why doesnt pihu deserve rudra... - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

4.2k

Users

18

Likes

77

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Additi_sjfan



awesome qns. ag fan but i dont want ag as guari. pihu has more zeist. binny as pihu, interesting would love to see that. would honestly still like pihu more. she brings something new n refreshing.

i want pihu n gauri to be friends. :)



But would you still ship Rudra-Pihu if Binny was playing Pihu?? I can understand all the ppl enjoying the AG-IK chemistry cuz they do have fab chemistry together of that there is no doubt....but I genuinely don't buy into the argument that as characters also Rudra-Pihu work together....no they don't.....no matter how many arguments ppl want to put forth about the complexities of love etc.....this relationship does not have any understanding to it....no matter what kind of "love" Pihu has for Rudra....so it just can't work.
Paru... thumbnail
Anniversary 15 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: -Shankar-

Now tell me, if AG got the role of Gauri and Binny got the role of Pihu. Wouldn't you be blasting at her? And wouldn't you want Gauri and Rudra together?



it was AG's decision to accept the role of Pihu.being fans our duty is to encourage her in whatever she does.but i would like to see more onscreen chemistry of AG and and iQ as i liked their chemistry and still believe that their experience in doing romantic scenes will really do good for the show.
Additi_sjfan thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: nureat01



But would you still ship Rudra-Pihu if Binny was playing Pihu?? I can understand all the ppl enjoying the AG-IK chemistry cuz they do have fab chemistry together of that there is no doubt....but I genuinely don't buy into the argument that as characters also Rudra-Pihu work together....no they don't.....no matter how many arguments ppl want to put forth about the complexities of love etc.....this relationship does not have any understanding to it....no matter what kind of "love" Pihu has for Rudra....so it just can't work.



I dont want Pihu-Rudr to be together... be it binny/ag as Pihu.. Pihu-Rudr love story like u said, they were never meant to be... which is why i find their love story interesting.. not all love stories r meant to be afterall...

but i would like to see more Pihu-Rudr love story cos its can be made interesting if wanted... (binny/ag as pihu)....

that said.. i like Pihu but yes i'd like Pihu more when AG is playin Pihu... cos now its my fav actress playing a char i actually like...
iqbalslover thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Additi_sjfan



honestly yaar. whr do u get ur concept of love from? ever heard of 'love is complicated' ????

i think whoever is in love knows the "concept" of love.
i am not deaf so definitely i have heard about love being compleicated
kasturika_kashu thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: steffroc

i think whoever is in love knows the "concept" of love.

i am not deaf so definitely i have heard about love being compleicated

👏👏👏👏👏 and thnx rabi for agreeing with me.... its really sad to see sometimes coz of the huge fan following of some actor... there is an impact in the concept of the story.... just thnk wat the state of these people might be if additi got replaced here....😆😆😆😉
kasturika_kashu thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: -Shankar-

Now tell me, if AG got the role of Gauri and Binny got the role of Pihu. Wouldn't you be blasting at her? And wouldn't you want Gauri and Rudra together?

yaa... am in all ears to know the answer of this question.....😆😆😆😆😉
kasturika_kashu thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: nureat01



But would you still ship Rudra-Pihu if Binny was playing Pihu?? I can understand all the ppl enjoying the AG-IK chemistry cuz they do have fab chemistry together of that there is no doubt....but I genuinely don't buy into the argument that as characters also Rudra-Pihu work together....no they don't.....no matter how many arguments ppl want to put forth about the complexities of love etc.....this relationship does not have any understanding to it....no matter what kind of "love" Pihu has for Rudra....so it just can't work.

👏👏👏👏 i love ur answers.......👏👏👏
pomegranate thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#38
ok after reading many topics in this forum, i get the vibe that people want pihu-rudra togather because of their chem or because AG is playing pihu and if ruhu are togather aditi/pihu will become the main character. a questing that has been lingering in mind is, if AG played gauri would you still want pihu and rudr togather? sure pihu has a lot of layers but in my view she is selfish, egotisical, immature, arrogant and stubborn even if both got married, they wouldn't last because they're not compatible, both rudr and pihu has similar neg personalities which will only make them logger heads. how is their Lovestory interesting? all they do is fight and confront eachother, I see no love between them!
what pihu did to rudra was despicable but it wasn't only pihu's fault rudra is to be blamed too. but I find it immature and stupid for a girl to break off a marriage at the last minute and embarass rudra in front of hundreds of people. if they really loved eachother- no actually if pihu really loved rudra then she would of made it work but now its too late. she is marrying abhay and I will seriously pity her if she runs back to rudra after he is married to gauri
monaha262 thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#39
I also think that pihu doesn't deserve rudra because she is selfish girl and her ego is really big. I think because of her ego she is not able to understand the real meaning of love and also she is fail to understand rudra. On the other hand I think guari deserve rudra because she is strong and she have no ego because of that she will understand rudra and his love.
ShadowKisses thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: kaasshh

