Inconsistency in the growth of Anshuman' character & other woes.

EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
For a show that is basically running on a bound script and a fixed number of episodes, of which we are already halfway thru truth be told I was starting to expect a lot, especially in regards with Anshuman.

Its been 2 mere days that these 'mahaepisodes' have begun and there are 3 more to go, and I don't know about you guys but honestly I am kinda beginning to see what a mistake this gimmick is.

When the promo for these extra long episodes aired, implying the deliverance of 2 of the most awaited events - Ayaan accepting Paakhi as his mother and Paakhi learning all the things that she knew so far about Anshuman and his stand on their marriage being a farce, I was giddy with joy. Especially since I thought the CV' are tackling these 2 issues simultaneously and maybe, just may be they would coincide, I had this mental picture as well - of an exhilarated Paakhi sprinting towards Anshuman to reveal to him Ayaan called her mom and seeing him with Tanya, as he promises her that they will wed soon and have this moment where she would be caught between the moment of such huge joy and such a betrayal in her life and couldn't wait for it to happen.

Then I saw these 'mahaepisodes' - the only thing maha about them being the amount of Tanya on my screen, really the show can now be rechristened ' Na kisiki Tanya' with the fact that the majority of scenes are devoted to Tanya either with her dad, Ayaan or Anshuman.

Initially when Tanya came into the picture and we started seeing Anshuman from her POV she had intrigued me, the fact that Anshuman Rathore, a man who craved thrills wanted her to slow down her car and not have them racing to death made me smile, thinking this is now a side of his that is not only trying to be careful but also is somewhat fascinated by the concept of stillness, a Thehrav that Paakhi brings with herself, which seems to be growing on him.

When Anshuman had that moment of contemplation as he inadvertently had remembered Paakhi' APA to Tanya' AT and Paakhi ' refusal to get bail on false grounds against Tanya using Ayaan' childish trusting nature to make him want to go to boarding school, I was one happy trooper. I believed now with the two women together, Anshuman would wake up to the truth that has been staring him in the face all along, but it seems I counted my chickens before they hatched.

Last night, as Anshuman reflects and acknowledges to himself he had been harsh on Paakhi and is truly sorry I thought finally the lad is waking up but oh no, he is simply not getting it.

The confrontation scene which should have made Anshuman have a moment' pang of guilt was wasted, since he was too busy being the spectator, to take the bull by the horns so to speak and tonight it seems he is picking rings with Tanya for their impending engagement.

What is Anshuman waiting for? and why are the writers not utilizing the ample fodder provided?

What happened to the guilt that Anshuman felt when Paakhi landed up in Jail? He started hating his own reflection at the time because he felt he was being such a horrible husband for the first time and also realizing, what a bang up job of being a father he must have done for his son to stoop this low to punish a woman who has never wronged him. What happened to the reluctant acceptance of him finding Paakhi as a woman who makes a wonderful wife, a loving mother, someone so good that he feels inferior to her?

I get it the show must have these moments of confrontation between Tanya and Paakhi but why is it not waking up to the fact that Anshuman has to draw parallels between these women not just in a episode or two, for it to fade later on, but have each of these confrontations serve as food for thought, so to speak, and realize Paakhi is the woman for him and what he had with Tanya, may have been attraction, friendship, a possible case of them making 'sense on paper as a couple' thing but not LOVE, never LOVE.

If the CV' can show Ayaan thrown in a tizzy last night by viewing one footage of Paakhi telling him, she won't let him go to a hostel or that if that happens she too will leave home what is Anshuman waiting for?

Why are the CV' not making Anshuman at least reflect for a scene or two, on his own, without him being brainwashed by Tanya or anyone the difference between the two women and what is it that he feels for them.

