Female singers on saregamapa - Page 2

Originally posted by: mdroy

This year's female singers were weak. Sugandha or Sniti would have been great this season.

Girls were very weak, Madhuri was good among girls but comparing with male counterparts she did not have any identity in respect of singing. Jasraj has his identity, MA is mahaan, Shehnaaz, Jazim all are great in their genre. In which genre Madhuri was great? None... I know naari jaati agar sankat mein ayee to purush zimmedaar... I accept still women all over world are treated badly... but we cannot say that happend in this show... It is voting based show.. ab naari naari ko vote na kare to kaya kahna... I think Naari hi Naari ki bari dushman hai...

Originally posted by: April2007

May be, but I found Maduri Day very good, her song "kaha aa gaye" was outstanding..she was demoralized by being voted in bottom three many times..almost in each and very episode, I think the judges were overly critical of her singing. I didn't think the judges were fair in this instance.

I find it strange that out of thousands of girls who auditioned for the show, they couldn'f find many outstanding singers. Bollywood has outstanding female singers..no male can sing better than Lataji and now Sherya is very very good..the song ,teri meri' is good due to her, Rehat Ali with is rough voice killed the song.

For future they have to design the shows in such a way that half and half female ratio is maintained..both the genders bring different skills on the table and one cannot replace other. If the format is not changed to ensure gender equality many viewwers like me wouldn't watch the show..

I don't enjoy or even will watch the show that doesn't have gender balance. ..male judges and male singer can enjoy each other and jump up and down to support each other..there is nothing for females to see as role model, or aspire up to..

Originally posted by: JasToronto

and Vishvjeet are good singers.</font>[/DIV]

<font color="#6600cc" size="2" face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">Bottom line Flop show, Bias Judges total failure of sa re ga ma pa.</font>

[/DIV]

Thanks Jas ji for agreeing with me..

Thousands of girls came to audition. I find it very hard to believe that they couldn't find as many good girls as boys for the show. The show is completely male based. The judges are male and so are the majority of the contestants.

It appears that the show is conducted for the enjoyment of the judges. They like pure classical and that is what they keep praising. MS is good but how many Indians listen to pure classical.
I have stopped watching this show because I don't enjoy all males thumping each other at the back and trying to get cheap publicity.

Unless the format of the show is changed, girls should stop auditioning, no point in being insulted by bunch of males.

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

Girls were very weak, Madhuri was good among girls but comparing with male counterparts she did not have any identity in respect of singing. Jasraj has his identity, MA is mahaan, Shehnaaz, Jazim all are great in their genre. In which genre Madhuri was great? None... I know naari jaati agar sankat mein ayee to purush zimmedaar... I accept still women all over world are treated badly... but we cannot say that happend in this show... It is voting based show.. ab naari naari ko vote na kare to kaya kahna... I think Naari hi Naari ki bari dushman hai...

Why didn't they choose very strong girls, there were thousands of them auditioning for the show. Read Jaspal's note Shanker already knew Jasraj.

I personally find Jasraj very repetitive (every song he sings is same) and pretty boring.
Even MS is very same, the same kind of raga, I don't think he can sing folk songs or light music. He sings all the songs in very similar fashion. This is not about treatment of the women but about fairness, nobody can convince me that their are no good women singer, only male can sing. I have not seen a single male beat Lataji, even Sherya are way better than many male singers. In my opinion no male can beat Lata Mangeshkar.

Girls sing different songs than males, they have different genre and no show is complete with just one gender singing for one hour. I don't want to hear one male song after other and male judges going out of control praising them ...horrible flop show. Bunch of male judges just choose male contestants and having fun in their own little world. After Renu was pushed out, I have stopped watching the show.

Not choosing right girl singers is judges fault they cannot convince me that good female singers don't exist. Vashali is one of the best singers I have listened to on saregamapa..

Since females and males sing at a different scale, have a different pitch etc etc, best would be to have an all female or a all male music show with so called judges of the same gender, running simultaneously on the same channel, so that viewers have the the option of watching whatever suits them.😳

Originally posted by: April2007

Why didn't they choose very strong girls, there were thousands of them auditioning for the show. Read Jaspal's note Shanker already knew Jasraj.

I personally find Jasraj very repetitive (every song he sings is same) and pretty boring.
Even MS is very same, the same kind of raga, I don't think he can sing folk songs or light music. He sings all the songs in very similar fashion. This is not about treatment of the women but about fairness, nobody can convince me that their are no good women singer, only male can sing. I have not seen a single male beat Lataji, even Sherya are way better than many male singers. In my opinion no male can beat Lata Mangeshkar.

Girls sing different songs than males, they have different genre and no show is complete with just one gender singing for one hour. I don't want to hear one male song after other and male judges going out of control praising them ...horrible flop show. Bunch of male judges just choose male contestants and having fun in their own little world. After Renu was pushed out, I have stopped watching the show.

Not choosing right girl singers is judges fault they cannot convince me that good female singers don't exist. Vashali is one of the best singers I have listened to on saregamapa..

Originally posted by: April2007

Why didn't they choose very strong girls, there were thousands of them auditioning for the show. Read Jaspal's note Shanker already knew Jasraj.

I personally find Jasraj very repetitive (every song he sings is same) and pretty boring.
Even MS is very same, the same kind of raga, I don't think he can sing folk songs or light music. He sings all the songs in very similar fashion. This is not about treatment of the women but about fairness, nobody can convince me that their are no good women singer, only male can sing. I have not seen a single male beat Lataji, even Sherya are way better than many male singers. In my opinion no male can beat Lata Mangeshkar.

Girls sing different songs than males, they have different genre and no show is complete with just one gender singing for one hour. I don't want to hear one male song after other and male judges going out of control praising them ...horrible flop show. Bunch of male judges just choose male contestants and having fun in their own little world. After Renu was pushed out, I have stopped watching the show.

Not choosing right girl singers is judges fault they cannot convince me that good female singers don't exist. Vashali is one of the best singers I have listened to on saregamapa..

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

I dont understand one thing, should we talk about Lata, Shreya and established male singer or contestants from this year or contestants from previous year... Vaishali was talented so she won. And about Lata, Shreya etc, talking about them in these reality show is simply disrespectful to legendary singers and injustice to these kids who are trying to plant their feet in singing...

If I look at this year crop, there was not a single female singer who should be in top 3-4 finalists, not a single female voice... If Zee goes with at least, we have been first person to rile Zee, now they are not applied quota system, then we should appreciate their effort. I understand your point show can not be complete without female and male both voices... but this is singing competion not the show.

Lataji and Sherya were mentioned to establish that women are very good singers. as good as male singer and even better. since 50 percent of population is male and other 50 percent male. I find it very hard to believe that all top six are male, rest of the 50 percent will need quota system to have fair representation.

I personally think the show is slated in favor of male singers. Unknowingly or knowingly all the 5 judges are male, and the judges love to show off their own talent and sing at the drop of hat. It seems that judges are promoting themselves. Somehow the judges seem to like male singers more than female, even during auditioning more male were chosen than female.

The viewers can clearly see that the judges start acting differently when camera falls on them.

Originally posted by: music-a-muse

Word Count: 0