Sab filmy naatak hai...Not Fair.. - Page 3

Originally posted by: set_raj

Summer you know the reason, I think last month when Bisakh was about to be eliminated, Sajid raised the question that are we going to be out of show also, since our last singer is being eliminated?...and next moment Bisakh jyoti was saved and other good singer was out...so it clearly understood that this is all planned show...who has seen the voting or the votes are counted in public?...it is just an eye-wash...😆😆 Look at DID also...same script...Zee wants all the judges and contestants from every group till final... Sugandha was top performer and next week she is eliminated?...all of sudden such a drastic fall in voting?...this should go in GUINNESS Book.👏

This is normal trend on Zee. It happens with Alisher too, he was highest vote getter a week before elimination.

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

I completely lost my interest in the finale. My last favorite Sugandha is out. She is very talented girl, I loved her classical, old songs. She just need to do one thing, she needs to give her voice an identity. She is very hard working.

HB it was understood that VS has two singers from their team..so it was their turn to sacrifice one of them...Bisakh is alone since last month in SW team....so Zee is just making mentors happy...they dont care about singers...they want higher TRP's which i dont think they can get next year...

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

Everything is manipulated. For last 3 years they had 4 group of judges and 3 finalists so one judge was being deprived of place on stage in finale, so they change the format and brought 3 group of judges so they can distribute finalist equally and give equal opportunity to all judges to be on stage. Good job Zee.

SRGMP was best during Sonu Nigam's time...it was Genuine reality show and later Shaan also handled very well, but since last five years the standard has gone down...now this will go on every year...

Originally posted by: set_raj

SRGMP was best during Sonu Nigam's time...it was Genuine reality show and later Shaan also handled very well, but since last five years the standard has gone down...now this will go on every year...

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

There were some very strong points this year, singers were much superios than last year. singers were given opportunity to stick to their strength, judges were supportive to each other and behaved well. They had differences sometime but handled it perfectly. We listen some golden era songs which no one attempted in past. Halla Bol songs were discouraged. From singers and singing point of view I can put this year at par with 2007. we got opportunity to see other side of Daler paa ji, he is a class ghazal singer. But as judge he was the worst, he did not give a single comment on singing or music.

Agreed this year singers were much much better, Sajid was too irritating in the begining, as every now and thn he used to hug all the female contestant...I think seeing public displeasure he mend his ways and most of time saw him sitting on his hot seat...😆

Originally posted by: set_raj

Agreed this year singers were much much better, Sajid was too irritating in the begining, as every now and thn he used to hug all the female contestant...I think seeing public displeasure he mend his ways and most of time saw him sitting on his hot seat...😆

DM showed that he is a ud classical singer but as a judge he was total failure.maybe he is not fluent in hindi that cud be a reason...Vishal was not good either...it was only Wajid and Shekhar who used to explain in details....on the whole below average show...

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc

😊 Agreed.......This season was below average.......the ratings clearly show that this season didn't connect with the audience........The judges were quite lacking when it comes to actual judging.....I mean this season the judges spent the maximum amount of time on stage.....At times it was like they were competing..........😊 The singers overall were quite okay, but not like C 05 and 07......The only one I really liked were Sugandha, and Ranjeet, and Rini......😊

It really dint connected at all...well we can say judges spent more time than singers..bechare singers...kya kar sakte hai...Ranjeet should have been in finals instead of Bisakh...but his fault was he never tried to sing other songs...he shud have tried singing other songs and shown his range....maybe this is the reason he was eliminated..

We should stop whinning. Common everybody know that Sughandha will be eliminated this week. No way Zee gonna take two finalist from one Gharana. Sughandha is my fav contestant this year but I dont wanna cry foul and keep on whinning. Let it go and wish all the best to her. IMO Sugandha is the best contestant in this years competetion. She can sing any kind of song from pure classical to soft number. But in Sa re ga ma pa , fate is decided by Zee and that has been happening every year. Anyway winning does not guarantee success. She has already been recocnized and hope she will be used by music directors.

Chalo another one bites the dust...

Yes what a waste. VS had to select between Kamal n Sugandha. Must have been very difficult.