Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 10th Sep 2024 Written Update and EDT - Page 21

Originally posted by: firewings_diya

Saving some one in critical situation is different than saving someone when situation is not critical and making it more critical.

Let's consider two scenarios here.

1. Ak and neil silently followed that vehicle and then informed police and poice would have stopped the vehicle on the way and nabbed those culprits and then neil, ak and her unborns kids along with those orphans will be alive and those criminals would have been caught.

What what ak did.

Even though police would have arrived in 10 minutes. She wanted to jump and help those orphans. What if those criminals harmed those orpjans ?

Neil said what can we do. She was like i will go and save them. Neil in the end has to face them as if he would have not gone his bhabhi would have risked her life. Jiss abhir ko leke ak ne abhimanyu ko torture kiya that abhir is alive only because neil stopped his bhabhi and decided to sacrifice himself. As his bhabhi was not listening that she should not go alone.

What was the end result neil died. Abhir's sibling died, Manjari was in critical situation , roohi lost her father, arohi lost her husband and manajri and harsh lost their son and abhimanyu lost his brother. And most importantly those criminals escaped and now they might be kidnapping more kids as because of ak's stupid decision making skills instead of chasing them police had to go behind ak and neil who are in critical situation because of one stupid zidd of ak.

So AK is and was responsible for all the mess that happened but she just punished abhimanyu for the miseries that she bought upon herself.

Agar sab kanoon apne haath main lene lage then this world would have been filled with criminals as they can frame someonen as criminal and kill them and show that they are heros. Only when situation is very critical, if someone saves someone then they may get veera chakra but if the situation is not critical and they get more ppl killed because of their pea sized brain then they will get chappal from government also.

Mods : since neils death was shown in today's episode giving the context here.

my question is how can she think the death is caused by ruhi, it was a accident if she dint open her mouth and police investigation would have concluded it was a plain accident. But this stupid women miserably failed to handle the situation and on top of it she was running away ( goenkas dint throw her out) with abhir who is abhimanyu son. Such a literate fool she is

Originally posted by: Abhiabhi1

my question is how can she think the death is caused by ruhi, it was a accident if she dint open her mouth and police investigation would have concluded it was a plain accident. But this stupid women miserably failed to handle the situation and on top of it she was running away ( goenkas dint throw her out) with abhir who is abhimanyu son. Such a literate fool she is

She was a fool. Ek bacchi ko naya trauma dekhar nikal gayi. That bacchi was waiting for her father figure usko bathaya thak nahi he died along with brother. Zindagi bhar ka trauma de diya usse.

Originally posted by: firewings_diya

Saving some one in critical situation is different than saving someone when situation is not critical and making it more critical.

Let's consider two scenarios here.

1. Ak and neil silently followed that vehicle and then informed police and poice would have stopped the vehicle on the way and nabbed those culprits and then neil, ak and her unborns kids along with those orphans will be alive and those criminals would have been caught.

What what ak did.

Even though police would have arrived in 10 minutes. She wanted to jump and help those orphans. What if those criminals harmed those orpjans ?

Neil said what can we do. She was like i will go and save them. Neil in the end has to face them as if he would have not gone his bhabhi would have risked her life. Jiss abhir ko leke ak ne abhimanyu ko torture kiya that abhir is alive only because neil stopped his bhabhi and decided to sacrifice himself. As his bhabhi was not listening that she should not go alone.

What was the end result neil died. Abhir's sibling died, Manjari was in critical situation , roohi lost her father, arohi lost her husband and manajri and harsh lost their son and abhimanyu lost his brother. And most importantly those criminals escaped and now they might be kidnapping more kids as because of ak's stupid decision making skills instead of chasing them police had to go behind ak and neil who are in critical situation because of one stupid zidd of ak.

So AK is and was responsible for all the mess that happened but she just punished abhimanyu for the miseries that she bought upon herself.

Agar sab kanoon apne haath main lene lage then this world would have been filled with criminals as they can frame someonen as criminal and kill them and show that they are heros. Only when situation is very critical, if someone saves someone then they may get veera chakra but if the situation is not critical and they get more ppl killed because of their pea sized brain then they will get chappal from government also.

Mods : since neils death was shown in today's episode giving the context here.

Adding reference of one of the true hero and its shame to compare them with ak.

https://youtube.com/shorts/MVH73tkP5mc?si=-Z6AIoKFIhGxrg4N

Whatever the scenarios were she could not be labeled as 'Khooni'. Agree it was the case of poor decision making that cause all miseries, agree that what abhi did was also aligned with the circumstances created, but who stopped him to find the whereabouts of akshara once the dust settled?? As it was he who divorced her. He listened that call to manish after 7 months... It was way too much a time for someone to mend relations if he really wanted to??? As he was the one to claim her back from abhinav in the hospital before knowing that abhir is his biological son.

