My analysis on the current track

Page

idonkno

@idonkno

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

So I was going through responses of other members both on youtube and here..I found that majority of the people are not liking this track.. However, my opinion is very different. I hope there are other people who are also supportive of Aaliya and Ishan love track.

This is what happens in real life as well. First love is not always the TRUE LOVE. There are lot of people who fall out of love and find that they were mistaken to assume infatuation or care as love. Ishan was close to Malvika but she broke their relationship. He was moving ahead without her when Aaliya came to his life and brought with her some relief to his miseries. So did he do wrong by befriending her? Of-course not. He never realized when Aaliya became more important than Malvika for him. Is this realistic? Yes.

On the other hand, Malvika was envious to see Ishaan happy. Is this right? No, after all she was the one who had broken their relationship. Every time she saw Ishaan and Aaliya together she felt a pang of jealousy. Was it because she loved Ishaan? No! She had never loved him. If she would have she would have never said that she would not allow Ishaan to forget her and move on with Aaliya. Its her ego that made her reconcile with Ishaan and not her love. Ishaan for her is like a trophy that she wants to flaunt in front of Aaliya. Ishaan was and is being used by Malvika to satiate her own ego and to prove the world that she is always a winner.

Veer is a guy to me whose character has not been sketched properly. I do not get when and how did he fall for Aaliya. I am pretty sure that there is much more to his character than shown to us. How can he propose her so easily without actually telling the truth about her Dad? Is he trying to get close to her in order to get forgiveness for the guilt he is suffering or is he involved in her dad's disappearance? Too early to believe his every action I would say!

And for the people who say Ishaan is cheating on Malvika! He wants to tell her the truth but Malvika's issues with her Dad did not let him do it! He still cares for Malvika and we all have seen that! And that is what I want to say - He is a good guy who cares for Malvika as a friend and his first love! But his true love is Aaliya! and how can he be with Malvika when after loving Aaliya he can't love anyone else? All of the sudden the definition of love has changed for him!! Its no longer the teenage love that we all go through but is much more deep!

This is what life gives us all as well! Our first love is not our true love! And for most of us it takes a long time to figure out who are true love is and once we know who that person is we should not let that person go away from us!

P.S : Ishaan is not Malvika's true love! So I don't sympathies with her! She will be over him!

Maybe you all won't agree with me but this is what I have experienced! Falling out of first love is pretty common!

Edited by idonkno - 9 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Ranjini

@MFRanjini

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

Very much agree with you.

Malvika was really rude to Ishaan after she broke up with him and getting him back was nothing but her ego. She wanted to win.

As for Veer CVs brought him suddenly without any proper build up of the character. Its pretty rushed.

As for Ishaan falling for Aliya its pretty natural. She is the one who made him live life fullest. Aliya Ishaan had such a good tuning, just what Ishaan explained as "Hum".

Only thing I dont like is crying sad Aliya.

Btw Ishaan Aliya were pretty hot in the confession scenes.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Zephyr8

@Zephyr8

Explorer

Posted: 9 years ago

I have always liked Alia and Ishaan together. I approve of them together In the current track too. The story as told earlier did seem to show that Malvika just didn't want ishaan to forget her. She still emotionally corners him with the father and loneliness story. At the same time, Alia seems to have become Malvika's godmother...How does It make sense to a person like her who thinks with her heart, to allow Malvika to be with someone who clearly told Alia that he doesn't love Malvika? I don't know how Alia can be with Veer? Isn't she cheating with his feelings? Those things are a contradiction to who Alia was when this story started. The "Hum" as Ishaan mentioned was apt and is missing from the story now. But all said and done, watching the show from the very beginning, Ishaan and Alia were always a wonderful pair to watch onscreen.

