Bloody but Unbowed - The Endless Self Deception

allforlove thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

Bloody but unbowed
You turn to face the crowd
How can you bring yourself to even care?
Show me a weakness if you dare

What will give?

That's what DevAkshi were yesterday. Bloody but unbowed, not caring (apparently), daring each other.

Love is a strange emotion. It makes people do strange things. But again, where does it all lead to? Will DevAkshi clash like titans or petty humans bound by their limitations and illusions? They have once loved intensely. So, the hurt after seven years is still raw and perhaps blinding (at least for Dev). Yet, I wish they don't make it frivolous by washing their dirty linen in public or indulging in silly antics only to inflict more hurt. Where will this all lead to?? What will give, and more importantly, what will it take them to see the truth?

Will Dev ever realize that it was not Sonakshi or even his mother, but HE himself who brought about this destruction? Seven years, a failed marriage, some broken dreams, and one irreparable loss - doesn't call for the slightest bit of introspection on his part?? The flashback was atrocious 🤢 It only shows the extent to which the Dixits have taken the endless cycle of self-deception. In fact, it has always been about self-deception for them.

Dev gives himself a wardrobe makeover and thinks he is a changed man!!? Seriously! What has changed Dev? You are still impulsive, you are still madly in 'love' with Sonakshi, and you are still not doing anything constructive to make things work. Instead, you bring in more destruction. You remember each of her taunts but don't remember what prompted her to say them. You remember she left you, but don't remember why. The only thing that has changed for good is your equation with your mother and your family - but in love, you have once again taken the wrong turn 🄱

Ishwari thinks of herself as the model mother. Even when Dev pointedly tells her that she destroyed him by taking away his freedom to decide for himself, live for himself, make his own choices - she still thinks she is blameless!! It was all Sonakshi's fault 😔 Really?? What will it take for Ishwari to realize that she has brought Dev down with her own hands. She still play acts as the perfect mother, caring about her son's happiness - doesn't it occur to Dev that she needs some sort of counselling and treatment?? 🤢 Instead, he keeps up the charade 🤢🤢 - and this time, consciously 😲

Even the lesser mortals in their family are self-deceptive. Neha married Ranveer knowing very well that he is a self-respecting man but still believing that he will take favors from her rich brother to rise in life. Rhea too would have married Ayan if only her family had allowed her to!

And now, Sona! Yes, she too. For seven years, she worked hard to make something of herself. She believed that she was out of his power now - that he didn't matter. Yet, at the slightest provocation she gives in. She gives all the credit to her ex-husband (even if ironically). Why Sona? Didn't you work for yourself, are you not worth anything for yourself, were you doing all this only to prove a point to him?? I thought you rose from your ashes because you are strong and gifted - not because you were wronged.

I have been a consistent follower of this show and have always tried to be non-judgmental about the characters, trying to understand them from their perspective. However, now I don't know where this is headed anymore. How will Dev justify his behavior (not just yesterday's but what is coming up too)? What can they possibly show to make Sona forgive him ...because it's a show after all and they will have to end up together! Yes, they were in love - and are still in love. But love is not enough. The world had broken them once - it can break them again. If they had emerged stronger, emotionally more mature, more resilient - they would have a chance but that's not what they are today. They are bloody and broken, still in love, but still far from the truth, still deceiving themselves as having moved on, still not acknowledging their mistakes. Whatever wonder Soha works, even if she manages to rekindle the buried flames, history will repeat itself as long as DevAkshi don't confront and accept their own and their partner's realities. History will repeat itself as long as they really don't break and rebuild themselves.

Btw, if anyone has reached till here and is curious, that song at the beginning is by Radio Dept.

And Lots of lovely write-ups today šŸ‘ Some really talented people out there 😊 Keep writing.

Take care.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.1k

Users

5

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

preethik thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Very well written. The story again seems to be getting into a rut with no introspection by the characters on their mistakes. 7 yrs is a long time to do that.
I don't understand the cvs. If they had to show Dev still having feeling for Sona then their execution is not going down well.

Lots of complaints today. We should put our thinking caps aside & watch it for what it is - an Indian soap where anything is possible.
allforlove thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: preethik

Very well written. The story again seems to be getting into a rut with no introspection by the characters on their mistakes. 7 yrs is a long time to do that.

I don't understand the cvs. If they had to show Dev still having feeling for Sona then their execution is not going down well.

Lots of complaints today. We should put our thinking caps aside & watch it for what it is - an Indian soap where anything is possible.


