He is doing great in his fun scenes and his work scenes. Only in emotional lacking a bit but no I don't think he is underperforming.
Just had one question? Are you same shally which we see in twitter? who loves to initiate bashing towards a person u know what I am talking about.
You can make a decent post than making such posts if u want to criticize
Originally posted by: shelly_22
I honestly feel Dr Sid is underperforming in front of DrIshani. Dr Ishani is a strong character and has many layers. She perfectly depicts all with ease and her camaradie with all her co-actors is amazing on-screen. Although I do get Anika feels during her banter scenes with Dr Sid, but thats that. Its only those scenes which are not randomly put but they are just executed wrongly and don't match up properly.
Dr. Sid however, isn;t that great with his acting. I get the fact that all praises are for him and none for Surbhi on twitter coz they're all dumb girls watching the show, not understanding medical terms, only looking at Dr sid'd hot-shot body and criticising Surbhi for her not-so stereotypical domicile sweet girl looks. Can someone please tell these dumb girls to understand the character and acting more than looks. Indeed the pairing is important but her character is flawed and not that MAHAAN unlike other stupid ITV girls.
But nonetheless, hater's gonna hate my post I don't care! Frankly both Dr Ishani and Dr Sid need to match their chemistry for the show to work. SO give them time to adjust with each other and the characters before judging as if you are so WISE!
by calling others stupid you are showing your stupidity.
This person I know very well guys and she loves to get SC bashed in name of acting as her fan. This post is taking personal digs on people so I request all to report like I did.
Strictly as an actor Namit has miles to match up with Surbhi especially emotional scenes, surbhi in initial three episodes lacked something but from episode four she has been on point, also if we see her scenes with others are organic & consistent flow while with Sid it's random scenes put together, & having watched SC for three years have to say the only scenes where SC doesn't give her 100% is when she can't connect to them, might as well be a flaw for someone.
But you shouldn't have called others dumb, tough I agree people are being unnecessarily harsh on SC & Ishani in name of healthy criticism & come up with tags like she's arrogant or harsh or ott as a defence statement instead of explaining why. The reason is majority feel Namit is an underdog who needs protection against ensemble of cast & SC in terms of popularity & that's why his mediocre acting skills & linear character sketch being hailed as something great & these are same people who r constantly putting down SC & Ishani as a mechanism to hail Namit for reasons best known to them & whose fans they are.
Strictly as an actor Namit has miles to match up with Surbhi especially emotional scenes, surbhi in initial three episodes lacked something but from episode four she has been on point, also if we see her scenes with others are organic & consistent flow while with Sid it's random scenes put together, & having watched SC for three years have to say the only scenes where SC doesn't give her 100% is when she can't connect to them, might as well be a flaw for someone.
But you shouldn't have called others dumb, tough I agree people are being unnecessarily harsh on SC & Ishani in name of healthy criticism & come up with tags like she's arrogant or harsh or ott as a defence statement instead of explaining why. The reason is majority feel Namit is an underdog who needs protection against ensemble of cast & SC in terms of popularity & that's why his mediocre acting skills & linear character sketch being hailed as something great & these are same people who r constantly putting down SC & Ishani as a mechanism to hail Namit for reasons best known to them & whose fans they are.
spot on 👍🏼
Even in first three episodes, Ishani scene when she gets coat was so beautiful, also with Vardhan, Anjali and shashank it was good. Only with Sid scenes were lacking something but then Sid-Ishani scenes itself felt abrupt random and as u said we have seen that when SC can't connect then we can see the difference so yeah it can be taken as flaw by peeps.
Totally agree on people being unnecessarily harsh on her for very different reasons they have and they will keep continuing this.