i thnk any other grl....just any other grl wud be perfect for rudra except pihu... she was selfish,arrogant and loved him the least.... she loved only and only herself.... she falls in the same category as rudra's family.... whu does nt care for rudra becoz he is RUDRA bt becoz he is some kind of related to them.... 🤢🤢 wich,to me,is SICK...🤢

in the original story devdas,it wasnt parvati's fault.. it was purely devdas's fault,whu was himself frickle-minded and whimsical.... bt in THIS story... rudra has no fault....just no fault... so why the hell is he getting hurt by each and evry person huh?😡 how cn these people be sooo sooo heartless?😡 and pihu is one among them too.. heartless..thats what she is.....😡
if u want to break up with ur lover.. whu happens to be ur childhood frnd too.... wud u evr do it in such a horrible way...? like as if twisting the lifeblood out of his heart frst.. and then breaking it into a zillion pieces.... and then leaving him? after KILLING him? 😡😡😡 dnt u thnk thats insane? u may break up u may nt find him perfect for u... bt it cud also have vbeen done in a vry vry PROPER way.... bt pihu did it it such a way.... wich revealed that she did nt only want to break up with him... bt she also wanted to hurt him to the core... and believe me... one day she will get it back... frm that person whu is above all.....😡
she may feel upset coz rudra slapped her... bt tell me this frnds...why actually did rudra slap her? coz she was trying to prove in frnt of him that she is soo broad-minded... in spite of such a wonderful proposal and gift package like ABHAY.. she was still clinging with him.....😡😡😡😡 if i wud have in rudra's place i wud have slapped my partner and tell him to go to hell.... bt wat did rudra do? he had no fault,yet he came down on his knees and asked for forgiveness.. and that maharani....?😡🤬
after seeing so many thngs...... i have absolutely noo respect left for pihu.. she is trul;y a disgrace in the name of woman... whu is known for her tender nature...and her affectionate heart..... pihu does nt evn have a heart... and she DOES NT DESERVE A PERSON LIK RUDRA... though i know......that she will try to return back to rudra agen in the future... bt then i want rudra to do the same thngs to her as she did to him.....

I get the gist of your post but personally, I abhor the idea that someone in the relationship has to "deserve" the other. IMO, it is more that her personality does not complement his, nor his hers.
I also think Pihu is being unfairly portrayed as an egomaniac. I can't name a single girl I know who would be easily placated by an apology after her fiance slapped her. More than ego, it's about self-respect and I can't fault her for that. I would have been more disgusted with her character had she just turned over and forgiven him regardless of how heartfelt his words may have been. Words and apologies don't make everything rosy. Different strokes for different folks, I guess.
Also, I think people focus way too much on how hurt Rudra (hurt-comfort phenomenon) got after Pihu agreed to marry Abhay (a decision I consider extremely rash, just saying) -- what of Pihu? I can't imagine how betrayed and hurt (emotionally) she would be feeling if the one person she is supposed to trust above everyone else to protect her, slaps her in a moment of complete irrationality.
Pray tell, what exactly is a person like Rudra? I'm not Pihu's biggest fan but I think you're glossing over Rudra's many apparent flaws. He has insecurity issues, gets jealous very easily, impulsive agression, reactive rather than proactive, needy, etc. Point is -- he has a lot of qualities that aren't attractive just as she does. It doesn't make her any less "deserving" of him than it makes him, of her.
Furthermore, what you described as the idea of a woman: "tender nature" and "affectionate heart" sounds a tad stereotypical. Why does she have to conform to some idealist archetype? That she isn't a soft-spoken, gentle, conciliatory person isn't an argument against her, but rather an aspect of her personality.
Top