Thank you 😊😊 We don't have any other option than to watch it as they show - I am just losing the hope of seeing the "mature" story they promised. The characters are not growing - it's like the same story in a different package Hope the CVs prove me wrong!
havima thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Harboring bitterness nd resentment is easier thn facing truth, since it keeps u going. Making peace nd introspection always comes later whn the dust settles. Now the storm of bitter past are haunting thm their initial behaviour of provoking each other is justifiable. But how thy take it frm here is something to wait nd watch. I predict it is going to get more uglier.
Btw. Am still giving the benefit of doubt to dev on his merry making ways as of now
sinduja_venkat thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: allforlove

I have been a consistent follower of this show and have always tried to be non-judgmental about the characters, trying to understand them from their perspective. However, now I don't know where this is headed anymore. How will Dev justify his behavior (not just yesterday's but what is coming up too)? What can they possibly show to make Sona forgive him ...because it's a show after all and they will have to end up together! Yes, they were in love - and are still in love. But love is not enough. The world had broken them once - it can break them again. If they had emerged stronger, emotionally more mature, more resilient - they would have a chance but that's not what they are today. They are bloody and broken, still in love, but still far from the truth, still deceiving themselves as having moved on, still not acknowledging their mistakes. Whatever wonder Soha works, even if she manages to rekindle the buried flames, history will repeat itself as long as DevAkshi don't confront and accept their own and their partner's realities. History will repeat itself as long as they really don't break and rebuild themselves.


I love how you've articulated this bit.

What can the makers now show to make them fall in love with each other once again?

To me both were at fault on that fateful day 7 years ago.

Dev was trying his best to resolve the situation in his mind but Sona was not helping him. Sona had reached her limit as well when it came to understanding Dev and his family but Dev was not helping.

Had Sona been more understanding of Dev's situation when it came to his family, for the sake of her love (yes!! even more than she had already been doing and at the risk of becoming a doormat) the separation could have been averted. Similarly had Dev been more effective in standing up for their relationship in front of his family the separation could have been averted.

Somehow there was a gap in what both were supposed to do for their love to succeed and stay together. And so the marriage simply failed.

I have been married for 7 years, and there have been several times when both me and my husband have had to make these "sacrifices" small and big - for us to be together. Of course, one of us always ends up feeling so wronged when we make this adjustment for the sake of the other.

However- I would like to say that with my marital problems if I found even a tiny way to solve a misunderstanding or to set things right I would gladly do it. In my mind I cannot be the quitter. Also mine is an arranged marriage- of the kind where our families chose us for each other. So apart from our love for each other, there is another bond there. And now after 7 years together ( yes magical number 7 šŸ˜†) we have both started to automatically try to solve issues just as they surface. We have started to read each others thought patterns, mood swings a lot more clearly than we used to.
Time and experience has served us well.

In Sona and Dev's case- they had reached a point where despite their love for each other they had serious problems that could not be solved as it were. Sona could not bear to have her family insulted by her in-laws and Dev could not bear to see that the girl who he thought loved him could completely fail to understand his intentions.

Another thing is many couples stay married despite these problems and don't separate or divorce due to a host of factors such as familial pressures to stay married, custody of child etc. But here Sona is portrayed as a bold person with a supportive family. And Dev's family only cares about the money he provides. So the only thing that actually kept these two together was their love. And when that love became questionable everything fell apart easily.

But after the seven years, what I find admirable is that Sona became successful in her career and Dev grew up as a person- he now knows the true face of his family.

Had the two of them stayed together, Sona would have never realised her full potential and Dev would have never realised the truth about his family- which would make them an average couple.


So the million dollar question is - As viewers which story would we have liked to watch ??


Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Beautifully written. šŸ‘šŸ‘ Dixits are doing what they know best - Blaming.
Well to me this is the worst love-story I have seen on Television. This is the story where people fall and fall deeper in love, not rise. šŸ‘ŽšŸ¼ I dont want to comment anymore today on Dev, he just doesnt worth my time anymore. But for Sona, well she is the most ungrateful daughter I have seen. The family which saved her, which helped her in overcoming her bad times, who was with her throughout all thick and thin, she forgot to thank them. All she could remember was Dev.🤢 Sona the 'lover' really annoys me like hell, because honestly I cannot see why a woman like her (with whom many of us can identify) can even fall in love with such spineless douche. 😵
allforlove thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: havima

Harboring bitterness nd resentment is easier thn facing truth, since it keeps u going. Making peace nd introspection always comes later whn the dust settles. Now the storm of bitter past are haunting thm their initial behaviour of provoking each other is justifiable. But how thy take it frm here is something to wait nd watch. I predict it is going to get more uglier.