TM shouldn't have called others dumb. Give feedback in subtle way than taking personal dig at anyone be it fan or actors
I agree no any junior resident should do any surgery alone but this is not in case with ishani
Ishani only stabilize that child but she didn't not do any surgery of child because at that time ishani did not wearing gown cap and gloves . At that time she was wearing white coat. So Dr ishani wearing white coat in treating child that she means she didn't not do any surgery only stabilize him
She did first surgery under supervision of Dr sid. And Dr sid call her to assist surgery
Second surgery of that lady who have problem in abdominal. In that too ishani did not do surgery alone but under in super vision of Dr rishabh and Dr rishabh also did surgery of that lady alone with ishani as dr rishabh also wearing cap gown and cloth
And questions is that why Dr rishabh did not stop ishan in first placei doing surgery of that lady
I didn't not understand first rishabh allow Dr ishani to do surgery. Even himself did surgery of that lady with Dr ishani . And then scolded her
Dr rishabh should have stop ishani in first place in doing surgery of that lady
Dr ishani did both surgery under supervision of senior resident only
Dr ishani did tell her in calm in first place . But Dr aasha ignore her only that ishani get angry
And Dr aasha is adult. She did mbbs . She is educated how come she didn't not know any which color dustbin bin use for which purposeHere Dr aasha deliberately did wrong thing
Dr aasha has deliberately ignore and
break rules
Yes ishani should not ask Dr aashato pick garbage from dustbin and throw into another dustbin but Dr aasha was also at fault and nothing wrong in pointed out that mistakes
And Dr aasha is too staff of hospital
Originally posted by: surabhi01
I agree no any junior resident should do any surgery alone but this is not in case with ishani
Ishani only stabilize that child but she didn't not do any surgery of child because at that time ishani did not wearing gown cap and gloves . At that time she was wearing white coat. So Dr ishani wearing white coat in treating child that she means she didn't not do any surgery only stabilize him
She did first surgery under supervision of Dr sid. And Dr sid call her to assist surgery
Second surgery of that lady who have problem in abdominal. In that too ishani did not do surgery alone but under in super vision of Dr rishabh and Dr rishabh also did surgery of that lady alone with ishani as dr rishabh also wearing cap gown and cloth
And questions is that why Dr rishabh did not stop ishan in first placei doing surgery of that lady
I didn't not understand first rishabh allow Dr ishani to do surgery. Even himself did surgery of that lady with Dr ishani . And then scolded her
Dr rishabh should have stop ishani in first place in doing surgery of that lady
Dr ishani did both surgery under supervision of senior resident only
@bold: Even I did not understand that part. He did do surgery with her so if Ishani had arranged OT for surgery he could have denied then only rather than going ahead with it? but may be since patient was severe and OT was ready so he went ahead?
@ bold : sorry I don't agree. She was yelling. You might not agree wid me.....but dts your opinion.
Dr Asha didn't do it deliberately.....it was a genuine mistake. They don't even have color coded dustbin in that Sanjeevani. That was just dry and wet dustbin and dt too same colour......so what Dr Asha did was a genuine mistake.
Ishani could hv told her that calmly and told her to keep it in mind next time. She is her colleague not her senior.
all characters have their flaws. but I am wondering why only Ishani is getting this so called criticism lol.
Yesterday and today Dr Asha behavior was uncalled for but I hardly see people making reference to that.
Lastly there were many other scenes of Ishani other than this few second scene. But yeah its your opinion on not liking actress or her acting. Appreciate that you did not bodyshamed
Now dr Sid is an adorable character. Viewers will definitely like him. But namit really need to work on his skill to do emotional scenes.
Dr Ishani is shown as arrogant and viewers will take time to accept her . My only problem with surbhi is she need to play it subtle .
Now dr Sid is an adorable character. Viewers will definitely like him. But namit really need to work on his skill to do emotional scenes.
Dr Ishani is shown as arrogant and viewers will take time to accept her . My only problem with surbhi is she need to play it subtle .
the episodes we have seen in start were shot in mid of july, infact even before that and it takes atleast 1-2 episode to get into a character. I am not sure if she fits in your liking now but From episode 4 she has been really good and even in start episode except with Sid and Asha her scenes were quite ok specially that magzine one and with vardhan
comment:
p_commentcount