Comparing Gajagamini Walk of Aditi with Deepika's - Page 4

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

Here in Dallas a crate of Alphonso sells for 50+ dollars......and it is a very delicate mango.....I have seen so many people complain that the mango have black patches......because it goes through a rigorous process getting to USA.

Exactly

Sare khilji ullu ban gaye

Comparing a fast beat music to a slow one then wondering why dance movements were faster in one and slower in another

Logic

Originally posted by: FatalFlaw

Saying that she couldn't dance in front of her family or dad sounds like we might be projecting our modern values onto a period drama. And if that was really the case, they could've just tweaked the step or choreography. I mean, Mastani is supposed to be both a skilled dancer and a warrior.

We are projecting our modern values on a period drama by default of historical fiction tho lol. I don't think Mastani and Kashibai shook a leg to Pinga or Mastani danced publicly to 'entice Bajirao' historically.

Mastani was a princess and all she did probably was just getting told all her life to expect a political marriage.

Originally posted by: hasini009

Aditi is a trained Classical dancer and Deepu is not. it’s clearly visible in their performances.

...which I find absolutely okay...like for Madhuri, too, it should be rewarding to have trained classical Indian dances.

I also find the argument about their body structure valuable.

So, there are three arguments which make the difference understandable without any need of criticising

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

SLB made Padmavati look so so bad....it was not even funny......even in Mastani....Deepu looked so stoned all the time with those watery glassy eyes....I say...SLB ke saath kaam he nahi karna chahiye Deepu ko....

Look how gorgeous Farah made Deepu look in OSO and HNY....absolutely gorgeous.....and SLB made the same gorgeous face look bad...

I always say.....that if something goes wrong in an SLB movie...it is only his fault....

Nah, Deepika just doesn’t have it in her to pull off a historical queen onscreen with conviction. The most pathetic performances she has given are in SLB period dramas, Aish would have been better in Padmavati’s role. The charm, grace, aura, body posture, dialogue delivery, timeless beauty etc. which is required for such roles, very few actresses have it in them. Deepika’s height, model like figure and that face is more suited for urban chick roles.

SLB decided otherwise, so it was his choice and it was he who guided her through the performing process.

Nevertheless, you may be right and he made the wrong choice. But that isn't Deepika's fault.