26-aug-2019: Dr shashank's words - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

4.9k

Users

12

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

ms.nitya12 thumbnail
Anniversary 8 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 0 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#21

Since I am one of the late comers 😆I am commenting on yesterday's episode ( about a couple of days back I had mentioned the same in another post) unfortunately, ITV equates the shades of intentions with good or bad in terms of characterization & layers to flaw in characters end up looking as flaws in writing .

Throwing a spanner in the works , suffused with incisive feelings around influence, culpability -emotional blackmail ignorance, incomprehensions etc, from Juniors still might stretch for clemency with the tutelage- it looks cosmetic cursory, an early manifestation around the clarity & compromises with characterization for broader, typical excessive " aim & scheme " brackets, peels away the skin of characters exposing skeletons that don't look prepossessing to viewers while watching.

angel_nonu thumbnail
Anniversary 8 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: super7879

But if it weren't for Sid wasn't the girl thrown out of Sanjivani and wouldn't she have died?? So even if a number of doctors performed the surgery on her. The most credit goes to Sid for bringing her back into Sanjivani.

What Sid does is unethical, agreed. I don't know how many have had experiences with big hospitals. Its a rip off without asking you to do extra surgeries. I understand that deluxe room has extra charges for the room but If you book a deluxe room your MRI will cost 4 times that of a shared room, Why is that? wouldn't you be under the same machine as the others and wouldn't your results take as long. All this money goes to the owners or board of directors of these hospitals. Why is it okay for them to do it for fattening their pockets but not for Sid to do it to save someone else's life?

About Girl being thrown so then I can say If Dr Ishani had not got to girl and also wouldn't have helped to get her to sanjivani at first then She wouldn't be saved. If Ishani wouldn't have helped Dr Sid to take her till OT She wouldn't been saved to how is only one person getting most credit.

I did not know that deluxe room MRI costs 4 times more than normal but if it does that is drawback of system and those system people are not doctors and that is not ok and none agrees that its right to do so that is why Vardhan is shown as that man who does so and that is why he is villian. but as a doctor Dr Sid putting rich patients life in danger asking them to do extra surgeries to get money is wrong as a doctor. Not every rich gets money by birth.

angel_nonu thumbnail
Anniversary 8 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#23

So Dr Shashank said yesterday that what Ishani is doing is right and he would have also complained if he known what Sid does but today he was saying sorry to him on Ishani behalf, what for?

Sparklingstar22 thumbnail
Anniversary 5 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: angel_nonu

So Dr Shashank said yesterday that what Ishani is doing is right and he would have also complained if he known what Sid does but today he was saying sorry to him on Ishani behalf, what for?

I haven't watched today's episode yet, but heard that Ishani took the blame on herself. So I think he also thinks she is at fault and that's why he was asking forgiveness from Sid, because he thinks that he was falsely accused by Ishani.

angel_nonu thumbnail
Anniversary 8 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Sparklingstar22

I haven't watched today's episode yet, but heard that Ishani took the blame on herself. So I think he also thinks she is at fault and that's why he was asking forgiveness from Sid, because he thinks that he was falsely accused by Ishani.

No He knows that She is right and that video was proof. She told him yesterday but today was such a let down with him saying sorry to Sid 🙄

Gayathri_10 thumbnail
Anniversary 7 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Sparklingstar22

I haven't watched today's episode yet, but heard that Ishani took the blame on herself. So I think he also thinks she is at fault and that's why he was asking forgiveness from Sid, because he thinks that he was falsely accused by Ishani.

no i think the apology to sid is juz namesake in front of board members, for the inconvenience caused to him...

but whatever it was highly disappointing epi...

Sparklingstar22 thumbnail
Anniversary 5 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Gdbs

no i think the apology to sid is juz namesake in front of board members, for the inconvenience caused to him...

but whatever it was highly disappointing epi...

Bold: This can be a possibility. Hope he rebukes Sid for his actions tommorow.

wingnutx thumbnail
Anniversary 5 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#28

Hey, Okay I get it what doctor Sid is doing wrong and about the surgeries. I've almost lost my father because an doctor thought my father's body could handle back to back surgeries but that wasn't the case. So, okay suggesting the surgeries was wrong but doctors usually have a medical record of patients and know how much strain and surgeries a patient's body can handle now moving on I don't think we should expect logics from itv shows as from the starting of the show their were many illogical parts like doctors with open hairs even the medical students have hair tied down when they're in hospital premesis duty and secondly poor patients generally do avoid this private Richie rich hospitals with air conditioners and automatic doors. I have visited many such hospitals in my life and know where the Poor's lies in such hospital a small room with just two three beds known as emergency ward and crying and even their entrance is from the back door and not the front where automatic doors welcome the rich and with receptionist greeting them and let's not talk about the cases happening in this hospitals where the doctors keep the dead patients on ventilator and collect money from them, (let's not talk whether they were rich or middle class) as I've mentioned before poor generally avoided this hospitals and opt for govt hospitals. Okay, I'm getting of the topic here.

Coming back to the topic, I don't know what the writers are thinking they're giving a reason for Sid's grudge against the rich but at the same time they're showing everyone turning a blind eye to his actions and maybe the reason behind is his behaviour as in Dr. Rishabh's intro scene, he put the phone on airplane mode and acted as if on call and when an elderly ward boy greeted him he totally ignored him. So, I concluded he didn't respect those below him.

As we see the characters everyone is flawed and I don't know why characters just don't age up in these shows again going off topic. So, I'll mostly blame on writing then characters or maybe they're showing everyone's flaws before going on the track of correcting the said flaws and character progress and I think they destroyed Dr Shashank's character or essence as this is not the sweet yet strict doctor I remember who asked even his own daughters to call him doctor in hospital or maybe finally old age is catching up to him. Moving on I really hope they'll show some kind of common ground where the characters reflect on their wrong doings and deal with their guilt and emotions as an emotionally unstable doctor is like death of his patient's and all of them must have a point where they feel bad about what they do.

Moving on do you think even Dr Sid has some strong connections with Sanjivani like the way his mother told him to never leave Sanjivani even when he was sure he'll get job in any other hospital. His mother grimly said he must work in Sanjivani only, what do you think might be the reason behind it??

Top