Btw. Am still giving the benefit of doubt to dev on his merry making ways as of now


Yes, that is very true but for how long? One year, two years, three years...7 years is a very long time. People mature with age. Even if they have loved deeply and lost badly, they tend to think. Especially for Dev, the truth is glaring in front of him. He has identified it partly too by de-throning his mother. Even if you harbor resentment, it tends to get blunt with time. If I accept that his love for her, and therefore his hurt, was and still is exceptional - it doesn't justify his behavior. His world revolved around his mother and wife. Ishwari he shut himself against, but Sona - didn't he even think of WHY things went wrong between them? If he loved her so much, didn't he, in all these seven years, give a thought even once to his own actions or try to understand Sonakshi's rejection? How can he not remember what he said to her, what she did to save their relationship so many times, her repeated pleas asking him to tell the truth on every occasion that later went wrong? You can remain blind for some time but not for seven years. He can ignore these only if he 'wants' to ignore these and harbor that resentment deliberately.

As I have mentioned in my post, I would have perhaps accepted it if they had clashed like titans - if he had destroyed her for leaving him (might still do that), for knowing him and his love, and still not accepting him with all his flaws (unreasonable expectation but yes it's there), I would have still understood the intensity. However, this is silly. Taking a girl in front of her inside the room and giving smirks as if he wants to prove he doesn't care, taking the award from her and making a public spectacle - simply silliness. I don't care what he does with the girl later. Here, I would also say that Sonakshi has taken him at face value time and again. She knows he is impulsive in taking decisions and then in his actions. Yet, she reacts to it. Also, the point is what next after the ugly spats - how will the show end convincingly if they don't grow? They haven't grown in seven years, will they do now in a few months?
allforlove thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Thanks for the lovely response 😊

Originally posted by: sinduja_venkat


I love how you've articulated this bit.

What can the makers now show to make them fall in love with each other once again?

To me both were at fault on that fateful day 7 years ago.

Dev was trying his best to resolve the situation in his mind but Sona was not helping him. Sona had reached her limit as well when it came to understanding Dev and his family but Dev was not helping.

Had Sona been more understanding of Dev's situation when it came to his family, for the sake of her love (yes!! even more than she had already been doing and at the risk of becoming a doormat) the separation could have been averted. Similarly had Dev been more effective in standing up for their relationship in front of his family the separation could have been averted.

Somehow there was a gap in what both were supposed to do for their love to succeed and stay together. And so the marriage simply failed.

I have been married for 7 years, and there have been several times when both me and my husband have had to make these "sacrifices" small and big - for us to be together. Of course, one of us always ends up feeling so wronged when we make this adjustment for the sake of the other.

However- I would like to say that with my marital problems if I found even a tiny way to solve a misunderstanding or to set things right I would gladly do it. In my mind I cannot be the quitter. Also mine is an arranged marriage- of the kind where our families chose us for each other. So apart from our love for each other, there is another bond there. And now after 7 years together ( yes magical number 7 šŸ˜†) we have both started to automatically try to solve issues just as they surface. We have started to read each others thought patterns, mood swings a lot more clearly than we used to.
Time and experience has served us well.

This is exactly my point - I too believe both were at fault! Marriage is very different from love. Sona knew Dev very well. Yet, she is swayed by his words again and again. When they broke up for the first time, he told her nasty things emotionally on that night Ish took the sleeping pills and she didn't wait for a day for things to at least settle down before taking the big decision. Then, she decided to marry Ritwick within I think a month! After her marriage with Dev, she adjusted a lot (really much more than many), still again she took his words seriously when he was emotionally down, bruised and battered and drunk. Now I am not justifying Dev's actions at all. They are thoroughly wrong; his words were hateful. But it all depends on how far you wish to go for a relationship; what it means to you. There is no 'right' and 'wrong' in it. There is no ego in it. I am married for 8 years and there have been numerous big and small occasions when my husband has been wrong but has blamed me out of hurt and anger - men will be men! - I have given it time and things have settled. He apologizes and realizes his mistakes too. The same goes with me as well. We don't take decisions at the heat of the moment and that doesn't make us doormats to each other. We know how far we can be patient, to what extent we can adjust, what things we can put up with. Over time, we have come to understand these boundaries and expectations and modify our behavior accordingly. We have sacrificed for each other, sometimes let go of our egos, and that has only strengthened the relationship. Ours was an inter-community love marriage amidst lots of dissenters including our parents - so, our life wasn't really rosy to begin with. Only we were patient and accommodating. DevAkshi simply didn't give each other the time to reach that level. I also don't know how they could have gotten divorced without seeing each other once in seven years. It's not that easy in our legal system!! Nor is it easy to divorce someone at the drop of a hat!!! But laying realism aside...šŸ˜›šŸ˜›

In Sona and Dev's case- they had reached a point where despite their love for each other they had serious problems that could not be solved as it were. Sona could not bear to have her family insulted by her in-laws and Dev could not bear to see that the girl who he thought loved him could completely fail to understand his intentions.

