Originally posted by: Honey-Friend
Haa! Kartik was a true lover! Reasons are listed below!
1. Kirti shadi fiasco when Aditya used to torture Kirti and Naira told him the truth, he didn't believe her. In fact, Naira had to show him proof (Kirti crying and doing her makeup to hide her bruises) for him to believe her. (Trust? What's that?)
2. He believed Naira didn't have the best interest of Kirti in her mind and that's why she shut him up during Keesh marriage. He blamed her for his sister's misfortune(?) when he himself had failed to notice the pain Kirti went through.
3. Blamed her for Subham's death.
4. Did baby swap of Krish without anyone's knowledge. He took Keesh baby without their permission. (Armaan is making the same mistake again but at least here it's Rohit who is doing the swap and Armaan is vehemently against it and later agrees only because of Abhira's health condition)
5. Character assassinated his loving faithful wife.
6. Married Vedika only to cheat on her. (it was wrong)
7. Blamed Naira (Again?? Seriously? Doesn't he understand the concept of accident? Blamed Naira for various other things. TBH He was a much better husband to Sirat than to Naira.)
8. Remarried within two years. (Yes you can remarry after your partner's death. But then you shouldn't make tall promises of never loving anyone else or dying without her. Tbh, Kartik and Naira were not suited for each other. Kartik was a good man and was a sensible person as long as he was living away from Goenkas. Maybe in an environment like the Maheswaris or Singhania's they would have flourished and lived happily ever after.)
9. Falling for Sirat and marrying her kinda proved that his love for Naira was superficial.
Your all points are appreciatable and good in quality wise.
Thank you Didi for replying because this us the only way we van find out why so much hate for Kartik Goenka.
I Guess I have no answer to these points except the fact that in rishta generation 2 last logner for 5 year 5 months 23 days.
So this is a long time and there are many thigns we can play with that character's arc and makers did they played successfully this long time.
And if they make Kartik stupid and doing everything for wife his character was not liked by me also,and I liked this Jolly Kartik not that one.
And I guess in each generation we can find such mini 2-3 episode mistakes, Because generation 1 was last long for 7 years and by this way we can found more mistakes of Naitik than Kartik did,I mean blaming Akshara and ignore Akshara and did not believe in Akshara and doubts her.
Generation 3 was only for 2 years compared to previous generation so there would've no mistake of character but can you say that there is a male lead exist who don't doubts his wife,who don't blame his wife,who don't ignored his wife,who don't punish his wife,who did not humilated her,who did not show his male ego,who did not tell her to get out of his house..
This is itv my friend and these are common tactics and situation that created in every generation and every show.
In rishta 4 it's one year Armaan changed in last 3 mitmhs but what's before that did tour forgot what's wrong he did with Abhira and of course he is whitewashed because he is a male lead,And 3 months good character arc is above all 9 previous months bad behaviour with her wife.
where are the people who call Armaan the worst male lead just because he sometimes go for Ruhi soemtiems for Abhira and Armaan loved twice.
And see his situation marru woman and said another woman not anything clearly but said that we are true lover,we will meet soon.
comment:
p_commentcount