Kashmir files - Review thread - Page 43

Can imagine how difficult it must have been for Vivek Agnihotri to make this film

https://twitter.com/BBTheorist/status/1503391416709713922?t=ouO5WE81JImoDmjctRkH3A&s=19

https://twitter.com/PoonamV_/status/1505401206696714240?t=fh_uvHbzuNpt6PvEIkhS3w&s=19

Of course the audience will accept the movie narrative after all fits their thought process against a certain community after systematic poisoning being fed for so long.

Why did the subsequent governments did not help them for past 30 years

I know am going to get brick bats or will be ignored why because no one wants to think differently only want to go with their linear vision.

The best part about all this is how the audience gives two shits about these armchair critics and their opinions.😊Inka bas chalta toh all genocides that don’t suit their narrative would be brushed under a carpet.

Originally posted by: sev.puri

The best part about all this is how the audience gives two shits about these armchair critics and their opinions.😊Inka bas chalta toh all genocides that don’t suit their narrative would be brushed under a carpet.

This kind of generalization isn't only unfair to those who raise an objection against the using of the movie but simply is false and bad discussion behaviour.

But you are right that the general audience may not be readers of what is written here.

Originally posted by: sunflower52

Of course the audience will accept the movie narrative after all fits their thought process against a certain community after systematic poisoning being fed for so long.

As the saying goes God helps those who help themselves. Here KP left and did not fight for their rights to stay in their homeland. Why did the subsequent governments did not help them for past 30 years

I know am going to get brick bats or will be ignored why because no one wants to think differently only want to go with their linear vision.

Do you even realise how fckin awful blame culture is? How dare KPs leave whilst their death was being proclaimed in the speakers of the mosques in Kashmir? How dare they even think of leaving their homeland without a fight when their women were being raped just because they were well, Hindu. How dare they think of leaving despite being significantly outnumbered against the majority that were out for their blood? How dare they think of survival of themselves and their future generations, they all should’ve just been wiped out in one go, right? Disgusting mentality.🤢

Originally posted by: sev.puri

Do you even realise how fckin awful blame culture is? How dare KPs leave whilst their death was being proclaimed in the speakers of the mosques in Kashmir? How dare they even think of leaving their homeland without a fight when their women were being raped just because they were well, Hindu. How dare they think of leaving despite being significantly outnumbered against the majority that were out for their blood? How dare they think of survival of themselves and their future generations, they all should’ve just been wiped out in one go, right? Disgusting mentality.🤢

Has the Kashmir issue still resolved no right. This is not a blame game if you think that way there is nothing I can say. My major question is why the government at that time let it happen in the 1st place and why this issue has been not addressed for past 30 years. This movie might have help acknowledge their tragedy but will this help them anyway. This is where the government step in start dialogue and let them go back to their homes.

You answer me this then tell me who has disgusting mind set.

Originally posted by: Clochette

This kind of generalization isn't only unfair to those who raise an objection against the using of the movie but simply is false and bad discussion behaviour.

But you are right that the general audience may not be readers of what is written here.

I’m afraid the lines of bad discussion behaviour were crossed a long time ago. When discussing a movie about genocide and engaging in whataboutery, using multiple lol emojis, but sure, my comment is the one you had a problem with SMH.

Yes, the general audience are not pseudo-intellectuals thankfully.

Originally posted by: sunflower52

Has the Kashmir issue still resolved no right. This is not a blame game if you think that way there is nothing I can say. My major question is why the government at that time let it happen in the 1st place and why this issue has been not addressed for past 30 years. This movie might have help acknowledge their tragedy but will this help them anyway. This is where the government step in start dialogue and let them go back to their homes.

You answer me this then tell me who has disgusting mind set.

Please go back and read your original post when you question why the KPs never stood up for themselves. I highlighted it in bold for you. Own up to your mistake or go and edit your post if you’re truly embarrassed by it. Goodbye.

I think, I'll take you advice, sunflower, and will stop to argue with sev.puri...no need for this "ping-pong" ;-)

In future, if a movie is made on Taliban atrocities... will it warrant similar criticism?