Another thing is many couples stay married despite these problems and don't separate or divorce due to a host of factors such as familial pressures to stay married, custody of child etc. But here Sona is portrayed as a bold person with a supportive family. And Dev's family only cares about the money he provides. So the only thing that actually kept these two together was their love. And when that love became questionable everything fell apart easily.

That is the thing - if love is all you have, and the world is against you, that is the thing you should hold on to. At least, if it means something to you! Sona did try to a great extent but Dev created too many problems but then that's how he was, he is!

But after the seven years, what I find admirable is that Sona became successful in her career and Dev grew up as a person- he now knows the true face of his family.

Here, I disagree with you 😊 Sona's success is her own - she shouldn't have forgotten that. I was very happy with her character post leap before yesterday but doubtful now. And Dev hasn't really grown. He has just changed his exterior and learnt some facts about his family. He is still misguided.

Had the two of them stayed together, Sona would have never realised her full potential and Dev would have never realised the truth about his family- which would make them an average couple.

This, we can't say. Sona wasn't as ambitious but she started the business before their breakup. We can't say if she wouldn't have been successful. As for Dev, he should have realized the truth once Ishwari showed him the papers. Even after acknowledging her role in the breakup, he blames Sona! Did it need a divorce for him to realize the truth of his family??

So the million dollar question is - As viewers which story would we have liked to watch ??

It is not about the story that's over. It's the story that is developing now. As a viewer, I would definitely like an intense love story but with more mature and evolved leads. At least as of yesterday, I don't see that maturity. Yes, Sona has grown socially and commercially but has she grown personally? Dev, as mentioned above, is still the same! Do they have it in them to make it work once again if they don't change?


havima thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
@ pehchaan kaun. I dont think sona is an ungrateful daughter. Infact she has always fought hard to live up to their expectations even at the cost of her own relationship. I understand being called thief nd accidental slap is extreme for a person of bijoy's age, i wud have been happy if he had said to sona tht her relationship with the dixit family is for her to decide though his has changed to enemity. But he chose to say he wud never let her forget it nd forced his expectation on her. This same person is treating his own son as doormat nd good for nothing in front of his daughter. Complete partiality i wud say.
Who knows with same amount of support thy have shown to sona, saurab too wud have shined nd made something of himself. The bose family knows where to expect nd make sure she lives upto it unlike the direct pressure ishwari gives to dev. So both parents r not much different in their selfishness. I shudder to think wht bijoy wud have said to sona if she hadnt succeeded. So as sona said credit goes to dev who knows her potential


@ allforlove.. i agree bitterness fades away with time. But the scar it leaves behind dont. The other day gemini54 opened a thread on fatherhood which opened some unhealed wounds for me. My father never trusted me where it mattered most nd chose to steer my life by outsider's comments or fearof society. As a teenager my expectation was my parents will trust nd support me no matter wht but i was proved wrong. It has stayed with me after all these years. Now aft 15 yrs ofmarriage whn he tries to meddle with my daughters life i tell him politely nd firmly tht i am not him nd my parenting shd be left to my own ways.


So the bitterness cannot be termed as shortlived or long. It depends on the person who is affected by it. As for dev he feels betrayed by the two persons he loved most. He has done a partial closure with his mother. But with sona he is yet to do it. The pond is just getting stirred. The stink of tripathi's hand in it has t resurface for thm to clean the pond nd make peace
allforlove thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Pehchaan.Kaun

Beautifully written. šŸ‘šŸ‘ Dixits are doing what they know best - Blaming.

Well to me this is the worst love-story I have seen on Television. This is the story where people fall and fall deeper in love, not rise. šŸ‘ŽšŸ¼ I dont want to comment anymore today on Dev, he just doesnt worth my time anymore. But for Sona, well she is the most ungrateful daughter I have seen. The family which saved her, which helped her in overcoming her bad times, who was with her throughout all thick and thin, she forgot to thank them. All she could remember was Dev.🤢 Sona the 'lover' really annoys me like hell, because honestly I cannot see why a woman like her (with whom many of us can identify) can even fall in love with such spineless douche. 😵


Thanks a ton šŸ¤—

Well, it did strike me too that she didn't thank her family who stood by her. As for her falling in love with Dev, I do understand that! People fall in love with all sorts of strange people and stay in love too 😊 You can't really explain how that happens. It defies all logic! The only thing that bothers me now is when will Dev grow a spine, if he ever will, how they will sort these differences to come together this time for good. I want the characters to grow and not just put up a visibly different front. I want them to learn from their mistakes and become better at understanding and accepting each other. Only then can they get a convincing closure.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".