ma-nishada thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
I don't know what i am going to say is relevant to the situation here or not?
I am not an ardent fan of MATSH nor a regular viewer of the show, but a regular visitor of the forum. I just want to ask you lovely people one thing, Sympathy for a character is ok , Empathy for a character is also human, but isn't it awkward to try to find out ourselves or our partner in a character?, that too a character created by Ekta. I felt, that's what you people are doing here.. trying to find out sense and sensibility.. but all in vain.. It's not necessary that everybody like each and every character, but is it necessary for us to defend or offend these characters? They are created by their creators to behave like this only and that's their creative freedom..


Our real lives are much much better than tv daily dramas and mostly not dramatic.. but ha drama occurs once in a blue moon. So some of us whom are comparing real and reel may find it difficult to connect with the characters. For that viewers, i just want to say , watch the show for the actors or for producers or for directors or for creatives or for all the people who are doing hard works both in front of and behind the camera.. please don't try to find sense. That will only kill your enjoyment.. and if you are not enjoying you can always change the channel.





Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

2.1k

Users

6

Likes

71

Frequent Posters

*Reemz* thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Interesting post.

I think if characters always behaved in the 'right' way then there is nothing to debate.

It's fiction, the creatives create characters which are meant to make you think. If they don't then the writers have failed.

It's not necessary to agree with their actions either. This show has a resemblance to Wuthering Heights and both Heathcliff and Catherine often acted in a way where you would question their 'love'. It wasn't conventional or relatable but it was THEIR world, their story created by the author. You can't agree with them all the time.

Ishani has acted stupid, Ranveer has acted rude but this is how the story moves on as well as their characters.

You can't suddenly say they shouldn't be together when the characters themselves want to be together. It makes no sense to me anyway.
life_is_fun thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Nice post 👏
A post which actually helps in bringing back my sanity...

For me criticizing and discussing things are not bad ... After all that is what IF is meant for... 😊 And trust me I have seen wonderful writers over here ... I agree with their POV or not is a completely different thing...
There have been people who come with really comical posts or the posts which beautifully describes the love of these two characters...

But it is really sad to see people lacking the cult of tolerance not realizing that at the end of the day there are real people around and we should not fight for fictional characters.. 😊


ma-nishada thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
@Reemz
Thank you for expressing your views.
Yes, i am agreeing with you... that's their story and what's happening in it is not in our hands to make it perfect for them and us...


About debate..

Fictions can be serious and non serious. Almost all the dramas running in our prime channels are non serious and has no social messages or say socially irrelevant topics... so i think, heated debate over fictional characters with no social relevance is too much.. yez we can take sides and debate... but there should be a limit... ryt???

most of the trp viewers, in our words the trp aunties, don't need a sensible story.. they just need high voltage dramas to boost minds and energise systems in their otherwise mechanical and not so happening
life.. i think... so this will continue and all the Ektaz and Guls and Saurabhz etc will continue to run the business smoothly..
Edited by ma-nishada - 9 years ago
BeEverVectorMan thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: life_is_fun

Nice post 👏

A post which actually helps in bringing back my sanity...

For me criticizing and discussing things are not bad ... After all that is what IF is meant for... 😊 And trust me I have seen wonderful writers over here ... I agree with their POV or not is a completely different thing...
There have been people who come with really comical posts or the posts which beautifully describes the love of these two characters...

But it is really sad to see people lacking the cult of tolerance not realizing that at the end of the day there are real people around and we should not fight for fictional characters.. 😊



Wow Pooja bang on point...yes these is the platform where we can discussed and give our views in free and frank way no one needs to get hurt...they don't own the characters... Even the actors who act for a particular character don't own it...and here we fight for it...

And yes as reemz point out its writers way of thinking...but no writers will dare to think what marsh cv's think...still now I have not come to the terms of character assignation of ritika...the lady who fell in love with the rapist...that is weird...and ladies shown get preggy PM...

Greetings
life_is_fun thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: BeEverVectorMan


Wow Pooja bang on point...yes these is the platform where we can discussed and give our views in free and frank way no one needs to get hurt...they don't own the characters... Even the actors who act for a particular character don't own it...and here we fight for it...

And yes as reemz point out its writers way of thinking...but no writers will dare to think what marsh cv's think...still now I have not come to the terms of character assignation of ritika...the lady who fell in love with the rapist...that is weird...and ladies shown get preggy PM...

Greetings

Anup,

Ritika's character is something which goes at least from 10 feets above my head.. 😆

All I can say that if our show is not showing soft hearted things which we should not expect also 😆, at least we should write words which actually do not hurt anybody's feelings... Why is it so difficult to write something which is gentle... Today was a very bad day for IF... So many fights I saw ... RV vs. Ishaani, Ishkar Vs. Ishaani...

Seeing the agression on the threads, I did not even feel like posting... 😭

BeEverVectorMan thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Greetings Pooja,
Please don't feel bad...at least you people are their whose post I really feel to read and have a good laugh...seriously you few people are talented and gifted writers whose post I enjoy reading...

The fight will go on till the very last day of episode... Also till few weeks after the end of episode... But one can laugh the way it will move ahead as days will progress...
ma-nishada thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: BeEverVectorMan


Wow Pooja bang on point...yes these is the platform where we can discussed and give our views in free and frank way no one needs to get hurt...they don't own the characters... Even the actors who act for a particular character don't own it...and here we fight for it...

And yes as reemz point out its writers way of thinking...but no writers will dare to think what marsh cv's think...still now I have not come to the terms of character assignation of ritika...the lady who fell in love with the rapist...that is weird...and ladies shown get preggy PM...

Greetings


@life is fun..
I too love IF. Had met so many talented, budding writers here.. we wont usually criticize our friend's creativity... even though we feel itz not good enough.. we will accept it as his or her creativity and some times we might just comment like.. you can do better than this dear... or some thing like that... but when comes to the real show most of us do OTT things... Healthy debates are always good..

@be ever vector man..

I think you are new to Indian dramas... any thing can happen here... man handling to rape... memory loss to facial plastic surgery... death to rebirth... so don't get upset dear... and be always ready for a roller coaster ride...


life_is_fun thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: BeEverVectorMan

Greetings Pooja,

Please don't feel bad...at least you people are their whose post I really feel to read and have a good laugh...seriously you few people are talented and gifted writers whose post I enjoy reading...

The fight will go on till the very last day of episode... Also till few weeks after the end of episode... But one can laugh the way it will move ahead as days will progress...


Well thanx Anup... But to make posts I have to at least watch the episodes...😆
And I am happy that some of you people are there whose posts I can attack and defend without giving a second thought. It is always my wish... 😆 😆

life_is_fun thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ma-nishada


@life is fun..
I too love IF. Had met so many talented, budding writers here.. we wont usually criticize our friend's creativity... even though we feel itz not good enough.. we will accept it as his or her creativity and some times we might just comment like.. you can do better than this dear... or some thing like that... but when comes to the real show most of us do OTT things... Healthy debates are always good..

@be ever vector man..

I think you are new to Indian dramas... any thing can happen here... man handling to rape... memory loss to facial plastic surgery... death to rebirth... so don't get upset dear... and be always ready for a roller coaster ride...



ma-nishada;

All the power lies in the hands of EK... 😆 She is the one who wraps people in the web of her shows and she is the one who has the power to release all the people who are trapped.. 😆
Top