And lastly, what in the hell are they doing to Lavanya, seriously, I am not a fan of how she still continues to treat Paakhi or think of her as a unsuitable woman for her brother, but what in the name of all that is holy is wrong with them to make her go this insane? Seriously, they are contemplating Lavanya have a tit for tat approach to the problem at hand in her life, yes Girish has lied to her, betrayed her and hurt her in the worst way possible, but can't the CV' see that looking for toy-boys or indulging in a fake affair, to just get Girish to back off is really not working, honestly my mind is boggled as to what are they doing here I can't even catch a fun side to this stupidity. Had Lavanya, found some friend with whom she unwittingly started an emotional affair, by means of confiding her marital woes and be caught in a zinger, I think I would have appreciated the approach, but what is it exactly that the CV' are trying to put across beats me - are they trying to get Lavanya to commit adultery as a means to lash out at Girish? or are they just gonna show Lavanya flaunting a fake boyfriend here to hurt Girish or what?

And really, why is Paakhi' one lone well wisher not even dropping hints to aid her? If he can drop by have casual chats with Anshuman over a cup of coffee, be game to babysit Ayaan, why not a scene where Girish tries to subtly draw Paakhi ' attention to the truth?

Seriously, I get it Paakhi is the heroine and has to face all these hurdles, and I honestly love her as a character - she is refreshing in her approach, in her outlook, a positive radiant ray of sunshine, not a crying beautified bimbo, like most Indian show female leads, but can they please, please for the love of god, try to get the other characters to grow too? Get em to grown in terms of their characters and on US as the audience, just like they have made us love Paakhi. I get it Anshuman is not a character to be loved or pitied at the moment, but can he not be so daft? And can Lavanya realize these schemes are not gonna help her drive Girish away, only perhaps make her feel more ridiculous and embarrassed of herself when she eventually forgives him.
Edited by AbandonedRiddle - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

1.8k

Users

11

Likes

58

Frequent Posters

LadyZaib thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
its cool i am loving this daft, sometimes sweet sometimes frustrates me hero anshuman..kinda makes it entertaining more colorful as for the story lets sit and wait and see how the story unfolds...patience is a key ;)
Edited by LadyZaib - 12 years ago
berrysweet thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Thank you.

Good post and a satisfying read as you have vented out ALL my frustrations. If the CVs were next to me ,they would feel my fingers around their neck for dragging a good story!!!
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: LadyZaib

its cool i am loving this daft, sometimes sweet sometimes frustrates me hero anshuman..kinda makes it entertaining more colorful as for the story lets sit and wait and see how the story unfolds...patience is a key ;)


Thanks for the reply to begin with, I am not hating Anshuman, but I wish they would give his role a little more meat, the show is becoming more Tanya centric, and despite the glaring differences in them which Anshuman noticed almost as soon as Tanya returned when he compared her to Paakhi, which have all but vanished now is what gets to me.

If the CV' could show that just at the onset of Tanya' journey they should not stop it so abruptly is all I am saying.

I am patient, 😆 may not seem with this post but I am just disappointed that they are not going anywhere with Anshuman' character atm as per me.😳
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: basheerahmajeed

Thank you.

Good post and a satisfying read as you have vented out ALL my frustrations. If the CVs were next to me ,they would feel my fingers around their neck for dragging a good story!!!


Oh I wouldn't wring their necks, but would wanna ask em after I have jolted them will we ever see a episode with barely 2 minutes of Tanya now? She has taken over the show, and Madhura is a good actress no doubt, she makes me despise Tanya, but I wanna watch more of Paakhi Anshuman😆

And can they pray tell me why is Mr. Rana not trying to get his daughter to back off? He is shown as extremely rich, more so than Anshuman I believe, his daughter is a lone child and a successful author then why does he act so cool with her wish to want to marry a man who is not only already married but also the father of a child? Why does he not wake her up to the fact that she would be wife no 3, when she can marry a bachelor who doesn't come with a baggage and perhaps history.
LadyZaib thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AbandonedRiddle


Thanks for the reply to begin with, I am not hating Anshuman, but I wish they would give his role a little more meat, the show is becoming more Tanya centric, and despite the glaring differences in them which Anshuman noticed almost as soon as Tanya returned when he compared her to Paakhi, which have all but vanished now is what gets to me.

If the CV' could show that just at the onset of Tanya' journey they should not stop it so abruptly is all I am saying.

