medha16 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Yes, I haven't watched the episode yet but i stand by what I said.
Kabir was in a right funk when he gave in that night.
He isn't a saint and we aren't moral popes to judge him for his one wrong action.
Isn't it enough that he is suffering still and is still at guilt over what happened?
I'do not support infidelity but we must take into account the state of mind he was in at that time...and his marriage was over long before it happened. That doesn't justify what he did but it also does not give anybody the right to point fingers at him.Infidelity is wrong but so is abuse and what shreya did to him was nothing short of that.

He is human and he gave into a moment of weakness where he probably needed some warmth to assure himself that he wasn't falling apart and that he was also a person to be loved and cherished even for that one single moment.

Does that make him a bad person? Of course not.

Actually his acceptance of his mistakes to Ananya, to Shreya actually elevated him in my eyes. To err is human but to accept one's mistake takes immense courage that only few can possess.
Kabir Sharma is not a saint, he isn't a doodh-ka-dhula, he has seen a lot, experienced a lot and as long as he stays true to his feelings for Ananya, i don't understand how he suddenly becomes "undeserving" of her love and of our respect. We need to stop putting our leads at a pedestal...he is NOT a hero, he is just you and me. i think those who have really delved into the world of Harry Potter will be familiar with what I'm trying to say. That's the most common analogy I can give u right now.
Edited by medha16 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.5k

Users

12

Likes

101

Frequent Posters

Mahi78 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Nice post Medha, even I loved this new twist, and appreciate the CVs for even taking such a big risk, 😊
Yes to Err is human after all. But to accept it take more courage than that, and moreover his lifetime redemption for his mistake, which no law can ever give such justice.


Even I'm a big fan of Harry Potter and the today's scene reminded me of prof.Dumbledore in 7 th part.😊
Edited by Mahi78 - 10 years ago
diksha2711 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
yes, i have said the same in another post of this forum that atleast he tried to correct the mistake and he also accepted his mistake that makes Kabir a gem of human beings! i mean how many ppl are there who r so reluctant to tell their horrible past to their GF, when they know that their past can shatter their present?
Now this is Kabir Sharma who not only accepts his past bt also tries to correct them!
icegirl31 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Nicely said ... he made a mistake n acceptd it rathr than lying or hidng

B/w hvnt seen much bt qs is does dis happen in real life dat a person is angry n goes 2 his frnd ... do dey seriously hv ONS or coz d oder person is sober n wud make d frnd in angr leave for d nite 2 clear his head ...

seriously wud d sobr frnd do dis ... wat if she ws engaged or married ???????? ws dat d only way 2 calm an upset frnd

As in odr shows dey show dat ONS happens if d person if upset or angry ... y idoes dis happen ... 2 show one is cherished or him nt 2 brk y is dis d only way shown in tv or films ???????


Edited by ice _girl - 10 years ago
medha16 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: ice _girl

Nicely said ... he made a mistake n acceptd it rathr than lying or hidng

B/w hvnt seen much bt qs is does dis happen in real life dat a person is angry n goes 2 his frnd ... do dey seriously hv ONS or coz d oder person is sober n wud make d frnd in angr leave for d nite 2 clear his head ...

seriously wud d sobr frnd do dis ... wat if she ws engaged or married ???????? ws dat d only way 2 calm an upset frnd

As in odr shows dey show dat ONS happens if d person if upset or angry ... y idoes dis happen ... 2 show one is cherished or him nt 2 brk y is dis d only way shown in tv or films ???????



Interesting question u put there.
What i feel is that when you are too affected by your emotions, by your desperate need to belong somewhere, u try and reach out to another person hoping for that comfort, that warmth u so needed right then.
We still don't know what exactly happened right there but Tarini was the one THERE with him when he was falling apart, she cared for him and maybe she saw that he required a human touch for one moment, to feel loved, to feel the care. U seldom think with your rational side when your emotions are at an all-time high and are all over the place, u just act according to how u feel, how the situation turns out to be. These things are never planned and that's what happened with both of them. They just gave in to the need of the hour.

It would have been a different issue had Tarini been married but the fact was that she wasn't and she was there with Kabir at that moment when nobody else was.

