Disclaimer- Please avoid making it a battle zone. Constructive comments are always welcome though.
There have been many reboots & remakes in cinema & TV. Mahabharata, Ramayana, Comics based movies, epic Novel based movies, remakes of popular movies of all time & they have been able to replicate the success, thanks to brilliant writing that have come again & again, even with the same central plot.
No one thought anyone could beat Nolan-Ledger's Joker until Phoenix-Todd's Joker came. No one thought Batman could ever be made so dark by Nolan. No one thought Mahabharat can again rule over people's hearts after its 80s version. And the list is gigantic.
This reboot, remake of KZK has literally destroyed the legacy that show held. The reason this version got its audience in its first place was because of that legacy. Legacy of original content, characters that were way ahead of its time when they first came on screen.
A woman pregnant before wedding was never seen before when it happened way back in 2001. A villian like Komolika had never happened before 2001. A grey character like Bajaj had not happened in a TV show in such a way before 2001. Neither did they show a couple like Anurag-Prerna before who gave many dynamics to one relationship- as lovers, as enemies, as married couple & then as parents. Neither did they show a couple like Bajaj-Prerna- as name sake couple, as evolving relationship that also evolved the characters in it. Despite the show running for 8 years, despite it ruining the TV with its stretched, melodramatic, stereotyping, it did enjoy an unparalleled fame.
I don't know why did EK decide to reboot that show up in 2018 when there could be so many stories. She has been the Queen after-all. A lot of brilliant first-time shows came from her. She did take risks to spread into different genres- Kitni Mohabbat Hai (Far from Saas-Bahu melodrama, a beautiful show about 2 individuals love & suffering), Pyaar Ki Yeh Ek Kahaani (an Indian version of Twilight which was good for a teenager in 2010 looking to break Indian TV monotony), web- shows like Kehne Ko Humsafar Hain, Bose, Testcase & so many others. She knows her art without doubt but it fails to make sense to me as to why would she reboot KZK up with such horrendous & loud version- be it dresses, plot, background & what not.
I never saw the original Kasauti but from the clips I have seen so far, I can tell that things were way subtle & organic in that version that it have ever been in this one.
They destroyed their lead heroine beyond repair. They have destroyed their iconic vamp with such extravaganza given to her. They destroyed the improved version of Bajaj beyond repair. They destroyed what AnuPre & BajPre could be separately. Prerna's sacrifice didn't look sacrifice. Love looked more toxic that innocent & pure that it was in 2000s. While it could work in 2000s, 2019 is not the era to celebrate toxic relationships in our entertainment. This reboot could be anything, with a completely new plot, a new characterization, instead of picking things from Season 1 diligently & then treating them in a trashy way.
It makes me all the more upset because leads in this show had a much better role to play in their last show. Erica had a brilliant female lead role as Sonakshi that will always stay relevant & classy. Parth played Manik, a great deviation from usual bad boys. He was in perfect sense a grey character as an individual with his own ups & down. The character had evolution with everything he faced. Komolika could be a turning point for any actress who had played it, but they chose to turn her completely psychotic & more stupid. Finally Bajaj had a brilliant start this season. He had everything in place- the mystery, the intriguing backstory, the dialogues. After Prerna, Bajaj is the character that has been butchered for what it was & what it could be as individual character. While a lot of people can call this show evolution of actors with these characters, I don't have the same opinion. For me, on a personal level it has been the devolution as actors & characters. This role may have given them more fame that they always deserved, more opportunities & avenues for their bright future, but it makes my heart sad to see their potential being wasted like this in a non-existent plot & story.
Writers are the heart & soul of a show. The reason we love Sonakshi-Manik is because writers did a fantastic job. The way Bajaj consumed me in the initial days was because he was written perfectly back then. But here, writers just don't get it. I don't think we lack good writers in a country this big. How badly can a bad writer screw things up can be best seen with the way GOT turned out in the last 2 seasons.
I don't agree when the show makers decide to pin it on the viewers by saying that we want this sort of stuff. Viewers deserve better for the time & love they invest in a story & the characters. Pinning self-incompetence on viewers by undermining their intelligence wouldn't do any good to anyone of us & is intellectual dishonesty of the writers with self. It just serves to continue with the cycle of temporary success & inevitable doom while they continue to wonder & experiment at the cost of plot & characters & their potential.
This show is failing again & again while viewers keep on clinging on to tiny plank of hope for a better & engaging plot. Shows & movies can be tremendously success without OTT drama in today's times. The entire entertainment industry is undergoing an overhaul at this point- from cheesy, unrealistic to realistic movies & engaging, unique shows. Ye Un Dino, Ladies Special, Patiala Babes, KRPKAB, Beyhadh & so many others. I don't see why should EK not go for an overhaul in TV content. EK is still capable of making brilliant shows which can be seen with the kind of shows web-platform has.
This reboot should have never happened. Erica-Parth could have come together in a show in a completely new plot & it would have still worked & that would have atleast been more engaging because it wouldn't have had an original plot & characters to compare too constantly that subconsciously pales everything about this version in comparison. This version just destroys a legacy of its own. Some shows shouldn't be touched ever. EK proved it with this one.
- A hopeful viewer of the past but not anymore.