Edited by mjhtfan8 - 9 years ago

Quote

Aashti

@Illuminati07

Dazzler

+ 6

Posted: 9 years ago

I agree with everything you sighted except for the fact about Ishaan cheating

Kissing someone else when you are still in a relationship is cheating. Even if you are in a meaningless relationship, even if the person you are in a relationship with is not ready for a break up, Kissing someone else for whatsoever reason is cheating.

It doesnt matter that Ishaan wanted to tell Malvika the truth but she wasnt in a position to handle it.. the right thing to do was to pursue his relationship with Aliya only after he ended it with Malvika.

Delaying such a news doesnt lessen the pain, it makes it worse... and cheating just cause your girlfriend isnt ready to handle the truth is a cowards way out. No matter what the circumstances, Ishaan should have broken up with Malvika before pursuing Aliya and I think that is the main reason the viewers were left with a bitter taste.

"wanting " to tell the truth but circumstances not being right might be understandable (not really) but it is not a justification for unfaithfulness

It is pretty obvious that Ishaan is in a physical relationship with Malvika.. As Dr Bedi says, you cannot walk out of a girl's bedroom after spending the night and just 'care' for her. We are no open society.

Breakup would hurt a girl but she would get past it.. Unfaithfulness would leave a girl scarred emotionally for a long time.

Oh yea I agree about Malvika not loving Ishaan and using him to satiate her ego.. But that doesnt mean she doesnt deserve things to be done the right way. Even people who get into relationships for ego sake dont realize it till its long over and they can look back and do some self analysis.

So yes Ishaan was wrong. He should have broken up with Malvika and then chased Aliya.

People fall out of love. Its not a crime. But least a person can do is close one chapter of their life before starting another or else it leaves the cheated one with a whole baggage of trust issues and no one no matter how hard hearted deserves that

Edited by aashti - 9 years ago

Quote

Blue Rose

@uniquebluerose

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

@idonkno

That was a bang on post...I agree with most of your points...esp regarding Malvika and Veer

@aashti

I quite agree with your arguments but then I believe what happened form the side of Ishaan was his desperateness... Malvika asks him to choose and then suddenly his good friend and confidant gives hims cold shoulder...he is comfortable talking to Aaliya but at that point she was not ready to listen to him or talk to him and obviously he became desperate possessive and of course Stupid...I am not saying this justifies what he did...but is understandable...

One thing I am shocked nobody seems to be worried about is the slap and Ishaan argument that Alya also kissed him...maybe I am a big time Aliya shipper but then I am sure it was not purposeful (either from Ishaan or Aliya) both just got carried away and the second time it plain Ishaan forcing himself upon her...and then his trying to chicken out by saying you also kissed me was total BS

Malvika however cheated she felt her name calling Aliya and slapping her was wrong...I wouldn't have justified the sap even if she had slapped Ishaan (though it would be understandable)...

Malvika has this sense of superiority about herself because of which she thinks only she "owns" Ishaan is entitled to Ishaan's love and friendship.

Her starting to trust Aliya is all a lie and she would not even thanked Aliya if the patch between her dad and herself has happened and Veer was not there. Malvika likes or pretends to like Aliya to keep Ishaan with herself and now she felt reassured because of the Veer-Aliya thing.

As for Veer I am pretty sure his character flip for Aliya is more because of the guilt and whole scenario of guild he feels doesn't make any sense. All he needs to say is he was there during the incident when major Akhtar went missing or was captured by the enemy camp.

Even now Veer giving a second chance makes no sense and is totally wrong he is doing it just so that his "mistake" is forgiven...if he really cares of Aaliya he should have listened to what she said and given her some space think about what you want.

Ishaan Malivka break up had to messy with or without the kiss between Ishaan-Aliya but Malivika just went down a notch by calling Aliya cheap...which was uncalled for...she still does not have the guts to understand she had lost Ishaan long back

As for all the rumours and gossip in hospital workplace romance has to be handled properly else can definitely go awry!!! Just like it happened here...

I guess I have ranted enough I really believe that all these tracks could have handled better by CVs

Quote

Top