Originally posted by: pillowwillow
The ending was absolutely crap as i had expected from Umeira .The drama was purely senseless, does umera know wut she was writing. Many of the people must be reading the novel itself. tell me how many middle class women ,like zainy, out dere look for some so-called hidden msgs in dese writings,dey only read the words and sit and fantasize about em.money,colourful stuff, and ya ofcourse those few designers names that umera knows and flaunts by using their names in her novels and those few english words when she's writing an urdu novel.These kind of wriitngs mislead those women, dey wud want escape from dere depressed lives and idealise such novels as a reason for dem to do wrong things just because Allah had let dis happen to zainy n den she went onto become something big dey shud also forget Allah do same stuff and den after few years sit and do toba cuz after all it sounded so attractive in umeira's novel. And wut an abusrd ending . if zainay is quitting industry she must have such thoughts crossing her mind dat wut she was doing was wrong , and dere shes committing suicide a haram death over something rather funny, and wen karam reaches her flat and she has already jumped down,zainy's voice echoes in his mind dat "duniya say exit shandaar hona chahiye tragic and dramatic" .This is what umera's mentality is dat suicide is a SHANDAAR death. Kudos to her! dere r so many women who have dere marriages engagements broken and dey may vow never to marry again but dey never act this way. I dunno why umera is so impractical and ppl love her extremly senseless dip into fantasies. we ppl need something positive in our lives. These depressing things are already enuf in this world and so are the suicide rates .Umeira needs to grow up.And so are the readers , do not senselessly support some1, use your own brains.Read her novels for killing time but not for learning anything. And u want guidance den read quran.
It's easy to read about pain and enjoy the feeling of it as it may seems in writing but we all know how it is like when we are facing .
Every story is what YOU CHOOSE to believe... every practicing Muslim knows Sucide is Haram death... every Practicing muslim knows we should not go against Allah and bring the wrath of Him...
The problem with today's society is especially the young generation is they dont have any sense of right and wrong.. thats what Umera depicted in her novel... i am in a profession where i intereact with all sort of people and get to know abt their lives... trust me.. 99.9 % of the girls think... modelling, acting is an amazing profession , somoking , wearing sleevless, is really "cool"... and showbiz is an extremely awesome feild to enter. Had Umera shown Zainy to have gotten married to Karam THEN it would have given out the msg "you can do anything u want and then Allah can forgive you"..
My dear friend you didnt notice one thing the character Zainy NEVER repented she did regret doing all what she did but she never repented or seek forgiveness. She did all this to take revenge and take out her spite but the result was she spoiled her duniya and Akhraat too..!
In a place like pakistan .. the lower middle class girls fantasize about getting rich through coming into showbiz, becoming actress/actor ...
Its a sad dilema ... but my friend the point is its what ONE CHOOSES to think.. if an uneducated person with no sense except fantasies watches this drama he/she might get no msg and say.."crap.. she did what she want and in the end committed sucide? what the heck? she had a good going"... but see it in a broader way... like for me the msg was "no matter what the cirsumctances are we should trust and believe Allah coz he knows the best for us.. whatever Zainy did was Haram in every way ".. Had she trusted what her father said "Allah k Haar kaam main koi na koi Maslihaat hoti hae" (in everything Allah does there is a betterment for us) she would have known the result... if she had married her cousin/faincee.. even after marriage he would have resorted to Haram earning and it would have created a rift between them.. but she choose to follow the wrong path ..
And as for the sucide part... sucide is Haram..she didnt say go commit sucide... she just showed that.. Zainy spoiled her duniya and akhrat.. with doing haram things and now dying a haram death..
Edited by Xenubia - 16 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount