 2 Participant Thumbnail Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: indiaforumacc

Nothing makes sense now.. How Lalla became a Dubai Sheikh and how someone forgets what they have been their entire life up til now and remembers the character that they enacted for a few days...


Dont know how a good show can become so dumb all of a sudden.


that's what we all are wondering bro. but the Dubai sheikh was an act put up by MPT a couple of episodes back.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".