Simi gave one score for almost all

I couldn't figure on what basis did Simi give Narayani, Apurva, Mouni and Juhi, give all of them 8 points. Though all four did sing pretty well, I think Narayani, Apurva were definitely better than Mouni and Juhi, yet they all got the same scores from her. Her score showed no difference whereas her comments said something else !

Also as compared to his previous two performances, Sumeet definitely didn't deserve a complete 10 yesterday.

And this surely a bad move of giving an authority to the ousted participant to save any one. He/She are surely to choose friendship over singing !

Looks like all reality shows this one is on the road to drama and controversies too. And they led us to believe that its going to be pure fun and enjoyment.

Michelle

may be she weighs 8o lb or her waist size is 8
Just kidding.

Hmm, she should have thought for bit before giving the points.
Apurva = 9 truly
Mouni = 9
Juhi = 8
Narayani = 7

Originally posted by: sweety23

may be she weighs 8o lb or her waist size is 8
Just kidding.

Hmm, she should have thought for bit before giving the points.
Apurva = 9 truly
Mouni = 9
Juhi = 8
Narayani = 7

Karan knows how to score and to look for what

I agree wid this scoring,

I felt the same Mich I feel she is not givig scores as what she talks abt their ability to sing.. Actually the scores are suppose to be givien then and their after the song is completed as you speak but they have spoken someth elese and then scores say a dofferent weightage.. 😕
Kjo was quite fair in his points... 😳

Michelle thats why before the start of this show I said this in Anuu's post that they should hv roped in someone who is realted to the Singing field 😃

What Simi and Karan understands about Sur and Taal??? 😕

Karan can still judge the X-Factor and all that but what will Simi judge?? 😕

Now wonder she is either sticking to 8 for good performance or 6 for Average performance

I strongly felt that Apu deserved at least 18 or 19 out of 20 for his yesterday's performance 😃

He was mayb better than even Sumeet yesterday in terms of pitching and Sur 😊