And also, I feel that relationships cannot be compartmentalised like that. A person can share a sexual relationship with someone and still be their friend. It's a matt of personal choice. It's a different matter altogether that the feelings Kabir and Tarini share are really platonic but that does not make either of them a "bad friend" if they had actually continued to sleep with each other post everything and had just remained friends.
Edited by medha16 - 10 years ago
medha16 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Mahi78

Nice post Medha, even I loved this new twist, and appreciate the CVs for even taking such a big risk, 😊

Yes to Err is human after all. But to accept it take more courage than that, and moreover his lifetime redemption for his mistake, which no law can ever give such justice.


Even I'm a big fan of Harry Potter and the today's scene reminded me of prof.Dumbledore in 7 th part.😊


Thanks! 😊

Actually i was thinking about Dumbledore, Snape and even harry's musings of not being perfect, of not being a hero while writing that line.
NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Yes to err is human
I was shocked to but we need to understand his state of mind

He was broken and shattered

And I love Anu for understanding
Mahi78 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: medha16


Interesting question u put there.
What i feel is that when you are too affected by your emotions, by your desperate need to belong somewhere, u try and reach out to another person hoping for that comfort, that warmth u so needed right then.
We still don't know what exactly happened right there but Tarini was the one THERE with him when he was falling apart, she cared for him and maybe she saw that he required a human touch for one moment, to feel loved, to feel the care. U seldom think with your rational side when your emotions are at an all-time high and are all over the place, u just act according to how u feel, how the situation turns out to be. These things are never planned and that's what happened with both of them. They just gave in to the need of the hour.

It would have been a different issue had Tarini been married but the fact was that she wasn't and she was there with Kabir at that moment when nobody else was there.

And also, I feel that relationships cannot be compartmentalised like that. A person can share a sexual relationship with someone and still be their friend. It's a matter of personal choice. It''s a different matter altogether that the feelings Kabir and Tarini share are really platonic but that does not make either of them a "bad friend" if they had actually continued to sleep with each other after everything just by being friends.


@bold agree to that, its just the human nature to search for some peace in that way when you high on emotions, especially when you r made to feel worthless.
Mahi78 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: medha16


Thanks! 😊

Actually i was thinking about Dumbledore, Snape and even harry's musings of not being perfect, of not being a hero while writing that line.


Yep the even Snape for that matter, his life long redemption was one such thought which crossed my mind.
icegirl31 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: medha16


Interesting question u put there.
What i feel is that when you are too affected by your emotions, by your desperate need to belong somewhere, u try and reach out to another person hoping for that comfort, that warmth u so needed right then.
We still don't know what exactly happened right there but Tarini was the one THERE with him when he was falling apart, she cared for him and maybe she saw that he required a human touch for one moment, to feel loved, to feel the care. U seldom think with your rational side when your emotions are at an all-time high and are all over the place, u just act according to how u feel, how the situation turns out to be. These things are never planned and that's what happened with both of them. They just gave in to the need of the hour.

It would have been a different issue had Tarini been married but the fact was that she wasn't and she was there with Kabir at that moment when nobody else was there.

And also, I feel that relationships cannot be compartmentalised like that. A person can share a sexual relationship with someone and still be their friend. It's a matter of personal choice. It''s a different matter altogether that the feelings Kabir and Tarini share are really platonic but that does not make either of them a "bad friend" if they had actually continued to sleep with each other after everything just by being friends.



I m jst tryng 2 undrstand dat wen one is angry hw does dese thoughts or feelngs even arise ... wnt d person in angr wanna hit or punch smth n being on alcohol jst curse n fall alseep coz of d alcohol ging into d brains n passng out

Dats wat i cant undrstnd y is dis d only thng dat happens n does dis actually happen in REAL LIFE ???????? ( coz i hv seen dis in tv or films n unable 2 undrstnd ... like if a persn is tensd he/she wud nt go out for ONS coz thng dey r tensd for wud b on their mind n wud talk wid someone abt it )

Does comfortng means ONS wen in such situatns ... then wnt all men do d same coz dey mite b hvng their share of dnws ...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".