Posted:
[QUOTE=Indradhanush
[/QUOTE]
1. His music is for lower class was not stated by me, I typed something said by Javed Akhtar in coffe with karan about HR
2. IMHO most of the HR songs are based on Aeolian mode with hardly any use of raaga.
3. OK to each his own pls tell me why ARR has got so many awards in last 15 years,. do you think HR can match this in same time period, if this is not about quality what is it (Ok lets put class aside):
1. I know u did not state that his music was for lower classes, I know u will not generalise like this. I was replying to the person who had said the same and u jumped in on my reply to her and hence was in the cross fire of exchanges. And u have quoted Javed wrongly, he has said that his music is for the Masses (masses and classes) are 2 different things. Mass means appealing to a large section of society and class means something else. High class and low class are terms which i feel are degrading and people use it very loosely showing how irresponsible and imature they are.
2. As i said, personal opinion is different, you may have one and I may have another. Its best if you respect the other wons view.
3. ARR has got many awards because is a great music director and gives great music. I have never said that HR is the only good director. He is also good but yes I agree that ARR is great at composing and deserves accolades. But at times I feel that he gets it one name, this year as per me he did not deserve for Guru. It should have gone to VS for OSO or MOnty for Saawariya.
If MAdan Mohan did not get as many filmfares like ARR does not mean he was not a good MD. I dont understand this urge of generalising views and forcing them onto others.
comment:
p_commentcount