SBS ' Razia Sultan might be pulled off air' - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

3k

Users

10

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

overactor thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: RheaSingh

well if people are watching this show for actors rather than the story, then i guess there's no point of watching it from story's perspective, they would be happy to get whatever gets served to them lol

good this show is taking down, when they were promoting it, i said on their fb page that this show will be a huge flop and it came out true

Its not a flop for stories there r story books available movies and shows r for entertainment not story reading even novel based films r altered and this is history about which no1 is sure if u hate the show so much what r u doing here๐Ÿ˜•
..radiance... thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: RheaSingh

I have gotten enough comics, and books on Razia Sultan she is one of my favourite historical heroines. sadly enough the show hasn't done justice to her braveura, it's really sad, i believe the doordarshan series that telecasted the historical heroes back then were far much better. i was like 5 then but later my father showed those recordings and razia's life was beautifully depicted in that. total to the point and no nonsense like these dramas,

even the film starring hema malini was a let down, romance b/w her and yaqut what were the makers thinking. also Pankhuri Awasthi isn't perfect to play razia somehow she carries the typical indian TV woman's vibes and should be suitably suited for such things. also the plot twists, razia showing robinhood, this and that illogical focus on shah turkan, disappointed me big time,

if this series was supposed to be a mini one, then its evne more disappointing that they haven't stuck to the story at all... AND RAZIA'S story began when she became the sultan, it didn't end with it, she had to face a lot of problems as her subjects were sexiest towards her, she waged a lot of battles and won too and later how she was betrayed and killed with altunia, damn i still have the comics...true razia lovers should read those from amar chitra katha it's far valuable than this boring drama seriously.


I hv seen a portn of d series bt its really nothing compard 2 d serial !
It seems lik u don't know abt real Razia much evn aftr so much comics n shows .!! Razia had a child in her heart but was a fearless warrior who would do anythng 4 her family n people undr her. Pankhuri is portrying Razia perfectly without any flaw.
N story ki jahan tak baat hai its great!! As u r saying it seems lik u expct a biography on milkha singh 2 start from d portion where he won d race rather than from his training n motivational sources.. Its a horrible idea of yours!!
No Offence meant by d way! Though u should stop commentng without giving it a thought
RheaSingh thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: ..radiance...


I hv seen a portn of d series bt its really nothing compard 2 d serial !
It seems lik u don't know abt real Razia much evn aftr so much comics n shows .!! Razia had a child in her heart but was a fearless warrior who would do anythng 4 her family n people undr her. Pankhuri is portrying Razia perfectly without any flaw.
N story ki jahan tak baat hai its great!! As u r saying it seems lik u expct a biography on milkha singh 2 start from d portion where he won d race rather than from his training n motivational sources.. Its a horrible idea of yours!!
No Offence meant by d way! Though u should stop commentng without giving it a thought


LOL i don't have to...the show is gonna off air soon and it tells everything else ๐Ÿ˜† and for the record. it's not a fan club ! its a discussion forum i haven't stepped into a fanclub or an appreciation thread. i entered a thread which says the show is about to go off air, and there are several news on google too. i personally don't like the show and i hv full right to say it so, m not forcing u guys, so why r u getting so affected by it lol
overactor thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#24
U should read the whole post the show isn't going off air as the dialogue wriyer confirmed these news r jusg plain rumors and who is forcing u to like it never seen some1 so desperate to write negative comments on a show they dnt like bht farig time he aapke paas๐Ÿ˜Š
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: RheaSingh

I have gotten enough comics, and books on Razia Sultan she is one of my favourite historical heroines. sadly enough the show hasn't done justice to her braveura, it's really sad, i believe the doordarshan series that telecasted the historical heroes back then were far much better. i was like 5 then but later my father showed those recordings and razia's life was beautifully depicted in that. total to the point and no nonsense like these dramas,

even the film starring hema malini was a let down, romance b/w her and yaqut what were the makers thinking. also Pankhuri Awasthi isn't perfect to play razia somehow she carries the typical indian TV woman's vibes and should be suitably suited for such things. also the plot twists, razia showing robinhood, this and that illogical focus on shah turkan, disappointed me big time,

if this series was supposed to be a mini one, then its evne more disappointing that they haven't stuck to the story at all... AND RAZIA'S story began when she became the sultan, it didn't end with it, she had to face a lot of problems as her subjects were sexiest towards her, she waged a lot of battles and won too and later how she was betrayed and killed with altunia, damn i still have the comics...true razia lovers should read those from amar chitra katha it's far valuable than this boring drama seriously.

When you are watching a historical show and that too on Indian TV,you have to prepare yourself for minor and major distortions.No historical show or movie can manage without twisting the facts a bit.I know that this show has deviated a lot from actual history but to be frank I am watching it for the actors who are doing their parts brilliantly and the fine execution by Swastik.
I disagree with your views on Pankhuri's acting.Pankhuri is portraying the character of a girl who grows up to be a matured and responsible woman.Razia was not the stern Sultan from the beginning.The change happened slowly and steadily.She evolved,learnt from the circumstances and eventually became Razia Sultan.The CVs have tried to show both the aspects of Razia's personality and Pankhuri is doing it fabulously.

