First Impressions!!!! - Page 3

Originally posted by: arshi_asya

I agree that hospital gives choice to the patient & treatment can't be stopped in midway but in cases like this, the surgery is shown in CSR records which every private orgnaization has to manage. What Sid did right there was strictly against medical ethics- suggesting random surgeries to his rich patient just for money. It was wrong on multiple grounds because with that they are trying to justify such malpractices in a certain way & last thing we need is such portrayal of doctors. They already have enough bad reputation in this country thanks to media highlighting such negatives every now & then.

I like the senior cast and I think junior cast will disappoint as much as senior cast will impress in upcoming episodes.

I guess we're on the same track so nothing more to add 👍🏼

This was on point👏! I have never watched Sanjivani or DMG so didn't expect anything, but 1 thing I was sure about and that is that they will make a mockery of doctor's profession. It is not only about this particular profession though. In daily soaps, they make a mockery of almost every profession that they take up. So I am expecting more of it and trying to ignore.😵 But Sid misguiding that lady and the childish bickering of the lead pair was a put off. Though I liked the episode as a whole.

Thats a very nice review dear, and the way Ishani can barge in between the doctors who are already treating a case and start handling her own treatment, ordering people around. The doctors surrounding her assisting her as if she was a consultant, just let me say this, if ever we did such a thing as a first year resident, we will face hell in real life. Also one thing that struck me odd was, shashank told sanjeevani is a govt. funded hospital, then why CFO is giving such a tough time to Sid and why Sid is taking illegal measures to arrange for surgery. He can easily speak with Shashank since its his patient and show that patient as one treated under funds. Atleast they should have shown some explanation to this, instead of showing doctors as two extremes. Because as I experienced my self , such things normally result in a lot of argument between management and doctors resulting in a lot of frustration.

Some points are realistic and a bit good more than what I expected from an Indian soap, like Sid cleaning the knife with alcohol, but would have been more better if he cleaned his hands and also surgical site.

also in second episode regarding the monitor of the second patient, after they resuscitated her how can her BP be suddenly 120/80 and her vitals normal, its really odd .... atleast show should consider blurring the monitors instead of making these mistakes. And dress code... I wonder i they took pointers from real doctors truly, because dress code is not at all followed . I wish they will correct these blunders so that it will be more authentic

Great analysis. Regarding the first two points then this is a Indian show yaha logic nahi chalta. People don't pay much attention to such things so CVs show whatever they can. Female doctors keep their hair open too except for the operation theatre.

Liked the characterisation so far except for the OTT reaction of Surbhi' character regarding the waste basket. It was annoying af.

Originally posted by: harianjana

Thats a very nice review dear, and the way Ishani can barge in between the doctors who are already treating a case and start handling her own treatment, ordering people around. The doctors surrounding her assisting her as if she was a consultant, just let me say this, if ever we did such a thing as a first year resident, we will face hell in real life. Also one thing that struck me odd was, shashank told sanjeevani is a govt. funded hospital, then why CFO is giving such a tough time to Sid and why Sid is taking illegal measures to arrange for surgery. He can easily speak with Shashank since its his patient and show that patient as one treated under funds. Atleast they should have shown some explanation to this, instead of showing doctors as two extremes. Because as I experienced my self , such things normally result in a lot of argument between management and doctors resulting in a lot of frustration.

Some points are realistic and a bit good more than what I expected from an Indian soap, like Sid cleaning the knife with alcohol, but would have been more better if he cleaned his hands and also surgical site.

also in second episode regarding the monitor of the second patient, after they resuscitated her how can her BP be suddenly 120/80 and her vitals normal, its really odd .... atleast show should consider blurring the monitors instead of making these mistakes. And dress code... I wonder i they took pointers from real doctors truly, because dress code is not at all followed . I wish they will correct these blunders so that it will be more authentic

Makers wanna take pride in saying it's a medical drama without paying attention to such intricacies. If one can't handle that then don't show it that way to do injustice.

There seems to be some inconsistency with Sashank & Vardaan's words. Maybe it's a semi-private hospital but they should pay attention to these details. What Sid did should not be glorified or justified in any way, no matter how noble his ulterior motives are.

I purposely ommitted what Ishani did there since she did not go into medicines & injection stuff & just limited herself to provide elect4ic blanket & UV lights. Otherwise, that would have invited het detention for a week for het stunt.

Originally posted by: MsChanadlerBong

Great analysis. Regarding the first two points then this is a Indian show yaha logic nahi chalta. People don't pay much attention to such things so CVs show whatever they can. Female doctors keep their hair open too except for the operation theatre.

Liked the characterisation so far except for the OTT reaction of Surbhi' character regarding the waste basket. It was annoying af.

Doctors rarely keep their hair open in hospital premises. They always keep them tied unless their hair are too short to bother them at all.

not going to details of medical procedures and their background. but I didn't like female lead. her ajeeb dressing sense and her OTT behavior didn't go so well👎🏼

I know one episode dekh kar aise conclusion pe aana galat hai. I hope she prove me wrong😳

Originally posted by: hasini009

not going to details of medical procedures and their background. but I didn't like female lead. her ajeeb dressing sense and her OTT behavior didn't go so well👎🏼

I know one episode dekh kar aise conclusion pe aana galat hai. I hope she prove me wrong😳

Same pìnch 😆

I deliberately didn't say this here as I don't know how many fans would pounce on me and I'm not prepared for this as I just saw her in 1 episode of her previous show that's all🤣

Nice to meet you here as well. Hope here our favourites match otherwise 🤣

Originally posted by: hasini009

not going to details of medical procedures and their background. but I didn't like female lead. her ajeeb dressing sense and her OTT behavior didn't go so well👎🏼

I know one episode dekh kar aise conclusion pe aana galat hai. I hope she prove me wrong😳

My only issue with the junior cast & leads is their characterization & acting as doctors. As long as characterization is good, I am fine with actors. I enjoyed Surbhi as mute Haya in QH. IB was unbearable for me because of OTT & so many villains.

The senior cast excels in that department. The subtlety they bring to their characters as doctors is great. Junior cast disappoints as a whole till now.

i have not idea about medical terms .. so cant comment on that .. but it is making me nostalgic every moments.. pls bring back arman ridima , atul , rahul , as dr juhi is here ..❤️

i like male lead.. but female lead reminding me another character , could not make connection with her still now.. hopefully 2-3 hapto mai ho jayegi ...

overall i am more interested in dr juhi , dr shashank , anjali right now... specially dr juhi , pls rahul ko bhi le aao 😭