daphli thumbnail
Group Promotion 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Dear Mr. Gajendra Singh,

I am very happy to address this to letter you. I always had a great regard for a talented and simple person like you for conceiving and presenting to us great shows like 'Antakshari' and 'SaReGaMaPa'(SRGMP).

Though surprised at the sudden demise of popular 'Antakshari' programme, of late I have the feeling that your SRGMP is becoming more and more a commercial and a farcical show.

I have listed out few points below for you think over.

Commercialisation: Today, your SRGMP show is commercialised to the core. It is very clear, no not just from the fact that you now drive a BMW, but from the way you are prolonging the show to get those extra SMSs and sponsorships, that you are now only focusing on making more money for your show and for your company, at the cost of talent. This is indeed sad.

Introduction of Mentors based system: Agree with you, that it was a good idea that you introduced this concept. It worked fine in the initial stages. But with the introduction of public voting, believe me Mr. Gajendra Singh, mentors are making a mockery of the system with their childishness, antics and buffoonery. If you are really serious about the SRGMP sequel to be popular and unbiased, you perhaps already know now, who you need to cull (word borrowed from the Avian Flu stories) out of the existing mentors.

Elimination of good singers: How we wish you had continued the earlier selection procedure of sticking to the revered and honourable judges to do the talent spotting? Because of unfair eliminations, today your SRGMP show is missing budding talents like – Nihira Joshi, Hema Chandra, Swananda, Sharib, Vishwanath, Himani, Raktima, etc.

Regionalisation: Intentionally or unintentionally, you have incited the issue of regionalization in the recent episodes. For heaven's sake you could have played it safer by not divulging the voting pattern by the region and stunts like including Madhya Pradesh in Western Zone (!?!). Do you think such tactics get you more votes? May be yes, but, unfortunately, you are doing an irreparable damage to your own country, my friend.

Programme format: Perhaps you already know yourself, deep down, that all is not well with the judgment being meted out to the budding singers through the public voting system. It is nothing new, Mr. Gajendra Singh, even Miss World competition also had the same issue, when best candidates were shown the door. We need to learn from such experiences and make necessary changes in the programme format to maintain fairness quotient of your show.

People's feedback: I am sure you are aware that popular programmes like yours do have people's feedback. Are you aware where to get them? No, not, definitely, from your cronies, yes you need to go to the intelligentsia. You need to employ agencies to do feedback polls for you. Or simply employ couple of guys to go through the India Forums, to notice the muck being dug out, in the recent days, on the show.

I don't know whether you will receive the same amount of patronage for your next show or not, but you, definitely, have lost one die-hard fan of SRGMP, i.e. me.

Good luck to you and your team….

daphli

_______________________________________

Dear fellow members,

After receiving further comments from you all, I intend to take a printout and courier it to Mr. Gajendra Singh. So, this is your chance to provide all your comments feedback.

Edited by daphli - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

1.9k

Users

12

Frequent Posters

musicpulse thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Good post and good points. πŸ‘πŸΌ
soulsoup thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
πŸ‘ - Mind Blowing Post.
But is it possible now to get back the original format? Return to innocence?
Itna paisa Zee ko kahase milega?? 😭 😭
desimam thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
πŸ‘
well said. agree completly
apparaohoare thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

πŸ‘

Excellent Post.

Edited by apparaohoare - 18 years ago
daphli thumbnail
Group Promotion 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: MrspetloverUS

And I second that opinion. i totally agree with you Monchau.

MPLji, are you sure??? I thought you too are sick of HR's antics????? very confusing yaar..............

daphli thumbnail
Group Promotion 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: monchau

daphli, if u remove that HR comment, i will surely comment somethin good about it 😊
cuz it isnt HR who started it.. go and see all those shows in AS and jatin lalit behaved in sucha degradin manner that HR had to act the way he is now.
havent u looked at the latest episodes? havent u seen what ID has been doing? all cheap tactics

so be fair.

monchau, I agree with you on AS, JL and ID. They did their foolish acts and if you see in these forums....I have derided them too...many many times....in fact there were shows, where I felt HR was the only sane, decent person...but unfortunately in the later shows, he turned out to be totally different and I was most upset with him when he said 'mind blowing' when the aunty in the crowd shouted a regionalistic comment 'we are looking for india's voice not assam's voice'....as mentor don't you think he should not incite regional sentiments by openly siding with such a stupid comment? I leave these thoughts with you now...god bless you...

mojazwal thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Hello dalphi. Thanks for posting this! I think this is a great idea to give feedback on the format of the show itself - better than asking X mentor to be removed, etc. Just a suggestion, in the same vein as monchau and Mrs.PetLover - I too think it might make your letter more effective if you did not dwell on or single out just Himesh Reshammiya. I can't stand the guy, but I think everyone is now well-aware of the backlash he has received, and pointing out stuff about HR takes away from the other excellent points you have made. Anyhow, I hope more people take the effort to do what you are doing. We need to let GS know that he is going to lose substantial viewership in the long run if he keeps up this reality show nonsense.

Edited by mojazwal - 18 years ago
soni28 thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
agree with u on all points daphli (esp. on the cull part!)
Edited by soni28 - 18 years ago
saum_Bangalore thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Daphli.

I dont think "Tit for Tat" policy does not fit in here. You can't appreciate What HR had been doing in the recent rounds, similarly if ID is following his footstep then it is really very bad.

Isn't there a thought somewhere in your mind that this whole program has been fixed since the final 12 started?
😭
Top