About the drama and the twists and turns,well,as I have said earlier,drama is necessary for the viewers to enjoy the show.This is a TV show and not a documentary.About the distortions well many historical shows had major distortions.

CGM prolonged Alexander's stay in India and even showed that Chankya's tactics may have been the cause of Alexander's retreat.

JA depicted Ruqaiya Sultan Begum as a vamp which she was not.However,it is Ekta's show and Ekta's shows are never complete without saas-bahu and vamps.They even went to the extent of showing witches and ghosts.

MP depicted Emperor Akbar as a villain and showed a love triangle between MP and his two wives Ajabdeh and Phool.They also showed a brief meeting between MP and Akbar in their childhood and Akbar falling for Phool.This is completely inaccurate.

CAS is the master of distortions.They turned CGM's wife Cornelia/Helena into a vamp,depicted the historically non-existent love between Bindusar and Dharma and gave the show a touch of Game Of Thrones.



Inspite of these distortions,all these shows were successful and liked by a majority of the viewers.Why???? Because they were entertaining and the acting was appreciated.Many viewers have accepted the fact that historicals tend to deviate from history and watched it purely for entertainment.

RS too has distorted the facts but I did not find a single track boring apart from the Yaldoz track.The leads have an awesome chemistry which is the USP of the show.

About Shah Turkan,well,she was a cruel character in history and here there is nothing wrong if she is portrayed as a villain in Razia's life.Sambhavna Seth's acting adds to the charm of the show.








..radiance... thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: RheaSingh



LOL i don't have to...the show is gonna off air soon and it tells everything else ๐Ÿ˜† and for the record. it's not a fan club ! its a discussion forum i haven't stepped into a fanclub or an appreciation thread. i entered a thread which says the show is about to go off air, and there are several news on google too. i personally don't like the show and i hv full right to say it so, m not forcing u guys, so why r u getting so affected by it lol


girl, u must know ki rumours r a part of this industry. D writer himslf cnfirmd its all a crap so sorry 2 break d dream bt its not ending.
N chahe discusn thread ho ya fanclub , India forum does nt allow any. -ve commnt about actors, show, peopl relatd with it or d membrs. U can always check it on d site!!
N ya one last thing there is a HUGE difference betwn voicing ur opinion n insulting smthing !!!!
overactor thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#27
Rs is still better then many historical jokes going around ๐Ÿ˜† for history ppl should read history books cause shows r for entertaintment not knowledge increase
overactor thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Astoria

When you are watching a historical show and that too on Indian TV,you have to prepare yourself for minor and major distortions.No historical show or movie can manage without twisting the facts a bit.I know that this show has deviated a lot from actual history but to be frank I am watching it for the actors who are doing their parts brilliantly and the fine execution by Swastik.

I disagree with your views on Pankhuri's acting.Pankhuri is portraying the character of a girl who grows up to be a matured and responsible woman.Razia was not the stern Sultan from the beginning.The change happened slowly and steadily.She evolved,learnt from the circumstances and eventually became Razia Sultan.The CVs have tried to show both the aspects of Razia's personality and Pankhuri is doing it fabulously.

About the drama and the twists and turns,well,as I have said earlier,drama is necessary for the viewers to enjoy the show.This is a TV show and not a documentary.About the distortions well many historical shows had major distortions.

CGM prolonged Alexander's stay in India and even showed that Chankya's tactics may have been the cause of Alexander's retreat.

JA depicted Ruqaiya Sultan Begum as a vamp which she was not.However,it is Ekta's show and Ekta's shows are never complete without saas-bahu and vamps.They even went to the extent of showing witches and ghosts.

MP depicted Emperor Akbar as a villain and showed a love triangle between MP and his two wives Ajabdeh and Phool.They also showed a brief meeting between MP and Akbar in their childhood and Akbar falling for Phool.This is completely inaccurate.

CAS is the master of distortions.They turned CGM's wife Cornelia/Helena into a vamp,depicted the historically non-existent love between Bindusar and Dharma and gave the show a touch of Game Of Thrones.



Inspite of these distortions,all these shows were successful and liked by a majority of the viewers.Why???? Because they were entertaining and the acting was appreciated.Many viewers have accepted the fact that historicals tend to deviate from history and watched it purely for entertainment.

RS too has distorted the facts but I did not find a single track boring apart from the Yaldoz track.The leads have an awesome chemistry which is the USP of the show.

About Shah Turkan,well,she was a cruel character in history and here there is nothing wrong if she is portrayed as a villain in Razia's life.Sambhavna Seth's acting adds to the charm of the show.

Bang on ash โญ๏ธ and shah turkan was a vamp in real too, she was pure evil even more then the show's turkan๐Ÿ˜† maybe comics didn't mention that ๐Ÿค” im not sure if batman superman spiderman movies r based on comics or not ๐Ÿ˜Š
Top