I am patient, 😆 may not seem with this post but I am just disappointed that they are not going anywhere with Anshuman' character atm as per me.😳




but one thing i just feel they have to show tanya as tanya was in anshuman's life before pakhi and also anshuman feels that tanya is the woman for him as she understands him(fakely) we see this as a viewer but anshuman doesnt we have to see how wrong tanya is for anshuman thats why perhaps she is more into focus...u see anshuman has to choose pakhi so that it doesnt feel that pakhi was forced on him...he has to realise what he has with pakhi for that as viewers we have to see how tanya is soo wrong for him..perhaps thats what the CVS are trying to show...what anshuman thinks is not sahi as tanya is only obsessed with him and what he has to offer whilst pakhi loves him for what he is daftness, khadooness included..
Edited by LadyZaib - 12 years ago
hnidiga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Hi AbandonedRiddle, To start with.. Ur post is awesome...👏👏 Let me point out that all ur questions are all valid in every sense.. I don ve an explanation (of course 😆) for a lot of them but I think (yea m just in the impression😉) I have an idea as to what is being done to Anshuman's character and why.. I am just putting this forward since v can weigh its credibility!
According to the book, Anshuman is confused abt his feelings for Paakhi till the time she leaves the house..In the book both the siblings (there s no Tanya in the book but Lavanya plays the vamp here) drive Paakhi to the point where she ses herself unfit with them. After a massive showdown from the siblings.. Paakhi literally doesnot say a word in the entire fiasco.. no tears.. not even words.. no explanation.. no expectation.. she doesnt even answer back..
After the entire scene she asks Anshuman at night, before sleeping.. time specific cuz it actually carries a lot of significance for the consecutive feelings that anshuman s subjected to. She asks anshuman if she can go back to her brother (this novel was written before independence, women were very docile back then😉) In that scene too Anshuman just doesnt know what he feels.. he s soo confused that he gets frustrated cuz he has to decide if he has to send Paakhi back or not!! He is frustrated with himself for being unsure but still having to decide.. And in the frustration he does what he thinks has to be obvious.. he ask Paakhi to leave, if she wishes to.
His sleep is disturbed that night over what he said and he decides he will ask her to stay. He even thinks to himself that "Does someone leave the house for such things?? We dint even have a proper fight" (The showdown happens regarding how Ayaan changes after Paakhi comes and Lavanya not approving it) He gets up in the morning half thinking what happened the previous night s a dream of his (all this is actually described in the book..Every detail f how anshuman feels is given.. thats why books r always waaay better😉). And all the while he even hears Paakhi giving instructions to the servants. He locks himself in the study room and has a conflict of emotions and when he finally decides to go to Paakhi and finally ask her to not leave... its too late!! Paakhi leaves even without telling him and thats when he realises the entire effect of the turn his life has taken.
Why I quoted this part here is because I wanted to tell u what the exact portrayal of anshuman in the book is like and I am also glad to say that the CV's have changed the story but ave still managed to preserve the character of anshuman.. his indecisiveness, his frustration with himself and his conflict of feelings and emotions. Basically he s a character with a lot of weakness and how Paakhi helps him later on is what makes the crux of the remaining story. So I think the CV's are just trying to preserve the main characterisation of Anshuman and will get to his realisation and redemption part only after Paakhi leaves.. Once again.. Mind you.. This is what I think since the story progression seems to be going there..
One more thing is Ayaan accepting Paakhi, Anshuman showing a soft spot suddenly in the maha episodes would have really been unrealistic since it wud seem like things moving too fast.. Also in the book Anshuman actually doesnot even talk to Paakhi until she actually shows him she can absolutely take the house's responsibility.. forget showing some compassion for her.. So lets see what happens ad how Cv's do justice to the book or otherwise.. time will tell..
LadyZaib thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: harithanhp

Hi AbandonedRiddle, To start with.. Ur post is awesome...👏👏 Let me point out that all ur questions are all valid in every sense.. I don ve an explanation (of course 😆) for a lot of them but I think (yea m just in the impression😉) I have an idea as to what is being done to Anshuman's character and why.. I am just putting this forward since v can weigh its credibility!

