Is this really an exact remake? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

4.7k

Users

10

Likes

57

Frequent Posters

laksh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#11

I understand what you are saying. We know one obvious answer. But that alone is not the reason.


Also, as much as there are additional scenes of Pakhi and Virat, there have been additional scenes of Virat and Sai too. Like the chocolate feeding scene on the first day of her college, the video call scene, the Naag Nadi episode, the hospital scene, the gift scene, the valentines day scene, the holi ofcourse and so much more.


They have given more background in Ghum for many scenes than in KD or Tamil.

In KD, the jealousy scene of Virat was limited to only one episode, here they showed us, him thinking about it the next day and visiting college too. Aniket track was a new track. And so was the hospital one.


I think they have always wanted to show his detachment from Pakhi and attachment to Sai.


In the Alta episode, the terrace scene made sense because Virat got to know what was Pakhi feeling. In other versions, they don't get to know like this. This is all a base for Pakhi's actions in future.


The ice scene wasn't necessary but Sai is very different from Emon or Saranya. We see Sai thinking about her feelings in Ghum whereas in other versions, they hardly do. For Sai to think about her feelings, I think they wanted to add jealousy as an emotion. This jealousy was expressed to Virat on the day she danced.


The same was with the rose scene. There was anyway no V day celebration in other versions. They want to show a contrast in Virat's behavior. The way he behaves with Sai and with Pakhi.


The Jhoola scene, though need not have been shot there, also showed that Virat trused Sai even after he had an argument with Sai right before he left the room. Pakhi's manipulation didn't work and she also got to know his trust on Sai. Virat shared what he thinks about Sai.

Edited by laksh - 5 years ago
840837 thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#12

I really dont think all the extra virat pp scenes have significantly helped take the story forward. The Sairat scenes have but the virat pp scenes have only infuriated me as a viewer because they are often extra long n often pointless several of them show virat as being unduly sympathetic towards pp and increase his "guilt" and "soft corner"

Like why did Virat need to justify giving Sai a rose to pp. Why did he need to stand and entertain her full sob story during alta episode. It could have been cut short. Why does he need to check on pp after having such a big showdown with his wife. Why does he need to storm into pp's room after fighting with Sai.

i really hope the makers focus their energy on Sairat's fresh scenes. If they want to show non Sairat scenes where Virat can vent his emotions that he hesitates to show Sai toh there are many many options- aai/virat, virat-mohit, virat-bua , virat-sunny, virat-imaginary jeeva (like in holi)...

tina2711 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 5 years ago
#13

Jab tak Vankar Dada ka support hai.....Didi ke extra scenes aate rahenge...

Chahe fir Sairat trend ho,No.1 ho ya kuch bhi ho..Verna didi sympathy post dal dengi ki people hate me.


Creative se dosti kam kr gyi hai. simple logic 😆

JugniPH thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Easter Egg Contest Winner (2023) Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 5 years ago
#14

Only logical explanation is CV head's friendship with 3rd wheel.

Every remake copy paste family scenes and add extra sequence of leads..

Yes there are some additional sairat scenes.sametime many sairat scenes were cut too..For eg. Shivrathri night there was one episode long sairat scene which is cut shot here to few minutes and instead of lovely conversation about themselves here we had virat pushing sai to become friend with pakhi..

Where as in virat pakhi CVS tone him down when it comes to pakhi, edits scenes where he is strict with her and add extra lovely scene.. blah..

Anyways I'm glad that virat pakhi lob story has started and ended in initial episodes. And have zero scope for flashbacks. Otherwise SV must have extra stretched them or gave extra fbs to romance the reel couple..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".