I don't watch Hindi films: Vidhu Vinod Chopra when quizzed about ADHM - Page 4

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

MadOwhat

@MadOwhat

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: bigul

wo sirf apne dukaan ki mithai ki hi nahin mithai khane walon ki bhi mazaak udata hai. ye to hypocrisy ho gayi ki apna mithai ka dukaan hai aur aap kehte ho ke main apne mithai nahin dusre ke dukaan ki mithai khata hun. 😆

Bold - How is not watching Hindi movies = Mocking the Industry/audience ? ...stating the article as is, not even getting into the implied part.

Red - Ghar ki murgi daal barabar kahawat to suni hogi.

Even if we ignore the proverb, its the reverse of hypocrisy, if all

...agar woh kehte tha ki mai sirf apni dukaan ki mithai khata hoon...it would have been hypocrisy...So Hypocrisy needs to replaced with Magnanimity...Kindly issue a revised version

Glossary

Mithai = Films

Dukaan = Regional Industry(West Bengal, Kerala, Maharashtra etc)

Edited by MadOwhat - 8 years ago

Quote

humanity

@F.I.T.B

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#32

HE is one of the technically and cinematographically sound director...

why he shelved Chandrakanta movie...😕 😕 😕

OKAY so whats big deal

Edited by _fillintheblank - 8 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

bigul

@bigul

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: MadOwhat

Bold - How is not watching Hindi movies = Mocking the Industry ? ...stating the article as is, not even getting into the implied part.

Red - Ghar ki murgi daal barabar kahawat to suni hogi.

Even if we ignore the proverb, its the reverse of hypocrisy, if all

...agar woh kehte tha ki mai sirf apni dukaan ki mithai khata hoon...it would have been hypocrisy...So Hypocrisy needs to replaced with Magnanimity...Kindly issue a revised version

Glossary

Mithai = Films
Dukaan = Regional (West Bengal, Kerala, Maharashtra etc)

i was not just talking about only this article. this is not the first time (i can post article links if you want)

, he continuously mocks audiences and their choices.

and its not magnamity its hypocrisy. the tone that he used explains it all. you can say main dusron ki dukaan ki mithai khata hun and its ok but you can't say main apne dukaan ki mithai nahin khaata hun( he meant mere dukaan ki mithai kharab hai). acc to him he didnt even see the movie and says i dont want to see that movie, then goes on to say watch this marathi movie and you will forget those movies and their controversies. you dont have to put one movie down to praise another.

Edited by bigul - 8 years ago

Quote

Deviant_Pixel

@Deviant_Pixel

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#34

Yes he should watch epically panned and financially disastrous Broken Horses.

Quote

humanity

@F.I.T.B

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#35

why people generally say they have not watched it ...genuinely they say or ego or liars...

many times if asked to different actress or actors or directors...

Quote

MadOwhat

@MadOwhat

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: bigul

i was not just talking about only this article. this is not the first time (i can post article links if you want)
, he continuously mocks audiences and their choices.

Bold - I am discussing about a issue pertinent to this thread ...and not letting any baggage cloud my thinking...else the discussion goes on till the cows go home...and nothing conclusive comes out.

Primarily he said I dont watch Hindi movies these days...in this article "These Days"was selectively edited

...even if I use this article as sacrosanct and avoid reading between lines ...I still agree with him ...its not worth wasting time on Pooja ki Thalis & Skyscraper jumping ...so what if it is a product of his Industry

why do you want to force him to watch something that sucks at a gun point.

In my view that is intolerance

Edited by MadOwhat - 8 years ago

Quote

humanity

@F.I.T.B

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#37

do an actor or actress or director or producer

needs to be politically correct

or we need good journalism

and not masala flavor one

Quote

MadOwhat

@MadOwhat

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#38

Originally posted by: bigul

and its not magnamity its hypocrisy. the tone that he used explains it all. you can say main dusron ki dukaan ki mithai khata hun and its ok but you can't say main apne dukaan ki mithai nahin khaata hun( he meant mere dukaan ki mithai kharab hai). acc to him he didnt even see the movie and says i dont want to see that movie, then goes on to say watch this marathi movie and you will forget those movies and their controversies. you dont have to put one movie down to praise another.

Bold - I didn't hear any tone...may be I am not gifted😆

UL - Its a possibility he meant that...and I wish he did and agree with him too...but it is also possible that he wants to explore other industries (Mithai) to get a different flavour...or has some other priorities these days ...you are assuming a lot.

Red -If he saw the movie...He would have said I have seen it...and this thread wouldn't have existed.

You are trying to be his proxy and decide for him ...don't undermine his intelligence😆 ...besides people make their decision based on reviews(not by watching and deciding whether to watch or not)...and he has one such film critic by his bedside.

Blue - which article are you reading😆 ...which movie did he put down ...He didnt make any comparison between ADHM & Ventilator ...assumption again...He just said I dont watch hindi movies these days.

P.S - Magnanimity because he is stepping outside his domain (Hindi FI) & being generous to other

Not Hypocrisy because he is not saying my Industry rocks ...and Rest suck

Edited by MadOwhat - 8 years ago

Quote

bigul

@bigul

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: MadOwhat

Bold - I am discussing about a issue pertinent to this thread ...and not letting any baggage cloud my thinking...else the discussion goes on till the cows go home...and nothing conclusive comes out.

Primarily he said I dont watch Hindi movies these days...in this article "These Days"was selectively edited

...even if I use this article as sacrosanct and avoid reading between lines ...I still agree with him ...its not worth wasting time on Pooja ki Thalis & Skyscraper jumping ...so what if it is a product of his Industry

why do you want to force him to watch something that sucks at a gun point.

In my view that is intolerance

isme intolerance kahan se aaya? who is forcing him to watch any movie? but definitely people can have different opinions and can react to his statements and discuss it. the point here is whether what he said is hypocrisy or not? thats it. anyways lets agree to disagree.

acc. to me he is an arrogant snob and its absolutely ok if you don't think so.

Quote

MadOwhat

@MadOwhat

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: _fillintheblank
do an actor or actress or director or producer

needs to be politically correct

or we need good journalism

and not masala flavor one

...or do we need to use discretion before concluding ?

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

Vidhu Vinod Chopra

topics	author	replies	views	reply
#Kalki2898AD (Hindi) Closes In On RRR (Hindi) - Mysore Extraordinary Surly_Devil 1 323	Surly_Devil	1	323	3 months ago Surly_Devil >
Are Rani's films are more versatile than Kajol's films? 2 3 sulini76 20 2k	sulini76	20	2k	4 months ago cougarTown >
Why did Amitabh, Vinod, Rishi, etc all come with Sridevi? fazgostoso 5 644	fazgostoso	5	644	2 months ago forza >
Don 3 shooting has been further pushed to May-June 2025 2 3 4 5 Surly_Devil 48 2.3k	Surly_Devil	48	2.3k	11 days ago rckRadhe >
Don 3 Starts Shoot February 2025 oyebollywood 2 426	oyebollywood	2	426	5 months ago Clochette >

I don't watch Hindi films: Vidhu Vinod Chopra when quizzed about ADHM - Page 4

Related Topics