marks Warning on PG 41 READ everyone - Page 3

605921

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka
Plain and simple... GC dance was not a dance but a jumping all over the places.

😆 i agree iw was uchal kud

2

Reply

Quote

433796

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Fans will never change which is given be it dance, singing shows or serials...Makes it very hard to critic than...In this whole mess GIA and Pratyusha got the short end of the stick..

I am not losing respect for Shampa... ek teacher to apna jee jaan laga deta hai, lekin it depends on student ke woh kitna talented hai... Sushaant was at entirely different level in dancing, so it was easy to get best out of him. Ab every to Shampa Lucky nahin ho sakti(dancing talent wise) but she is lucky she got GC the heartthrob blah blah as her student.. so it is sure she will be there till finals.

2

Reply

Quote

Rapier

@Rapier

Rocker

25

Posted: 12 years ago

#23

I don't think anybody is gonna like this, but I thought none of the performances this week deserved a 30. Shibani, Isha, Gurmeet were very good. But I thought 30 was a bit much. That implies that there was absolutely NOTHING wrong with the performances, which I don't agree. Out of the three, Shibani's was the best, and then Isha's, and then Gurmeet's.

29 for Shibani, 28 for Isha, and 27 for Gurmeet should've been the scores.

I also don't quite agree with the other scores as well. Archana's was bad I admit, but not worse than Sushil's. And Bharti did better than Sushil. Scores should reflect that. I liked Jayati's performance very much, but a 10 from Remo was a bit much, but it's ok. 28 is good. And although Darsheel did really well, I think 27 or 28 would've been a better score.

My $0.02!

6

Reply

Quote

chocobear

@chocobear

Inactive

28

Posted: 12 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka
Plain and simple... GC dance was not a dance but a jumping all over the places.

hawwwab toh gayi/gaye tum kaam se😆

2

Reply

Quote

akruz

@akruz

Voyager

17

Posted: 12 years ago

#25

I dont know whether the judgement was scripted..but i completely agree that neither Gurmeets performance nor Shibanis performance deserved a 30. If you compare what Salman-Isha did to what GC did or Shibani did, then Salman-Isha should get more marks...even i had tears when i saw Shibanis act, but bringing personal touch to dances, showing off ones emotions and getting marks from it, i dont approve...Madhuri said emotions outplayed the dance and we didnt see where the hands went or legs went..hmm...thats bad..she is there to judge...and i really cant think of making a dance concept out of my deceased cousin... meager commercialisation...

GCs act was good, but certainly not 30...then i feel Jayati deserves 30 tooo..i had tears in my eyes when she cried...it was very genuine...Madhuri Karan never pointed out a mistake for Jayati,.then y restrict to 9 and not 10...

1

Reply

Quote

605921

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: chocobear

hawwwab toh gayi/gaye tum kaam se😆

😭 ghor paap huagya in se 😭 🤣

2

Reply

Quote

chocobear

@chocobear

Inactive

28

Posted: 12 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: Be.A.Rebel
😭 ghor paap huagya in se 😭 🤣

aankhein band kar lo..humne kuch nahi dekha kuch nahi pada kuch nahi likha😆

2

Reply

Quote

gururockss

@gururockss

Inactive

27

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#28

ahahah

i was waiting for a negative post again

and look i found it lolz

keep rocking guys...

i perrsonally loved GC's performance and according to me it was a well deserved 30

7

Reply

Quote

danceismyworld

@danceismyworld

Dazzler

24

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#29

Well...What a topic...No offence...but after reading the views of TM and some comments..I am feeling like You have any particular problem with GC...Well about He deserved 30 marks or not...and judges were biased or not...I think a rational viewer knows it very well...and you talk about flaws...well to be honest..there were same flaws in Isha and salman performance..Those 30 maks of Isha and salman mainly belongs to concept(and you know that very well)...But i don't want to mention because you guys don't want to see that...so i don't want to waste my time and energy...😳

oh...k judges are biased...Don't you think by saying that You are insulting them...

Remo Desuza...(most strict and loyal dance judge ever( in DID history too)), Can he be BIASED or SCRIPTED towards dance???????? He will never do that.😳

Atleast Don't insult dance by saying this...If you can't respect someone...then you shouldn't insult them either

And about other two, I won't comment as I don't know them properly and have not right to judge them as a person!!!😳

Edited by danceismyworld - 12 years ago

7

Reply

Quote

605921

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: chocobear

aankhein band kar lo..humne kuch nahi dekha kuch nahi pada kuch nahi likha😆

😭😭 nahe choco g ab to parh lia 😭😭

Reply

Quote