Why dislike science mumbo jumbo in IPK3 but love'em in Flash, MacGyver

Originally posted by: shesherkobita

I see a lot of criticism of the scientific techniques shown in IPK3. Admitting that it's kinda new for TV Hindi serial . But I have once seen a mother in law put a safety pin inside a jar of pickle to torture a daughter in law I would take the flying tea cups with classical background music over those shows anyday. ... and not to mention homing pigeons who get homed by technology , what a pun ! 🤣

Also the same people who are hating IPK3 science tricks don't mind watching them on superhero shows . You do realize that none of the superheroes are really super human ? 😆They are all human who use futuristic scientific gizmo to accomplish their deeds. Only Superman ( he is an alien from planet Krypton😃 ) and Wonder Women ( she is Greek God Zeus's daughter) are non human. If you don't mind watching mumbo jumbos on Flash, Arrow or MacGyver ( who is totally dependent on science tricks ) then why so much hatred for a desi show showing them? 😔

I admit the remote button looks silly when it lights up ( a change to a more complicated device would look nice ). Just look at what's happening to the real world right now ? USA bombs targets by no-pilot-drone-planes by just pressing a button from mobile devise thousands of miles away😡. Russia manipulated US election results by hiring hackers who pressed buttons to start a chain of Bot-Clicks🤢

So yeah, I don't mind these tricks on IPK3 ...in fact I welcome them ... All these flying dupattas ?? Surely they should be controlled by a motion sensor ? Sindoor on Chandni's mang every morning ? Surely that should be calibrated and dispensed remotely from Advey's cell phone even if she marries PP baba. 🤡Advey aroused by Chandni's touch? Surely she planted a Heat Seeker chip in his and her wrist ?

Anyways, all I'm saying is cut some slack for this show ... If you hate all future forward shows than I understand but I know you find radio active spider bite on cute boy Peter Parker all plausible and you love watching Barry Allen flashing around in that tight red leotard suit 😳... If that is so then don't mind the magnets and flammable oils , after all they are devised by a ruggedly handsome devilish charmer named Advey ; played by the most handsome man on earth. I am in Sobti heaven every weekday ...sigh! Enjoy the show and go with the flow 🤗

Originally posted by: amortentia15

🤗 pigeon pooping was somewhat weird for even a phankhi like me but your post just made me so happy! also as i have said in another post since there are symbolisms galore in the show i think this was advay's way of conveying to moonlight what a shitty proposal she had agreed to in the first place like literally😆 i just laaaud all the other scientific experiments😃

😆 Oh my ...that's brilliant ... I didn't think of the symbolism part of it 👏 I found the scene amusing ... The groom's name is PP , a little bird excreta should be okay for him 🤣

What an awesome post. Yes everything is plausible and infact intellectual for some people be it Spider Man weaving Spider webs with a flick of his wrist or Batman using lots of gadgets to finish his enemies. Bas in Indian TV shows the male lead shouldn't be shown as someone who has brains and who is using brains. All he should do is do romance or be like a furniture in a show run with female actress.


People are behaving as if they have never seen any homing device? Don't they know that helper dogs for blind people are trained with these devices. Even though the CGI effects were horrible in the last part of the episode with that much birds and all of them suddenly popping I actually laughed after seeing the scene. Here chandni is going - Yay I got one up on you Advay and giving a tit for tat but what does she know Advay is 2 steps ahead of her and he signals the birds. Advay is someone who can't be defeated no matter what.

I agree criticsm for show is at another level but that pigeon poop was too much for me,but criticsm for screenplay and costumes are valid they need to improve a lot.

Originally posted by: PSharada

What an awesome post. Yes everything is plausible and infact intellectual for some people be it Spider Man weaving Spider webs with a flick of his wrist or Batman using lots of gadgets to finish his enemies. Bas in Indian TV shows the male lead shouldn't be shown as someone who has brains and who is using brains. All he should do is do romance or be like a furniture in a show run with female actress.


People are behaving as if they have never seen any homing device? Don't they know that helper dogs for blind people are trained with these devices. Even though the CGI effects were horrible in the last part of the episode with that much birds and all of them suddenly popping I actually laughed after seeing the scene. Here chandni is going - Yay I got one up on you Advay and giving a tit for tat but what does she know Advay is 2 steps ahead of her and he signals the birds. Advay is someone who can't be defeated no matter what.

And I really think there is a reason for the creatives showing all these gadgets. I don't think Advay is going to be a guy who is going to track down his parents culprits and going to take them to jail and allow the law to take its own course. He is going to use his gadgets and going to finish them off but at the same time make sure it doesn't come to him. That is why they are showing that Advay is someone who uses gadgets to his advantage. I don't know why it has to be such an issue if they show ML to be someone who actually uses his brain.

What I have understood is some people just can't grow up - They are stuck in some fictional show and ghoom phir ke baat 2012 pe hi aa kar aatakthi hain. I thought 5 yrs is a long time but nope 50 yrs also is not enough for these people to get over a fictional show.

Originally posted by: hina11

I agree criticsm for show is at another level but that pigeon poop was too much for me,but criticsm for screenplay and costumes are valid they need to improve a lot.

Originally posted by: shesherkobita

I see a lot of criticism of the scientific techniques shown in IPK3. Admitting that it's kinda new for TV Hindi serial . But I have once seen a mother in law put a safety pin inside a jar of pickle to torture a daughter in law I would take the flying tea cups with classical background music over those shows anyday. ... and not to mention homing pigeons who get homed by technology , what a pun ! 🤣

Also the same people who are hating IPK3 science tricks don't mind watching them on superhero shows . You do realize that none of the superheroes are really super human ? 😆They are all human who use futuristic scientific gizmo to accomplish their deeds. Only Superman ( he is an alien from planet Krypton😃 ) and Wonder Women ( she is Greek God Zeus's daughter) are non human. If you don't mind watching mumbo jumbos on Flash, Arrow or MacGyver ( who is totally dependent on science tricks ) then why so much hatred for a desi show showing them? 😔

I admit the remote button looks silly when it lights up ( a change to a more complicated device would look nice ). Just look at what's happening to the real world right now ? USA bombs targets by no-pilot-drone-planes by just pressing a button from mobile device thousands of miles away😡. Russia manipulated US election results by hiring hackers who pressed buttons to start a chain of Bot-Clicks🤢

So yeah, I don't mind these tricks on IPK3 ...in fact I welcome them ... All these flying dupattas ?? Surely they should be controlled by a motion sensor ? Sindoor on Chandni's mang every morning ? Surely that should be calibrated and dispensed remotely from Advey's cell phone even if she marries PP baba. 🤡Advey aroused by Chandni's touch? Surely she planted a Heat Seeker chip in his and her wrist ?

Anyways, all I'm saying is cut some slack for this show ... If you hate all future forward shows than I understand but I know you find radio active spider bite on cute boy Peter Parker all plausible and you love watching Barry Allen flashing around in that tight red leotard suit 😳... If that is so then don't mind the magnets and flammable oils , after all they are devised by a ruggedly handsome devilish charmer named Advey ; played by the most handsome man on earth. I am in Sobti heaven every weekday ...sigh! Enjoy the show and go with the flow 🤗

Originally posted by: amortentia15

We know why they are doing whatever they are doing! Its so hard being happy in a forum of a show I completely love! Whatever goes on in the name of constructive criticism is anything but that! And don't get me started on 2012. People who don't even know him hate him with a vengeance similar to the way advay hates chandni. 😆 weird

Flash in red - yes