According to the book, Anshuman is confused abt his feelings for Paakhi till the time she leaves the house..In the book both the siblings (there s no Tanya in the book but Lavanya plays the vamp here) drive Paakhi to the point where she ses herself unfit with them. After a massive showdown from the siblings.. Paakhi literally doesnot say a word in the entire fiasco.. no tears.. not even words.. no explanation.. no expectation.. she doesnt even answer back..
After the entire scene she asks Anshuman at night, before sleeping.. time specific cuz it actually carries a lot of significance for the consecutive feelings that anshuman s subjected to. She asks anshuman if she can go back to her brother (this novel was written before independence, women were very docile back then😉) In that scene too Anshuman just doesnt know what he feels.. he s soo confused that he gets frustrated cuz he has to decide if he has to send Paakhi back or not!! He is frustrated with himself for being unsure but still having to decide.. And in the frustration he does what he thinks has to be obvious.. he ask Paakhi to leave, if she wishes to.
His sleep is disturbed that night over what he said and he decides he will ask her to stay. He even thinks to himself that "Does someone leave the house for such things?? We dint even have a proper fight" (The showdown happens regarding how Ayaan changes after Paakhi comes and Lavanya not approving it) He gets up in the morning half thinking what happened the previous night s a dream of his (all this is actually described in the book..Every detail f how anshuman feels is given.. thats why books r always waaay better😉). And all the while he even hears Paakhi giving instructions to the servants. He locks himself in the study room and has a conflict of emotions and when he finally decides to go to Paakhi and finally ask her to not leave... its too late!! Paakhi leaves even without telling him and thats when he realises the entire effect of the turn his life has taken.
Why I quoted this part here is because I wanted to tell u what the exact portrayal of anshuman in the book is like and I am also glad to say that the CV's have changed the story but ave still managed to preserve the character of anshuman.. his indecisiveness, his frustration with himself and his conflict of feelings and emotions. Basically he s a character with a lot of weakness and how Paakhi helps him later on is what makes the crux of the remaining story. So I think the CV's are just trying to preserve the main characterisation of Anshuman and will get to his realisation and redemption part only after Paakhi leaves.. Once again.. Mind you.. This is what I think since the story progression seems to be going there..
One more thing is Ayaan accepting Paakhi, Anshuman showing a soft spot suddenly in the maha episodes would have really been unrealistic since it wud seem like things moving too fast.. Also in the book Anshuman actually doesnot even talk to Paakhi until she actually shows him she can absolutely take the house's responsibility.. forget showing some compassion for her.. So lets see what happens ad how Cv's do justice to the book or otherwise.. time will tell..



wow really is anshuman exactly like that in the book? i always wondered that?

u are right..anshuman is a weak and we see that clearly

so here anshuman actually has shown care towards pakhi and they have such a comfortable relationship
Edited by LadyZaib - 12 years ago
hnidiga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: LadyZaib



wow really is anshuman exactly like that in the book? i always wondered that?

u are right..anshuman is a weak and we see that clearly

so here anshuman actually has shown care towards pakhi and they have such a comfortable relationship

yes, Since I have read the book, I know how it is and how its shaping up.. and I amexpecting Cv's to stick to the original version.. so far they have.. but in future I dunno.. but the way the story is heading it certainly seems like it will..
Neway I am thinking to make a post regarding this.. wt say Ladyzaib??
...Jes... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
well i don't think it is the time to judge him coz honeslty we haven't seen anything of him .. we have learnt abt Paakhi and so Aayan and Tanya .. but Cvs have still not shown any importance to Anshuman .. i mean this is their main card .. they can't show us everything at a time .. for now i m enjoying the mother side of Paakhi and her substance as a woman .. where Anshuma's character fails to nail .. but that is the theme only .. Anshuman is not a solved soul and so the story is getting its twists .. Anshuman never even showed any real feelings till now,well he has some mechanical theories of him .. but other than that he is shown as nothing .. soon he wil change and story wil roll on .. and yes Tanya was the missing link in the story .. till now we all were high per abt why Anshu is not feeling love for Paakhi?now we knw that reason coz his mind is set the way that He can only love Tanya and she is perfect for his status .. so Tanya also needs the screen pace in the story,i do not object here .. Tanya's entry wil show us Anshuman's flaws ever more and finally Paakhi wil come to knw abt his true colours ..

i think makers r pretty much sure what they r doing and they r doing very smooth job! :)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".