Dear Amit Tandon Haters.... - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

50

Views

7.2k

Users

36

Likes

165

Frequent Posters

beckysharp thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: imperial

@pomegranite

Yes and you are the expert for which creatives come to make decisions on IF as to who is good at doing what. I also am not going to waste my time trying to make you and the KP groupies change their minds as to what proper acting or expressions are about b/c you guys have your own opinions which I see as bias rather than constructive. I appreciate Amit's acting ability as do many many others so will leave it at that


I am sorry, but I do take offense at the word groupie. On this forum no one has been spared when we have felt that the character has fallen short in portraying the emotions in the correct manner. Be it KP, DT or anyone else. I myself have crticizes AH umpteen number of times when I felt her expressions were monotonous n one dimensional. You are absolutely entitled to your opinion that AT is God's gift to Indian TV. But majority of the people on the forum feel he lacks acting skills and needs to improve, myself included. It is constructive criticism and he needs to take it in the same manner.

The thing that gets to most of us, is his justification where none is required... N his blowing his trumpet and his self importance.

He needs to realize HE is not the LEAD of this show ! KP is, n to give him his due, though KP is a superlative actor he has never stood up on a soap box and trumpeted his importance !



RaimaV thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: -MS-



You must be having brain fart otherwise you wouldn't have dragged KP into this. Don't tell me you and your family actually got fooled by reading those fake delusional news reports that said KP/Raman would be replaced by Subbu/Amit Tandon! If you believed that good luck with your state!

You bashed KP for no reason, totally out of the context but you should know that your beloved Amit Tandon wouldn't have got any chance to show his face in YHM if KP wouldn't have gone for holidays and CVs were not out of ideas.So at least be thankful, beta. 😳

And, more people are watching this? In what delusional world do you live in? It's KP's acting during Mani track that secured 2nd position for YHM for the first time. Whenever KP was sidelined the TRP dropped. If you want TRP charts I can provide that to you as well. When your beloved AT was on and KP was on leave, TRP dropped and YHM slipped to 5th position. Do check that as well. Last week earthquake scene was ridiculous but YHM was still at top 2. Check scrutiny blog if you don't believe me. In short, you're having brain fart.

But whom do I talking to? You made this account to defend Amit Tandon, all your 11 posts are just shameless campaigning for Amit Tandon. Do that if you want to but next time don't you dare drag KP into this.


Perfect reply...👏👏👏
-Anku- thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#43
As viewers we come with a right to put forward our opinion about YHM and its actors. We have rights to appreciate the goodness of tracks and have the same to do when the tracks are lame and questionable. And similarly if an actor whose made an entry as an important character (whose track is twisted, unnecessary and not interesting) and he makes it worse by not expressing whatever wafer thin depth that character has, we are obviously going to point that out.

TBH I do not understand Subbu's character at all. Normally you form an opinion or understanding of one character over time. We call Param a leech, Ashok insecure and Shagun a bitch. The actors have made the character trait come across that well. But Amit Tandon does NOTHING to justify what the character goes through. I am sure partly its the writing that's weak. But he gives nothing as an actor that affects me. His anger attacks are supposed to scare but instead they make me laugh. His despair over his wife's death should make me feel pity but it makes me yawn. And if he's negative I should be able to hate him, which also I am unable to do because I am so flabbergasted with the lameness of the characters existence in the story.

If you can't smile, cry or laugh along with a character, it means the actor has failed. I have seen Amit in shows before and he was always decent, or average. But NOW in YHM, even after giving him chance after chance, I think the less I talk about his 'acting' the better.

And I don't want to talk about him off screen because I barely know him. But his interviews seem OTT to me, because he's not even the lead really but talks like he knows what the real leads also do not know,or divulge if they do.
-K.13- thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: -Anku-

As viewers we come with a right to put forward our opinion about YHM and its actors. We have rights to appreciate the goodness of tracks and have the same to do when the tracks are lame and questionable. And similarly if an actor whose made an entry as an important character (whose track is twisted, unnecessary and not interesting) and he makes it worse by not expressing whatever wafer thin depth that character has, we are obviously going to point that out.


TBH I do not understand Subbu's character at all. Normally you form an opinion or understanding of one character over time. We call Param a leech, Ashok insecure and Shagun a bitch. The actors have made the character trait come across that well. But Amit Tandon does NOTHING to justify what the character goes through. I am sure partly its the writing that's weak. But he gives nothing as an actor that affects me. His anger attacks are supposed to scare but instead they make me laugh. His despair over his wife's death should make me feel pity but it makes me yawn. And if he's negative I should be able to hate him, which also I am unable to do because I am so flabbergasted with the lameness of the characters existence in the story.

If you can't smile, cry or laugh along with a character, it means the actor has failed. I have seen Amit in shows before and he was always decent, or average. But NOW in YHM, even after giving him chance after chance, I think the less I talk about his 'acting' the better.

And I don't want to talk about him off screen because I barely know him. But his interviews seem OTT to me, because he's not even the lead really but talks like he knows what the real leads also do not know,or divulge if they do.


Anku...

@purple: 🤣

I have seen AT's acting before & while he wasn't absolutely spectacular to me personally, he didn't royal stink either.

But here the combination of the horrible characterization, a mind numbing track, and 'interesting' off screen interviews...has unfortunately made it look like AT has dropped the ball to some degree. Had the character had better shape from the get go, then maybe people wouldn't react so strongly.
beckysharp thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: -K.13-


Anku...

@purple: 🤣

I have seen AT's acting before & while he wasn't absolutely spectacular to me personally, he didn't royal stink either.

But here the combination of the horrible characterization, a mind numbing track, and 'interesting' off screen interviews...has unfortunately made it look like AT has dropped the ball to some degree. Had the character had better shape from the get go, then maybe people wouldn't react so strongly.


Krishy, my dear hope your exams are ok ! We miss you and miss the mutual fangirling on our favourite person !

Hope to see ya back soon.
aukips thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#46
Subbu is a grey character it seems.nd amit is foing an average job..but he doesnt deserve this much bashing nd hatred. I am a hardcore fan of KP. But its not fair to compare anyone...!!
-K.13- thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: beckysharp


Krishy, my dear hope your exams are ok ! We miss you and miss the mutual fangirling on our favourite person !

Hope to see ya back soon.


Just 3 more days...then freedom & vellapanti! 😳 I miss spending more time gupshupping with everyone too! 🤗

Luckily for me - my daily short IF visits with this asinine track & leap talk have been wonderful destressors! 😆

Hope you are doing well! 🤗
beckysharp thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: -K.13-


Just 3 more days...then freedom & vellapanti! 😳 I miss spending more time gupshupping with everyone too! 🤗

Luckily for me - my daily short IF visits with this asinine track & leap talk have been wonderful destressors! 😆

Hope you are doing well! 🤗


We are all missing you ! Look forward to the gupshup when you are back. Aru, has had a fall n sprained her elbow !
Veeann thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: -K.13-


Just 3 more days...then freedom & vellapanti! 😳 I miss spending more time gupshupping with everyone too! 🤗

Luckily for me - my daily short IF visits with this asinine track & leap talk have been wonderful destressors! 😆

Hope you are doing well! 🤗


Krishy 🤗
leo4ever thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Commentator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#50
fact amit tandon cant act
even couldnt sing in indian idol
best could be a model

his poor acting skills and never ending attitude is prolly the reason he is still to make a mark or have own successful shows


Top