I am not supporting akshara by any means here regarding her stupid decision makings but my whole point is she was not the only person at the time who took wrong decisions. And irrespective of whatever happened she was not the one to stab/shoot/push anyone here nor did she intentionally planned anything, Hence can't be called a Murderer/khooni.

Originally posted by: Krinya

Abhira ko chaanta laga ? Sapne mei? Ye kaisa detailed wala sapna hai

But MG kab sathiyega Matlab.. why would abhira break her engagement if MG is abhiras maayka ?

arey samjho Manish wants abhira to go away 😛

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

Before any shaadi and nautanki I want abhira to prove her mother's innocence in Arohi's hit and run case. Raha sawal Neil ki death ka toh jab woh khandaan hi nahi raha toh I don't think uska koi relevance bhi bacha hai story mein. For me if Neil's death is caused by akshu then abhinav's death is also caused by manyu. I don't think an adult jumping into a trouble with his full conscience has anything to do with others accompanying him/her.

But this pagal aurat (Ruhi) who is no more a bachi should know this by now that it was her driving adventure that has caused the death of her matashree.

That pagal aurat is going to blame Abhira for that now.usse support karne ke liye that vile dadi bhi.How she slapped Abhira for her hatred towards Abhira's mother in Manish dream?MG can miscalculate how Abhira's reaction will be knowing about Ak's past but no way he misjudged Ruhi who he raised.

You know what Akshara put a gun on Neil's head and forced him and threatened if he dint she will kill him thatswhy he get into it and died.Ak knew he will anyway going to die in that it's not available in ordinary hotstar which we use .dont come into manyu.iy will be more worse .He bring divorce papers and made her sign in it when she just had a miscarriage and he dint listen when she called him about one child being alive.But galti kiski?Akshara ki.for running away and moving on with another man .

Originally posted by: Abhiabhi1

my question is how can she think the death is caused by ruhi, it was a accident if she dint open her mouth and police investigation would have concluded it was a plain accident. But this stupid women miserably failed to handle the situation and on top of it she was running away ( goenkas dint throw her out) with abhir who is abhimanyu son. Such a literate fool she is

how can ak blame a 6 yr old kid. It's all for her guilt free life only she ran away. If she sees ruhu in front daily she feels arohis death by her.

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

Whatever the scenarios were she could not be labeled as 'Khooni'. Agree it was the case of poor decision making that cause all miseries, agree that what abhi did was also aligned with the circumstances created but who stopped him to find the whereabouts of her when the dust settled?? As it was he who divorced her. He listened that call to manish after 7 months... It was way too much a time for someone to mend relations if he really wanted to??? As he claimed her from abhinav in the hospital before knowing that abhir is his biological son.

I am not supporting akshara by any means here regarding her stupid decision makings but my whole point is she was not the only person at the time who took wrong decisions. And irrespective of whatever happened she was not the one to stab/shoot/push anyone here nor did she intentionally planned anything, Hence can't be called a Murderer/khooni.

Ak is not a murderer but her decisions costed a life. People have every right to call out her stupid decision making skills.

Even ruhi ne bhi armaan se affair nahi kiya and even was not manoing sr with him but just because she has feeling for armaan she is being called out as lusty.is anyone stopping them ?

No right. Then ppl can tag ak as murderer if they feel so as kya patha nobody can be so stupid to take decision that killed ppl multiple times. Agar repeatedly same galthi log karenge toh woh galthi nahi gunah hotha hai.

Edited out gen#3 discussion not related to the episode

Originally posted by: firewings_diya

She was a fool. Ek bacchi ko naya trauma dekhar nikal gayi. That bacchi was waiting for her father figure usko bathaya thak nahi he died along with brother. Zindagi bhar ka trauma de diya usse.

what ruhi is today is because of ak.
Abandoned by all loved ones and deaths of her own made ruhi this today. Manish may dance as akshu ki beti but once ruhi is in danger he will hold her no doubts.

Edited out gen#3 discussions not related to the episode

Rohit left home on his own seeing ruhi and ar side of perception. But ruhi is mocked as khoooooni for rohit missing incident. Did ruhi kill him or told him to go away.

Originally posted by: viji2111

Didn't she knowing what happened to Abhir when he was separated from his mother and father figure. The boy lost his senses, ran away from the house. Abhimanyu had to return the kid to them for his son's happiness. And here Roohi lost her mother and doesn't even know Abhimanyu is dead and thinks he left her and is enjoying his life with mausi and kids.

ak is selfish always looked for herself and her convenience. She got support for her crime and illegal deeds through an illiterate idiot so she was walking on sky boasting about that pati with whom there is only till till end.