Why this show isn't working?

Hey guys, I have been watching this hsow diligently since I am a huge fan of HC and JW, and while I think the concept is super interesting, I think the show is just not working on a global level. I wanted to see what you guys thought.

This show reminds of Gul's show with HC, Humsafars on Sony. He played a relatively similar character, an angry young man guy whose actions and emotions were so intense that they often felt unrealistic and idiotic (and I remember these random shirtless scenes which while I visually appreciated 😆, just felt like they were totally unnecessary as in this show).

This show has made a huge error by not showing us more of Aditya/Pooja and Yash/Zoya before the accident because now I can't relate to any of them. Adi seems like a ball of crazy, Zoya seems like a doormat/overly naive, and Pooja/Yash just seem like non-entities who I have no opinion of and keep getting random flashbacks of. I can't relate to them because I didn't have a chance to connect with them. The ancillary characters like Adi's sister and the parents equally do a lot of over-acting, I still don't understand what their hang ups are.

I have a feeling this show is also going to get shut down like Humsafars though I hope that's not the case. What do you think?

I dont know about you but the place where i live this show is pretty popular already so its obviously working for us.

Well I am from outside India and in my country people are just loving this sow and I think the show is working pretty well in India as well andtrps are it's biggest proof. But keeping the trps aside from my POV I think this show is going pretty strong it has all the elements that will keep the audience glued to it. Plus comparing it with a show like Humsafar will not be fair because in that show the story was not that good plus the actress was horrible. Here we have two best actors in the lead roles and the story is interesting too

I agree with TM on some points.

I just started to watch this show and caught up to it.I am from overseas and I think in general on social media there is a good buzz about this show. It has made an impression. I have seen Jennifer in SC and Beyhadh and Harshad in Humsafars. So I know both their work a bit. Acting wise, they are both experienced and seasoned performers. No issues there.

I know a lot of people can't relate to Adi's anger and the way he is behaving with Zoya but I think it's totally justified.

1. He has been through all of this as a kid when his dad cheated on his mum so he has already had a disturbed childhood hence a lot of his anger comes from that

2. Yash is dead so he can't hurt him but to vent he can hurt his family hence Zoya is the target

3. Even I would be pissed off if my counter part would be sympathetic towards a cheater! He can't understand how anyone can forgive' a cheater and again this goes back to his childhood. He probs sees his mum in Zoya. His mum accepted his dad's two timing and now Zoya according to him is doing the same so this is naturally going to make him mad and this is his way of dealing with his sorrows.

If both were alive, Adi would've gone to Yash, beaten him to death and then taken out all his anger on Pooja but he can't do that.

He feels he has been cheated on. How else is he supposed to react. He hates his father for this very same reason and now it's happened to him. What else can he do.

Tbh I can't relate to Zoya. She needs to grow a spine and stop sobbing! OK she believes Yash didn't cheat on her but does she really believe his sister is that nice overnight?

If u say humsafar serial sahir's character , that was really dark , layered, intense character, a character had mission in life 2 fulfill that he can do anything, in humsafar serial was rubbish including lead actress , only sahir was gud character.