BW actress Payal Rohatgi trolled after demanding a Hindu Nation - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

77

Views

14.8k

Users

30

Likes

156

Frequent Posters

AllThatCritique thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 5 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Thug-Leader

answer some simple question, why did Goddess Sati committed Sati. Was she a widow? Did she commit Sati because Shiva die?

It's a long story but Sati basically immolated herself because her father insulted her husband Shiva and she sacrificed herself for save his honor. The same strain of honour was responsible for the custom as well. One honors their husband in life and then in death by committing Sati so that he is free from the cycle of birth and to purge their sins. That was the religious angle given to make it 'society-friendly' and to manipulate women to being 'chaste' and 'a pious wife'. The real reason was definitely property ownership.

Ur-Miserable thumbnail
Anniversary 8 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago
#32
Thanks Pachu and ATC, but sorry it was a rhetorical question lol. While I don't agree with the BS these ''Hinduism Khatre Main Hain'' group, but I just found it was necessary to tell simsim mistook Sati's immolation with the widow immolation.
simim thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: Thug-Leader

Thanks Pachu and ATC, but sorry it was a rhetorical question lol.While I don't agree with the BS these ''Hinduism Khatre Main Hain'' group, but I just found it was necessary to tell simsim mistook Sati's immolation with the widow immolation.

I did not. I know very well why Sati burnt herself. My point was that saying it’s not part of Hinduism and came with invaders is ridiculous when the custom is named after her act. And she is Shivas wife. And Shiva is a Hindu God. How can ppl say that it was not in Hinduism and came with invaders when the custom is named Sati.

The last known act of Sati was in 2002!!! Who invaded and who had to escape the invaders in 2002?

This is not the first time I am hearing this. This is something systematically spread during the last 5 years that anything problematic with Hinduism is due to invaders and anyone else. And if you disagree then you are an anti national sickular urban naxal communist etc etc

anjs thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 5 years ago
#34

Can someone tell me what is the actual thought process of Payal behind calling him a traitor............. he is the one who fought against Sati pratha.... why does that make him a traitor ?

Also before jumping on a 'Hate Hinduism, Hinduism is evil' bandwagon, do some research............. Sati Pratha was never prevalent in Maharashtra, Goa and I guess South India as well......... these parts also have Hindus, we worship lord Shiva and Goddess Sati, but there is no Sati Pratha here............ though yes Women were forced to shave their head in Maharashtra, but that was cause they feared that some men will try to force these young women............there was no action taken to usurp these women's properties..........cause there was joint families and widow were also part of the families and looked after.......

yes, the shaving of head, not allowing to attend marriages etc were the sad part followed even in Maharashta........... but not in goa........not sure about south India though.......

simim thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: anjs

Can someone tell me what is the actual thought process of Payal behind calling him a traitor............. he is the one who fought against Sati pratha.... why does that make him a traitor ?

Also before jumping on a 'Hate Hinduism, Hinduism is evil' bandwagon, do some research............. Sati Pratha was never prevalent in Maharashtra, Goa and I guess South India as well......... these parts also have Hindus, we worship lord Shiva and Goddess Sati, but there is no Sati Pratha here............ though yes Women were forced to shave their head in Maharashtra, but that was cause they feared that some men will try to force these young women............there was no action taken to usurp these women's properties..........cause there was joint families and widow were also part of the families and looked after.......

yes, the shaving of head, not allowing to attend marriages etc were the sad part followed even in Maharashta........... but not in goa........not sure about south India though.......


Pls show a comment which states that they hate Hinduism? Why are you talking about which regions had it and which did not? That’s not being discussed here at all!!!

Pls go through what Payal said and what people commented.

She claims that Sati Pratha is not part of Hinduism and came with invaders and that people who fought against it are basically just followers of the British who were discrediting Hinduism by calling it a Hindu practice.

So I don’t know why you are talking about where it was followed and where it was not.

anjs thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 5 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: simim


Pls show a comment which states that they hate Hinduism? Why are you talking about which regions had it and which did not? That’s not being discussed here at all!!!

Pls go through what Payal said and what people commented.

She claims that Sati Pratha is not part of Hinduism and came with invaders and that people who fought against it are basically just followers of the British who were discrediting Hinduism by calling it a Hindu practice.

So I don’t know why you are talking about where it was followed and where it was not.


dude, your comment fully imply blaming hinduism..........believe it or not, my reply is based on your comment alone.........

it is not about hinduism, if its not a practice followed by all hindus............so stop blaming hinduism for every damn thing.....

as for Payal, she is a dumb woman as per my opinion since survivors, so i wont take anything she says, seriously.........

anjs thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 5 years ago
#39

Sati (practice) From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Jump to navigation Jump to search "Suttee" redirects here. For other uses of "sati", see Sati (disambiguation).

An 18th-century painting depicting sati.

Sati or suttee[note 1] is an obsolete funeral custom where a widow immolates herself (Anumarana) on her husband's pyre or takes her own life in another fashion shortly after her husband's death.[2][3][4][5]

Mention of the practice can be dated back to the 3rd century BCE,[6] while definite inscriptional proof in Nepal and India starts appearing from 5th and 6th centuries CE respectively. Sati stones started appearing in large numbers from 11th century. From 12th to 19th century and also in the late modern era, there were incidents when it often occurred in large numbers, especially as a reaction to military conquests by foreign militaries. The number of women burning themselves however always remained low in relation to the number of people. Resolute support for Sati by some authors only appears from 15th century, however there were also many in opposition to it. The practice was particularly prevalent among some Hindu communities,[7] observed in aristocratic Sikh families,[8] and has been attested to outside the Indian subcontinent in a number of localities in Southeast Asia, such as in Indonesia and Vietnam.[9] The practice was never widespread throughout India, nor did it have scriptural sanction.[10]

simim thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: anjs


dude, your comment fully imply blaming hinduism..........believe it or not, my reply is based on your comment alone.........

it is not about hinduism, if its not a practice followed by all hindus............so stop blaming hinduism for every damn thing.....

as for Payal, she is a dumb woman as per my opinion since survivors, so i wont take anything she says, seriously.........

Hinduism has several good and several bad points. Trying to say that all bad are due to invaders is nonsense.

Believe it or not I like Hinduism the way it is. I dislike the nonsense being propagated in the name of Hinduism. Leave Hinduism as it is and it’s good.

Just because you disagree with the utter crap that someone says doesn’t mean that you hate a religion and you are merely reiterating what I said. If you disagree with something then you hate or are anti national or a sickular....

Pls read completely and understand what is said before making ridiculous claims.

Top